This is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
Archive 10 | ← | Archive 14 | Archive 15 | Archive 16 | Archive 17 | Archive 18 | → | Archive 20 |
I'm using theses sites as references on Razer Naga, but I'd like confirmation that they're reliable. -- Anarchyte ( work | talk) 11:52, 28 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Nintendo Everything" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Just another Nintendo-focused website that needs to be vetted. Saw it be used on different articles so it would be helpful to see other peoples take on it. GamerPro64 18:50, 31 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Hardcore Gaming 101" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I understand this website has been brought up before, but can we establish the site as a completely reputable source instead of conditional? The site's head editor Kurt Kalata, has already been proven to be a reliable source and fact checks all submissions. From the about page: All submitted articles are subject to fact checking and editing by staff. Contributors should nonetheless always strife to write as accurately and fairly as possible. We reserve the option to not publish any submitted articles for content, completion or quality concerns. We'll always write back to discuss whatever improvements may be necessary to bring it up to standards. In addition to this, many site articles have been published in physical format in the "Hardcore Gaming 101" series of books, also run by Kalata. This website is a tremendous source of information for older more obscure games. Thoughts? I just can't believe that this site is yellow and that garbage website Kotaku is green. TarkusAB 02:29, 23 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Power Up Gaming" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I think that this is an unreliable source because I can not find policies concerning ethics and credentials, but I want to double-check just to be sure.
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 02:45, 4 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Shmuplations" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Hey guys, I want to send an email to the site owner, but I'm having trouble figuring out exactly what I'm trying to ask. As you may or may not know, this guy translates interviews from old Japanese publications to English. My main issue with the site is he often doesn't say WHERE he got the interview from. For example, there's a great interview about Ikaruga on there, but it only says it's an interview with Masato Maegawa from 2001, no source mentioned.
Ultimately, I think determining the quality of the translator's skill is not important. It's no different from me opening an old Famicom issue, and translating it as I write it into Wikipedia. Many editors don't have English as their primary language too. That is why we source, so that if other editors doubt information, they can go to the source and check it themselves and verify. Given the amount of work and effort put into the website, I think we can safely say he doesn't have malicious intent.
So is it really the reliability of Shmuplations we are looking for here? Honestly, I think if he sources back to the original source (issue number and everything), than I say use his translations all you want, just footnote the ORIGINAL source he listed into wiki. I was going to send him an email to suggest to start putting that information in more often. What do you think? And I mean hey if we determine shmuplations itself is reliable, I won't complain :) TarkusAB 23:52, 3 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "The Washington Times" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Recently, I have told Steam users in the forums that something bad was going to happen to the Internet, and I have used this source, The Washington Times (Yes, they do cover video game subjects as well.), but they say that it will not happen, and two of them said that The Washington Times is a "fearmongering tabloid with no credibility whatsoever". However, I think that they are lying (simply because the newspaper is conservative), and I want to know whether this is a good source to use to cover video game subjects.
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 02:37, 16 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Pocket Tactics" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Noticed this at the bottom of the Wargamer page. Seems they're both owned by Slitherine Software and, according to their about page, they're on Metacritic. Of course that doesn't mean it'll be considered reliable here automatically. So what does everyone else thing of the website? GamerPro64 23:32, 25 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Millenium Portail" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
http://www.millenium.org/, French gaming and eSports website.-- Prisencolin ( talk) 04:44, 26 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "The Escapist" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
The site has been rather turbulent since that one event in 2014 took the gaming world by storm. Between replacing or firing most all of its staff, axing its office and generally just not being discussed in my circles, is it still considered a reliable source for news an opinions? I went for a quick look and the editorial policy doesn't seem to exist, but I did find an ethics policy. The drama surrounding Star Citizen shows that oversight is weak and since then it doesn't seem to have gotten better. Alex's questionable statements also do not bode well for reliability (or a sort of neutral stance). For the sake of making this easy, let's ignore Zero Punctuation.
