This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This section is for the other party to add any issues that are not included above. User bullet points to add additional issues. This is not a response to the issues set out above, nor is it an opportunity to make a statment of the party's opinion, describe another user's actions, or state the history of the dispute. Only issues are to be added; as above, commentary on persons, rather than issues, will be removed by a member of the Mediation Committee. Excessive or spurrious commentary will also be removed. (Once again, only committee members may remove text from the RfM page.)
Each party should provide the issues to be mediated in a separate section; if there are three parties, then there should be three "issue" sections. Editing of another party's section is not allowed. If any party does not agree to mediate, it is not necessary to fill out these sections; simply indicate "Do not agree" and sign in the section below. If any party refuses to mediate, then the mediation will be automatically rejected.
Only signatures should go here, along with either "Agree" or "Do not agree." Any additional comments will be removed by a member of the Mediation Committee.
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
Agree ArielS 16:58, 2 October 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
Gary Chapman Bonnie Jo Chapman Cecily_Chapman/ Cecily_Barmore Abbie Mae Chapman Lyssa Chapman They were delited by Saxifrage ( talk · contribs)
There was no discusion by other user involved with this.
I created several articles of the children of Duane Chapman and Beth Smith. How come there deleted. Anybody that is currently in a TV show and has en IMDB entry is worthwhile to have article created on.
They were deleted them before there can be a discussion done on them by other users. I think that other user should give their opinion discus/debate before they are deleted.
-- Jessica93 00:35, 10 November 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
*Agree --
Doc Tropics
Message in a bottle 03:16, 31 October 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
None (other than informal discussion in Shell Kinney's talk page)
(bold type is mine to emphasize the contradictions with Shell Kenney's warn).
(a "no relevance" resolution)
So I asked the warn removed or at least clearly reviewed, as the different administrators had resolved different things. But Shell Kinney archived/removed the case without allowing more time for it and without a clear resolution. I protested that was hiding the dirt under the rug but got no replies. I also protested at her talk page but we only talked in circles.
My request is that the case is reopened until the warn is reviewed (this does not mean necessarily removed, just reviewed consistently) and that a clear resolution is issued.
Note: I fear that this mishandled case gave air to Thulean to keep wikilawyering against other editors who opposed his views, with or without reason. It also made me (and possibly other serious wikipedians) to feel gagged. At some point I had to recuse myself from the mediation cabal because I felt I could hardly express my opinions being under (apparent, unclear) warn and therefore danger of block.
-- Sugaar 17:52, 11 November 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This section is for the other party to add any issues that are not included above. User bullet points to add additional issues. This is not a response to the issues set out above, nor is it an opportunity to make a statment of the party's opinion, describe another user's actions, or state the history of the dispute. Only issues are to be added; as above, commentary on persons, rather than issues, will be removed by a member of the Mediation Committee. Excessive or spurrious commentary will also be removed. (Once again, only committee members may remove text from the RfM page.)
Each party should provide the issues to be mediated in a separate section; if there are three parties, then there should be three "issue" sections. Editing of another party's section is not allowed. If any party does not agree to mediate, it is not necessary to fill out these sections; simply indicate "Do not agree" and sign in the section below. If any party refuses to mediate, then the mediation will be automatically rejected.
Only signatures should go here, along with either "Agree" or "Do not agree." Any additional comments will be removed by a member of the Mediation Committee.
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
Agree ArielS 16:58, 2 October 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
Gary Chapman Bonnie Jo Chapman Cecily_Chapman/ Cecily_Barmore Abbie Mae Chapman Lyssa Chapman They were delited by Saxifrage ( talk · contribs)
There was no discusion by other user involved with this.
I created several articles of the children of Duane Chapman and Beth Smith. How come there deleted. Anybody that is currently in a TV show and has en IMDB entry is worthwhile to have article created on.
They were deleted them before there can be a discussion done on them by other users. I think that other user should give their opinion discus/debate before they are deleted.
-- Jessica93 00:35, 10 November 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
*Agree --
Doc Tropics
Message in a bottle 03:16, 31 October 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
None (other than informal discussion in Shell Kinney's talk page)
(bold type is mine to emphasize the contradictions with Shell Kenney's warn).
(a "no relevance" resolution)
So I asked the warn removed or at least clearly reviewed, as the different administrators had resolved different things. But Shell Kinney archived/removed the case without allowing more time for it and without a clear resolution. I protested that was hiding the dirt under the rug but got no replies. I also protested at her talk page but we only talked in circles.
My request is that the case is reopened until the warn is reviewed (this does not mean necessarily removed, just reviewed consistently) and that a clear resolution is issued.
Note: I fear that this mishandled case gave air to Thulean to keep wikilawyering against other editors who opposed his views, with or without reason. It also made me (and possibly other serious wikipedians) to feel gagged. At some point I had to recuse myself from the mediation cabal because I felt I could hardly express my opinions being under (apparent, unclear) warn and therefore danger of block.
-- Sugaar 17:52, 11 November 2006 (UTC)
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |
This is a hard copy of a request for mediation which was rejected by the Mediation Committee. Rejected requests are substituted to these archives of rejected requests, then deleted. Please do not remove this tag or edit this request for any reason. To request mediation of this dispute, please submit a new request. |