Username: N5iln User groups: reviewer, rollbacker First edit: May 15, 2006 19:11:03 Unique pages edited: 22,053 Average edits per page: 1.30 Live edits: 28,105 Deleted edits: 671 Total edits (including deleted): 28,776 Article 12471 44.37% Talk 515 1.83% User 268 0.95% User talk 12817 45.61% Wikipedia 1897 6.75% Wikipedia talk 41 0.15% File 21 0.07% File talk 1 0.00% MediaWiki talk 1 0.00% Template 49 0.17% Template talk 4 0.01% Help talk 3 0.01% Category 15 0.05% Portal 1 0.00% Month counts 2006/05 12 2006/06 0 2006/07 2 2006/08 0 2006/09 0 2006/10 0 2006/11 0 2006/12 0 2007/01 0 2007/02 0 2007/03 7 2007/04 406 2007/05 535 2007/06 0 2007/07 0 2007/08 0 2007/09 0 2007/10 0 2007/11 0 2007/12 0 2008/01 0 2008/02 0 2008/03 0 2008/04 0 2008/05 0 2008/06 0 2008/07 0 2008/08 0 2008/09 0 2008/10 0 2008/11 0 2008/12 0 2009/01 0 2009/02 0 2009/03 0 2009/04 0 2009/05 0 2009/06 0 2009/07 0 2009/08 671 2009/09 6604 2009/10 3658 2009/11 768 2009/12 282 2010/01 384 2010/02 791 2010/03 1389 2010/04 1686 2010/05 1344 2010/06 463 2010/07 365 2010/08 193 2010/09 313 2010/10 398 2010/11 859 2010/12 599 2011/01 627 2011/02 1321 2011/03 1222 2011/04 881 2011/05 1088 2011/06 786 2011/07 450 Article * 31 - Drag_racing * 23 - Firefly_(TV_series) * 18 - National_Hot_Rod_Association * 16 - Colbie_Caillat * 13 - 2011_NHRA_Full_Throttle_Drag_Racing_Series_season * 12 - MV_Bright_Field * 12 - Firefighter * 11 - 2010_NASCAR_Sprint_Cup_Series * 10 - Cirque_du_Freak:_The_Vampire's_Assistant * 10 - Kurt_Busch Talk * 62 - Death_of_Osama_bin_Laden * 11 - Gabrielle_Giffords * 10 - Drag_racing * 9 - Emergency_medical_technician * 8 - R_(programming_language) * 7 - Mike_Skinner_(musician) * 7 - Firefly_(TV_series) * 6 - Barack_Obama * 6 - Ubuntu_(operating_system) * 5 - Van_Jones User * 86 - N5iln * 21 - N5iln/huggle.css * 14 - N5iln/monobook.js * 5 - Deucalionite/WP:Accurate_reference_citations * 5 - TheCatalyst31 * 5 - N5iln/2011_NHRA_Full_Throttle_Drag_Racing_Series_s... * 4 - N5iln/sandbox * 3 - Chris-in-the-hemel * 3 - Deucalionite/Treaties * 3 - Abc518 User talk * 345 - N5iln * 8 - 199.44.252.34 * 6 - 74.0.157.163 * 6 - Tide_rolls * 6 - 92.251.69.19 * 5 - 65.246.143.130 * 5 - Ordurac * 5 - 86.133.152.183 * 5 - 96.35.145.30 * 5 - 79.71.240.71 Wikipedia * 528 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 476 - Huggle/Whitelist * 400 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents * 61 - Requests_for_page_protection * 25 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention * 14 - Conflict_of_interest/Noticeboard * 9 - Huggle/Feedback * 9 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention/Bot * 9 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Edit_warring * 9 - Requests_for_adminship/N5iln Wikipedia talk * 5 - WikiProject_Anime_and_manga * 5 - Requests_for_adminship/Dylan620_2 * 5 - Requests_for_adminship * 4 - WikiProject_Spam * 2 - AutoWikiBrowser/CheckPage * 2 - Twinkle * 2 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 2 - Ambassadors * 1 - Citing_sources * 1 - Signatures File * 1 - Top_of_Atmosphere.jpg * 1 - Cats_&_Dogs_film.jpg * 1 - Lima_Convento_San_Fransisco.jpg * 1 - K-strawberry234.jpg * 1 - Clarence_Hotel_Dublin.png * 1 - Single_lavendar_flower02.jpg * 1 - Animalcrackers_lg.jpg * 1 - Gormogon.jpg * 1 - Fruitnveg-3.png * 1 - SyrianPassportVisaFree.PNG File talk * 1 - Elephant_seal_colony_edit.jpg MediaWiki talk * 1 - Spam-blacklist Template * 10 - Vandalism_information * 4 - HTTP * 1 - Infobox_magnesium * 1 - PBB/7273 * 1 - Madonna * 1 - User_page/doc * 1 - Cleanup/doc * 1 - Noontime_variety_shows_in_the_Philippines * 1 - Standard * 1 - Gridded_chart_of_ITU_prefixes Template talk * 1 - Editnotices/Page/Talk:Main_Page * 1 - Shared_IP * 1 - Asia_topics * 1 - The_Holocaust_(end) Help talk * 1 - Editing * 1 - Using_talk_pages * 1 - Edit_summary Category * 1 - Ships * 1 - Châteaux_in_France * 1 - Languages_of_Honduras * 1 - Tokugawa_clan * 1 - 1996_disasters * 1 - Wikipedians_who_use_VandalProof * 1 - American_female_singers * 1 - Hip_hop_production * 1 - Russian_anti-communists * 1 - Ancient_Greek_cities Portal * 1 - Nautical
Oppose Per the signatures policy that the candidate even links to in his own userbox, signatures that contain no reference to the username are strongly discouraged. Keepscases ( talk) 01:55, 16 July 2011 (UTC)
( ←) I wouldn't have opposed if that was always their sig. The new sig isn't the point. If someone complained about the "x" in my sig (let's say they thought it should say "talk"), I don't think they would find it reasonable for me to change it to: Swarm TALK to the aforementioned Wikipedia user. I think they would feel patronized by the new, excessive version. I think they would acknowledge that yes, their concern was technically addressed, but it was not done in a reasonable way. There's the analogy to this situation. The problem is no longer with the sig, the problem was with their unreasonable response to a complaint, which, if done to intentionally patronize is a behavioral problem and if done in good faith is a judgement problem. Swarm X 19:03, 19 July 2011 (UTC)
Username: N5iln User groups: reviewer, rollbacker First edit: May 15, 2006 19:11:03 Unique pages edited: 22,053 Average edits per page: 1.30 Live edits: 28,105 Deleted edits: 671 Total edits (including deleted): 28,776 Article 12471 44.37% Talk 515 1.83% User 268 0.95% User talk 12817 45.61% Wikipedia 1897 6.75% Wikipedia talk 41 0.15% File 21 0.07% File talk 1 0.00% MediaWiki talk 1 0.00% Template 49 0.17% Template talk 4 0.01% Help talk 3 0.01% Category 15 0.05% Portal 1 0.00% Month counts 2006/05 12 2006/06 0 2006/07 2 2006/08 0 2006/09 0 2006/10 0 2006/11 0 2006/12 0 2007/01 0 2007/02 0 2007/03 7 2007/04 406 2007/05 535 2007/06 0 2007/07 0 2007/08 0 2007/09 0 2007/10 0 2007/11 0 2007/12 0 2008/01 0 2008/02 0 2008/03 0 2008/04 0 2008/05 0 2008/06 0 2008/07 0 2008/08 0 2008/09 0 2008/10 0 2008/11 0 2008/12 0 2009/01 0 2009/02 0 2009/03 0 2009/04 0 2009/05 0 2009/06 0 2009/07 0 2009/08 671 2009/09 6604 2009/10 3658 2009/11 768 2009/12 282 2010/01 384 2010/02 791 2010/03 1389 2010/04 1686 2010/05 1344 2010/06 463 2010/07 365 2010/08 193 2010/09 313 2010/10 398 2010/11 859 2010/12 