Are we sure we want to keep this as reliable? Zero Serenity ( talk - contributions) 21:04, 27 September 2016 (UTC)
The Escapist hasn't changed its policies, and staff turnover shouldn't matter as long as their policies remain in place. An individual piece here or there with errors in it is something that happens to pretty much everybody at one point or another. — Torchiest talk edits 17:24, 30 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Classic Game Room" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Is Classic Game Room a reliable source? I was searching for sources about
Star Wars: Jedi Arena, and I have stumbled upon this source, but I am thinking that it is just a fan website with no credentials (I cannot find its policies).
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 18:09, 21 October 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Let's Play Video Games" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This site recently came up in a discussion at Talk:Nintendo Switch, and I don't see the site listed anywhere here, including the archives. If it turns out not to be VGRS and non-credible rumors keep coming out of it, we should have something to point to if we have to remove it from Nintendo Switch. Is this site reliable or not? — Gestrid ( talk) 05:56, 28 October 2016 (UTC)
If I remember correctly the founders of this website used to be part of Destructoid but got laid off a couple months ago. That said, it doesn't mean the site is automatically reliable. I don't see any policies stated on the site so that's a red flag right there. So I'm unsure about this source. GamerPro64 17:59, 30 October 2016 (UTC)
I know that EventHubs and SRK are unreliable, but what do you people think of the following sites?
As for unreliable sources, I would like to point out that SmashBoards which is an unreliable source, uses XenForo to function. Notably Test Your Might, 8WayRun, Skullheart, FreeStepDodge and VFDC also share this trait.
So what's your thoughts on my six sources that are on here? ULTRA-DARKNESS :) 2 CHAT 13:41, 7 October 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Quarter To Three" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I've heard of this website before but don't think there's ever been consensus of use here. The site is run by Tom Chick, who has freelanced for multiple websites that have been deemed reliable here. GamerPro64 18:56, 4 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Gamerant.com" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR · free images · free news sources · TWL · NYT · WP reference · VG/RS · VG/RL · WPVG/Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This one has been discussed twice in the past, but without much input either time. Was hoping to get a solid word on it this time. They have an about page, but there's just two people listed as dedicated staff, and neither seem to have any credentials other than "being video game enthusiasts" and writing for GameRant. One has a college degree, but its in Film, so not particularly helpful. Other contributors don't have any info listed at all other than a name as far as I can tell. I'm leaning unreliable. Thoughts? Sergecross73 msg me 22:02, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Flaregamer" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
When working in some Final Fantasy articles, I've found this website, Flaregamer, which has been writing articles for many years. Here is the staff that created the website. They also contacted some people though. The main reason I bring this up here is because I was planning to nominate Tidus in the future and one of Flaregamer's articles has a lot about how he was designed. Regards. Tintor2 ( talk) 17:23, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "PlayStation LifeStyle.net" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I just started editing the article
Star Wars Battlefront, and I have noticed that one passage cites two sources, one of which is
this. I doubt the reliability of the website, but I would like to double-check, and I do not have time to review the website myself (and I do not always trust myself anyway when it comes to determining the reliability of a source).
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 18:33, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
I lean towards Reliable as well. Don't really see much in terms of policies besides a Review policy but that's better than nothing. GamerPro64 19:20, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "LGBTQ Video Game Archive" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This academic source is specialized in LGBT themes in video games. It was discussed at Talk:LGBT characters in video games#Reliability of LGBTQ Video Game Archive and the reliable source noticeboard, where it has been deemed reliable for the commentary and analysis of their academic authors.
The specifics of particular details about the games should be taken with a grain of salt though, as the primary author has said that she hasn't played all the 350+ games directly and has been relying on other reliable sources for their descriptions of specific LGBT-related episodes within the games. Diego ( talk) 14:20, 10 November 2016 (UTC)
Ok, I've listed this discussion at WikiProject LGBT studies and WikiProject Video games to try and get some more input. Diego ( talk) 16:35, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
I'm not familiar with this site—does anyone know more about it?
