Case clerk: TBD Drafting arbitrator: TBD
Wikipedia Arbitration |
---|
|
Track related changes |
Case opened on 21:30, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Case suspended by motion on 21:30, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Case closed on 09:16, 28 August 2022 (UTC)
Do not edit this page unless you are an arbitrator or clerk. Statements on this page are copies of the statements submitted in the original request to arbitrate this dispute, and serve as verbatim copies; therefore, they may not be edited or removed, however lengthy statements may be truncated – in which case the full statement will be copied to the talk page. Evidence which you wish to submit to the committee should be given at the /Evidence subpage, although permission must be sought by e-mail before you submit private, confidential, or sensitive evidence.
Arbitrators, the parties, and other editors may suggest proposed principles, findings, and remedies at /Workshop. The Workshop may also be used for you to submit general comments on the evidence, and for arbitrators to pose questions to the parties. Eventually, arbitrators will vote on a final decision in the case at /Proposed decision; only arbitrators may offer proposals as the Proposed Decision.
Preliminary statements given in the case request stage may be found at Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Jonathunder/Preliminary statements.
Should a case request really restart the clock?- no, but we should at least give them a few days to respond. In addition, from a procedural standpoint, a case request must be open for at least 48 hours before we can proceed to arbitration; we are barely over 24 hours at this point in time and I see no intent from the Arbs to fast-track the process. Primefac ( talk) 11:53, 21 February 2022 (UTC)
There's no need for a week of the "fun" involved in an arbitration case request– I completely understand where you're coming from; participating in a case request isn't fun. Personally, I would advise community members that they aren't missing out on much if they choose not to participate. Chances are that if nobody but the filer in this case request had submitted a statement, we would be in exactly the same place as we are now. As many community members have noted, this is so far a pretty straightforward case. So if this case request is stressful or unpleasant, non-parties should please not feel an obligation to submit a statement. Personally, the trend of every case request seeing a dozen-plus uninvolved statements no matter how straightforward baffles me a bit. Best, KevinL (aka L235 · t · c) 19:59, 21 February 2022 (UTC)
Discussion on motions.
|
---|
Motion: Accept and suspendThe "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months. If Jonathunder should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is instructed not to use his administrator tools in any way until the closure of the case; doing so will be grounds for immediate removal of his administrator userrights. If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: expedited caseThe "Jonathunder" arbitration case request is accepted, and an arbitration case shall be opened on an expedited basis. The following timeline shall govern the case, subject to change by the drafting arbitrators:
For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: Jonathunder warnedThe "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is resolved as follows: The Committee recognizes Jonathunder's long service, and encourages his continued editing. However, Jonathunder ( talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA) is warned that the use of the administrator toolset must conform to the policies set by the community. He should especially take note of WP:ADMINACCT, and remember that the toolset is not to be used to further content or policy disputes. The Committee will consider any further misuse of the toolset within a two-year period to be immediate cause for opening level 2 de-sysop proceedings. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: Accept and suspend (2)The "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months. If Jonathunder ( talk · contribs) should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is temporarily desysopped for the duration of the case. If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be permanently desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
|
The "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months.
If Jonathunder ( talk · contribs) should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is temporarily desysopped for the duration of the case.
If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be permanently desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship.
Case clerk: TBD Drafting arbitrator: TBD
Wikipedia Arbitration |
---|
|
Track related changes |
Case opened on 21:30, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Case suspended by motion on 21:30, 26 February 2022 (UTC)
Case closed on 09:16, 28 August 2022 (UTC)
Do not edit this page unless you are an arbitrator or clerk. Statements on this page are copies of the statements submitted in the original request to arbitrate this dispute, and serve as verbatim copies; therefore, they may not be edited or removed, however lengthy statements may be truncated – in which case the full statement will be copied to the talk page. Evidence which you wish to submit to the committee should be given at the /Evidence subpage, although permission must be sought by e-mail before you submit private, confidential, or sensitive evidence.
Arbitrators, the parties, and other editors may suggest proposed principles, findings, and remedies at /Workshop. The Workshop may also be used for you to submit general comments on the evidence, and for arbitrators to pose questions to the parties. Eventually, arbitrators will vote on a final decision in the case at /Proposed decision; only arbitrators may offer proposals as the Proposed Decision.
Preliminary statements given in the case request stage may be found at Wikipedia:Arbitration/Requests/Case/Jonathunder/Preliminary statements.
Should a case request really restart the clock?- no, but we should at least give them a few days to respond. In addition, from a procedural standpoint, a case request must be open for at least 48 hours before we can proceed to arbitration; we are barely over 24 hours at this point in time and I see no intent from the Arbs to fast-track the process. Primefac ( talk) 11:53, 21 February 2022 (UTC)
There's no need for a week of the "fun" involved in an arbitration case request– I completely understand where you're coming from; participating in a case request isn't fun. Personally, I would advise community members that they aren't missing out on much if they choose not to participate. Chances are that if nobody but the filer in this case request had submitted a statement, we would be in exactly the same place as we are now. As many community members have noted, this is so far a pretty straightforward case. So if this case request is stressful or unpleasant, non-parties should please not feel an obligation to submit a statement. Personally, the trend of every case request seeing a dozen-plus uninvolved statements no matter how straightforward baffles me a bit. Best, KevinL (aka L235 · t · c) 19:59, 21 February 2022 (UTC)
Discussion on motions.
|
---|
Motion: Accept and suspendThe "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months. If Jonathunder should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is instructed not to use his administrator tools in any way until the closure of the case; doing so will be grounds for immediate removal of his administrator userrights. If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: expedited caseThe "Jonathunder" arbitration case request is accepted, and an arbitration case shall be opened on an expedited basis. The following timeline shall govern the case, subject to change by the drafting arbitrators:
For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: Jonathunder warnedThe "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is resolved as follows: The Committee recognizes Jonathunder's long service, and encourages his continued editing. However, Jonathunder ( talk · contribs · blocks · protections · deletions · page moves · rights · RfA) is warned that the use of the administrator toolset must conform to the policies set by the community. He should especially take note of WP:ADMINACCT, and remember that the toolset is not to be used to further content or policy disputes. The Committee will consider any further misuse of the toolset within a two-year period to be immediate cause for opening level 2 de-sysop proceedings. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
Motion: Accept and suspend (2)The "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months. If Jonathunder ( talk · contribs) should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is temporarily desysopped for the duration of the case. If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be permanently desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship. For this motion there are 13 active arbitrators. With 0 arbitrators abstaining, 7 support or oppose votes are a majority.
|
The "Jonathunder" request for arbitration is accepted. This case will be opened but suspended for a period of six months.
If Jonathunder ( talk · contribs) should return to active editing on the English Wikipedia during this time and request that this case be resumed, the Arbitration Committee shall unsuspend the case by motion and it will proceed through the normal arbitration process. Such a request may be made by email to arbcom-enwikimedia.org or at the clerks' noticeboard. Jonathunder is temporarily desysopped for the duration of the case.
If such a request is not made within six months of this motion or if Jonathunder resigns his administrative tools, this case shall be automatically closed, and Jonathunder shall be permanently desysopped. If tools are resigned or removed, in the circumstances described above, Jonathunder may regain the administrative tools at any time only via a successful request for adminship.