The Adrenaline Vault (Avault) used to be one of the premier gaming sites but slowly died due to an internal conflict. [1] It has recently been resurrected and is small scale. The current staff are volunteers, [2] and some of its news are sourced from other major news sources. [3] Some of its staff such as Bob Mandel, have been heavily involved with the games industry for years. It can possibly be used for reviews and features but I am uncertain on its usage for news (perhaps older archives from its heydays could be considered reliable for old games?).
— @ David Fuchs, Archive 1 (2008)
Was it once reliable? Or only in comparison to other early Internet sites? I only took a cursory look through the archives but I didn't see any basis for calling it reliable. Perhaps someone with more background can comment. Also is it related to PCM&E's Adrenaline Zone? czar 17:50, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
Can we get www.kotaku.com.au added to the custom google searches? I believe we're only searching kotaku.com. Is there any reason to think the AU site is less reliable? -- ferret ( talk) 22:05, 29 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources:
"Zelda Informer" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"Gamnesia" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"Nintendo Prime" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
I feel like the websites mentioned above should be (re-)evaluated for several reasons. For one, Zelda Informer and Gamnesia are no longer "bundled together" by contract. They are now completely separate entities. (After this discussion is finished, they should also be listed separately.) Also, the head of Zelda Informer (Nathanial Rumphol-Janc) was able to get into E3 2016, likely using his credentials from Zelda Informer. (Remember that E3 is only open to the press unless you actually win tickets.) I feel Gamnesia, which I admittedly don't follow as much as Zelda Informer, should be re-evaluated simply because it was originally evaluated in connection with Zelda Informer. As I said above, it is now its own entity. Nintendo Prime should be evaluated because it is created and maintained by the creator and head of Zelda Informer. — Gestrid ( talk) 22:02, 27 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "FanSided" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Writing for FanSided
FanSided editors are given full editorial control of their very own team sites. Theyre eligible for our competitive revenue sharing program and a myriad of other perks. Whether you are looking to make a little extra money covering your favorite teams or you want a career in sports, FanSided is where you want to be.
Apply to become a FanSider today.
— http://fansided.com/about-fansided/
This site is apparently owned by Time, but that doesn't mean that the editorial control descends downwards. There is no apparent editorial structure to this site, so it should be marked as unreliable. czar 17:12, 10 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Niche Gamer" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
In the middle of reviewing Mortal Kombat X and seeing it using a source from Niche Gamer. Previous consensus was that it was deemed unreliable. Looking at the site now they have their own ethics policy and review policy. Seems to be a step up from last time it was checked, though I'm not sure what the site was back in 2014. Is the site still considered to be unreliable here? GamerPro64 20:19, 7 December 2016 (UTC)
I and User:Dohvahkiin are having a little debate conserning this guideline page; please see my talk page and the article's history. If possible, please comment. 88.113.105.231 ( talk) 21:36, 10 December 2016 (UTC)
Would using the website for the Complex magazine be all right?
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 04:07, 18 December 2016 (UTC)
Find sources: Google ( books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL
Website at [4]. I found this one in a ref on the Nintendo 64 article and was disturbed when I saw the referenced page says that Alien vs Predator (Jaguar game) was released near the end of the Jaguar's lifetime. (Wherever they got that idea from, they didn't need to do any hardcore research to check it; just glance at the copyright year and you'll see Alien vs Predator wasn't released anywhere near the Jaguar's end.) Checking on the about section, the fact that the editors' profiles cite only their gaming history, with no hint of journalistic experience or credentials, makes me suspect this source is indeed unreliable.-- Martin IIIa ( talk) 17:05, 11 December 2016 (UTC)
{{citation needed}}
...
czar 17:19, 19 December 2016 (UTC)NowGamer.com is by UK magazine publisher Imagine Publishing. I believe they are a reliable source for video game news, reviews, and opinions and should be added to the list. Here are some reliable sources that have considered NowGamer's opinions, reviews, and news reliable and noteworthy: PushSquare, Geek.com, Engadget, GameSpot, IBTimes, VG247, BGR (Penske Media Corporation). -- Odie5533 ( talk) 16:50, 17 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources:
"TV Tropes" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"WatchMojo" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
What do you folks think about the two sources. ULTRA-DARKNESS :) 2 CHAT 20:28, 14 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Glixel" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Glixel is Rolling Stone's video-game news site. It has been running on the rolling stone domain for the last several months but it is officially launched today as its own brand. (See [5]). It is implied that the same editorial aspects Rolling Stone has done still apply here. -- MASEM ( t) 01:04, 16 November 2016 (UTC)
Electric Playground was added as a RS in Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Video games/Sources/Archive 4#The Electric Playground and Reviews on the Run. How far back does their reliability go? It started as what appears to be an amateur website in 1994 (anyone have more info?) and went in the air a few years later. What year/period would it become credible? And should reviews from 1995 be deemed reliable if there is no perceptible editorial policy? It's kind of like citing early Kotaku... czar 22:18, 28 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Chris Hoffman's blog" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Just found out that Nintendo Power's Chris Hoffman is still writing reviews and opinion pieces, on his own site, and wondered what the wikiproject thinks about this. According to
WP:SPS, self-published expert sources may be considered reliable when produced by an established expert on the subject matter, whose work in the relevant field has previously been published by reliable third-party publications
, and Hoffman has been
editor for Gamers' Republic, a freelance video game writer for "various companies", senior editor for Play, writer and senior editor for Nintendo Power, and managing editor for MacLife. I'm thinking that it'd be a situational source: I see his own articles as reliable, self-published expert sources, while reblogged posts (unsure if there are any as I haven't looked through the archives) of course would be unreliable.--
IDV
talk 15:18, 29 December 2016 (UTC)
This is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
Archive 10 | ← | Archive 14 | Archive 15 | Archive 16 | Archive 17 | Archive 18 | → | Archive 20 |
I'm using theses sites as references on Razer Naga, but I'd like confirmation that they're reliable. -- Anarchyte ( work | talk) 11:52, 28 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Nintendo Everything" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Just another Nintendo-focused website that needs to be vetted. Saw it be used on different articles so it would be helpful to see other peoples take on it. GamerPro64 18:50, 31 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Hardcore Gaming 101" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I understand this website has been brought up before, but can we establish the site as a completely reputable source instead of conditional? The site's head editor Kurt Kalata, has already been proven to be a reliable source and fact checks all submissions. From the about page: All submitted articles are subject to fact checking and editing by staff. Contributors should nonetheless always strife to write as accurately and fairly as possible. We reserve the option to not publish any submitted articles for content, completion or quality concerns. We'll always write back to discuss whatever improvements may be necessary to bring it up to standards. In addition to this, many site articles have been published in physical format in the "Hardcore Gaming 101" series of books, also run by Kalata. This website is a tremendous source of information for older more obscure games. Thoughts? I just can't believe that this site is yellow and that garbage website Kotaku is green. TarkusAB 02:29, 23 August 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Power Up Gaming" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I think that this is an unreliable source because I can not find policies concerning ethics and credentials, but I want to double-check just to be sure.
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 02:45, 4 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Shmuplations" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Hey guys, I want to send an email to the site owner, but I'm having trouble figuring out exactly what I'm trying to ask. As you may or may not know, this guy translates interviews from old Japanese publications to English. My main issue with the site is he often doesn't say WHERE he got the interview from. For example, there's a great interview about Ikaruga on there, but it only says it's an interview with Masato Maegawa from 2001, no source mentioned.
Ultimately, I think determining the quality of the translator's skill is not important. It's no different from me opening an old Famicom issue, and translating it as I write it into Wikipedia. Many editors don't have English as their primary language too. That is why we source, so that if other editors doubt information, they can go to the source and check it themselves and verify. Given the amount of work and effort put into the website, I think we can safely say he doesn't have malicious intent.
So is it really the reliability of Shmuplations we are looking for here? Honestly, I think if he sources back to the original source (issue number and everything), than I say use his translations all you want, just footnote the ORIGINAL source he listed into wiki. I was going to send him an email to suggest to start putting that information in more often. What do you think? And I mean hey if we determine shmuplations itself is reliable, I won't complain :) TarkusAB 23:52, 3 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "The Washington Times" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Recently, I have told Steam users in the forums that something bad was going to happen to the Internet, and I have used this source, The Washington Times (Yes, they do cover video game subjects as well.), but they say that it will not happen, and two of them said that The Washington Times is a "fearmongering tabloid with no credibility whatsoever". However, I think that they are lying (simply because the newspaper is conservative), and I want to know whether this is a good source to use to cover video game subjects.
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 02:37, 16 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Pocket Tactics" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Noticed this at the bottom of the Wargamer page. Seems they're both owned by Slitherine Software and, according to their about page, they're on Metacritic. Of course that doesn't mean it'll be considered reliable here automatically. So what does everyone else thing of the website? GamerPro64 23:32, 25 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Millenium Portail" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
http://www.millenium.org/, French gaming and eSports website.-- Prisencolin ( talk) 04:44, 26 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "The Escapist" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
The site has been rather turbulent since that one event in 2014 took the gaming world by storm. Between replacing or firing most all of its staff, axing its office and generally just not being discussed in my circles, is it still considered a reliable source for news an opinions? I went for a quick look and the editorial policy doesn't seem to exist, but I did find an ethics policy. The drama surrounding Star Citizen shows that oversight is weak and since then it doesn't seem to have gotten better. Alex's questionable statements also do not bode well for reliability (or a sort of neutral stance). For the sake of making this easy, let's ignore Zero Punctuation.
Are we sure we want to keep this as reliable? Zero Serenity ( talk - contributions) 21:04, 27 September 2016 (UTC)
The Escapist hasn't changed its policies, and staff turnover shouldn't matter as long as their policies remain in place. An individual piece here or there with errors in it is something that happens to pretty much everybody at one point or another. — Torchiest talk edits 17:24, 30 September 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Classic Game Room" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Is Classic Game Room a reliable source? I was searching for sources about
Star Wars: Jedi Arena, and I have stumbled upon this source, but I am thinking that it is just a fan website with no credentials (I cannot find its policies).
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 18:09, 21 October 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Let's Play Video Games" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This site recently came up in a discussion at Talk:Nintendo Switch, and I don't see the site listed anywhere here, including the archives. If it turns out not to be VGRS and non-credible rumors keep coming out of it, we should have something to point to if we have to remove it from Nintendo Switch. Is this site reliable or not? — Gestrid ( talk) 05:56, 28 October 2016 (UTC)
If I remember correctly the founders of this website used to be part of Destructoid but got laid off a couple months ago. That said, it doesn't mean the site is automatically reliable. I don't see any policies stated on the site so that's a red flag right there. So I'm unsure about this source. GamerPro64 17:59, 30 October 2016 (UTC)
I know that EventHubs and SRK are unreliable, but what do you people think of the following sites?
As for unreliable sources, I would like to point out that SmashBoards which is an unreliable source, uses XenForo to function. Notably Test Your Might, 8WayRun, Skullheart, FreeStepDodge and VFDC also share this trait.
So what's your thoughts on my six sources that are on here? ULTRA-DARKNESS :) 2 CHAT 13:41, 7 October 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Quarter To Three" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I've heard of this website before but don't think there's ever been consensus of use here. The site is run by Tom Chick, who has freelanced for multiple websites that have been deemed reliable here. GamerPro64 18:56, 4 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Gamerant.com" – news · newspapers · books · scholar · JSTOR · free images · free news sources · TWL · NYT · WP reference · VG/RS · VG/RL · WPVG/Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This one has been discussed twice in the past, but without much input either time. Was hoping to get a solid word on it this time. They have an about page, but there's just two people listed as dedicated staff, and neither seem to have any credentials other than "being video game enthusiasts" and writing for GameRant. One has a college degree, but its in Film, so not particularly helpful. Other contributors don't have any info listed at all other than a name as far as I can tell. I'm leaning unreliable. Thoughts? Sergecross73 msg me 22:02, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Flaregamer" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
When working in some Final Fantasy articles, I've found this website, Flaregamer, which has been writing articles for many years. Here is the staff that created the website. They also contacted some people though. The main reason I bring this up here is because I was planning to nominate Tidus in the future and one of Flaregamer's articles has a lot about how he was designed. Regards. Tintor2 ( talk) 17:23, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "PlayStation LifeStyle.net" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
I just started editing the article
Star Wars Battlefront, and I have noticed that one passage cites two sources, one of which is
this. I doubt the reliability of the website, but I would like to double-check, and I do not have time to review the website myself (and I do not always trust myself anyway when it comes to determining the reliability of a source).
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 18:33, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
I lean towards Reliable as well. Don't really see much in terms of policies besides a Review policy but that's better than nothing. GamerPro64 19:20, 14 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "LGBTQ Video Game Archive" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
This academic source is specialized in LGBT themes in video games. It was discussed at Talk:LGBT characters in video games#Reliability of LGBTQ Video Game Archive and the reliable source noticeboard, where it has been deemed reliable for the commentary and analysis of their academic authors.
The specifics of particular details about the games should be taken with a grain of salt though, as the primary author has said that she hasn't played all the 350+ games directly and has been relying on other reliable sources for their descriptions of specific LGBT-related episodes within the games. Diego ( talk) 14:20, 10 November 2016 (UTC)
Ok, I've listed this discussion at WikiProject LGBT studies and WikiProject Video games to try and get some more input. Diego ( talk) 16:35, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
I'm not familiar with this site—does anyone know more about it?
The Adrenaline Vault (Avault) used to be one of the premier gaming sites but slowly died due to an internal conflict. [1] It has recently been resurrected and is small scale. The current staff are volunteers, [2] and some of its news are sourced from other major news sources. [3] Some of its staff such as Bob Mandel, have been heavily involved with the games industry for years. It can possibly be used for reviews and features but I am uncertain on its usage for news (perhaps older archives from its heydays could be considered reliable for old games?).
— @ David Fuchs, Archive 1 (2008)
Was it once reliable? Or only in comparison to other early Internet sites? I only took a cursory look through the archives but I didn't see any basis for calling it reliable. Perhaps someone with more background can comment. Also is it related to PCM&E's Adrenaline Zone? czar 17:50, 15 November 2016 (UTC)
Can we get www.kotaku.com.au added to the custom google searches? I believe we're only searching kotaku.com. Is there any reason to think the AU site is less reliable? -- ferret ( talk) 22:05, 29 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources:
"Zelda Informer" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"Gamnesia" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"Nintendo Prime" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
I feel like the websites mentioned above should be (re-)evaluated for several reasons. For one, Zelda Informer and Gamnesia are no longer "bundled together" by contract. They are now completely separate entities. (After this discussion is finished, they should also be listed separately.) Also, the head of Zelda Informer (Nathanial Rumphol-Janc) was able to get into E3 2016, likely using his credentials from Zelda Informer. (Remember that E3 is only open to the press unless you actually win tickets.) I feel Gamnesia, which I admittedly don't follow as much as Zelda Informer, should be re-evaluated simply because it was originally evaluated in connection with Zelda Informer. As I said above, it is now its own entity. Nintendo Prime should be evaluated because it is created and maintained by the creator and head of Zelda Informer. — Gestrid ( talk) 22:02, 27 November 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "FanSided" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Writing for FanSided
FanSided editors are given full editorial control of their very own team sites. Theyre eligible for our competitive revenue sharing program and a myriad of other perks. Whether you are looking to make a little extra money covering your favorite teams or you want a career in sports, FanSided is where you want to be.
Apply to become a FanSider today.
— http://fansided.com/about-fansided/
This site is apparently owned by Time, but that doesn't mean that the editorial control descends downwards. There is no apparent editorial structure to this site, so it should be marked as unreliable. czar 17:12, 10 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Niche Gamer" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
In the middle of reviewing Mortal Kombat X and seeing it using a source from Niche Gamer. Previous consensus was that it was deemed unreliable. Looking at the site now they have their own ethics policy and review policy. Seems to be a step up from last time it was checked, though I'm not sure what the site was back in 2014. Is the site still considered to be unreliable here? GamerPro64 20:19, 7 December 2016 (UTC)
I and User:Dohvahkiin are having a little debate conserning this guideline page; please see my talk page and the article's history. If possible, please comment. 88.113.105.231 ( talk) 21:36, 10 December 2016 (UTC)
Would using the website for the Complex magazine be all right?
Gamingforfun365
(talk) 04:07, 18 December 2016 (UTC)
Find sources: Google ( books · news · scholar · free images · WP refs) · FENS · JSTOR · TWL
Website at [4]. I found this one in a ref on the Nintendo 64 article and was disturbed when I saw the referenced page says that Alien vs Predator (Jaguar game) was released near the end of the Jaguar's lifetime. (Wherever they got that idea from, they didn't need to do any hardcore research to check it; just glance at the copyright year and you'll see Alien vs Predator wasn't released anywhere near the Jaguar's end.) Checking on the about section, the fact that the editors' profiles cite only their gaming history, with no hint of journalistic experience or credentials, makes me suspect this source is indeed unreliable.-- Martin IIIa ( talk) 17:05, 11 December 2016 (UTC)
{{citation needed}}
...
czar 17:19, 19 December 2016 (UTC)NowGamer.com is by UK magazine publisher Imagine Publishing. I believe they are a reliable source for video game news, reviews, and opinions and should be added to the list. Here are some reliable sources that have considered NowGamer's opinions, reviews, and news reliable and noteworthy: PushSquare, Geek.com, Engadget, GameSpot, IBTimes, VG247, BGR (Penske Media Corporation). -- Odie5533 ( talk) 16:50, 17 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources:
"TV Tropes" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
Find video game sources:
"WatchMojo" –
news ·
books ·
scholar ·
images –
VGRS ·
WPVG Talk ·
LinkSearch ·
LinkTo
What do you folks think about the two sources. ULTRA-DARKNESS :) 2 CHAT 20:28, 14 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Glixel" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Glixel is Rolling Stone's video-game news site. It has been running on the rolling stone domain for the last several months but it is officially launched today as its own brand. (See [5]). It is implied that the same editorial aspects Rolling Stone has done still apply here. -- MASEM ( t) 01:04, 16 November 2016 (UTC)
Electric Playground was added as a RS in Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Video games/Sources/Archive 4#The Electric Playground and Reviews on the Run. How far back does their reliability go? It started as what appears to be an amateur website in 1994 (anyone have more info?) and went in the air a few years later. What year/period would it become credible? And should reviews from 1995 be deemed reliable if there is no perceptible editorial policy? It's kind of like citing early Kotaku... czar 22:18, 28 December 2016 (UTC)
Find video game sources: "Chris Hoffman's blog" – news · books · scholar · images – VGRS · WPVG Talk · LinkSearch · LinkTo
Just found out that Nintendo Power's Chris Hoffman is still writing reviews and opinion pieces, on his own site, and wondered what the wikiproject thinks about this. According to
WP:SPS, self-published expert sources may be considered reliable when produced by an established expert on the subject matter, whose work in the relevant field has previously been published by reliable third-party publications
, and Hoffman has been
editor for Gamers' Republic, a freelance video game writer for "various companies", senior editor for Play, writer and senior editor for Nintendo Power, and managing editor for MacLife. I'm thinking that it'd be a situational source: I see his own articles as reliable, self-published expert sources, while reblogged posts (unsure if there are any as I haven't looked through the archives) of course would be unreliable.--
IDV
talk 15:18, 29 December 2016 (UTC)