599 2011/01 627 2011/02 1321 2011/03 1222 2011/04 881 2011/05 1088 2011/06 786 2011/07 450 Article * 31 - Drag_racing * 23 - Firefly_(TV_series) * 18 - National_Hot_Rod_Association * 16 - Colbie_Caillat * 13 - 2011_NHRA_Full_Throttle_Drag_Racing_Series_season * 12 - MV_Bright_Field * 12 - Firefighter * 11 - 2010_NASCAR_Sprint_Cup_Series * 10 - Cirque_du_Freak:_The_Vampire's_Assistant * 10 - Kurt_Busch Talk * 62 - Death_of_Osama_bin_Laden * 11 - Gabrielle_Giffords * 10 - Drag_racing * 9 - Emergency_medical_technician * 8 - R_(programming_language) * 7 - Mike_Skinner_(musician) * 7 - Firefly_(TV_series) * 6 - Barack_Obama * 6 - Ubuntu_(operating_system) * 5 - Van_Jones User * 86 - N5iln * 21 - N5iln/huggle.css * 14 - N5iln/monobook.js * 5 - Deucalionite/WP:Accurate_reference_citations * 5 - TheCatalyst31 * 5 - N5iln/2011_NHRA_Full_Throttle_Drag_Racing_Series_s... * 4 - N5iln/sandbox * 3 - Chris-in-the-hemel * 3 - Deucalionite/Treaties * 3 - Abc518 User talk * 345 - N5iln * 8 - 199.44.252.34 * 6 - 74.0.157.163 * 6 - Tide_rolls * 6 - 92.251.69.19 * 5 - 65.246.143.130 * 5 - Ordurac * 5 - 86.133.152.183 * 5 - 96.35.145.30 * 5 - 79.71.240.71 Wikipedia * 528 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 476 - Huggle/Whitelist * 400 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents * 61 - Requests_for_page_protection * 25 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention * 14 - Conflict_of_interest/Noticeboard * 9 - Huggle/Feedback * 9 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention/Bot * 9 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Edit_warring * 9 - Requests_for_adminship/N5iln Wikipedia talk * 5 - WikiProject_Anime_and_manga * 5 - Requests_for_adminship/Dylan620_2 * 5 - Requests_for_adminship * 4 - WikiProject_Spam * 2 - AutoWikiBrowser/CheckPage * 2 - Twinkle * 2 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 2 - Ambassadors * 1 - Citing_sources * 1 - Signatures File * 1 - Top_of_Atmosphere.jpg * 1 - Cats_&_Dogs_film.jpg * 1 - Lima_Convento_San_Fransisco.jpg * 1 - K-strawberry234.jpg * 1 - Clarence_Hotel_Dublin.png * 1 - Single_lavendar_flower02.jpg * 1 - Animalcrackers_lg.jpg * 1 - Gormogon.jpg * 1 - Fruitnveg-3.png * 1 - SyrianPassportVisaFree.PNG File talk * 1 - Elephant_seal_colony_edit.jpg MediaWiki talk * 1 - Spam-blacklist Template * 10 - Vandalism_information * 4 - HTTP * 1 - Infobox_magnesium * 1 - PBB/7273 * 1 - Madonna * 1 - User_page/doc * 1 - Cleanup/doc * 1 - Noontime_variety_shows_in_the_Philippines * 1 - Standard * 1 - Gridded_chart_of_ITU_prefixes Template talk * 1 - Editnotices/Page/Talk:Main_Page * 1 - Shared_IP * 1 - Asia_topics * 1 - The_Holocaust_(end) Help talk * 1 - Editing * 1 - Using_talk_pages * 1 - Edit_summary Category * 1 - Ships * 1 - Châteaux_in_France * 1 - Languages_of_Honduras * 1 - Tokugawa_clan * 1 - 1996_disasters * 1 - Wikipedians_who_use_VandalProof * 1 - American_female_singers * 1 - Hip_hop_production * 1 - Russian_anti-communists * 1 - Ancient_Greek_cities Portal * 1 - Nautical
Oppose Per the signatures policy that the candidate even links to in his own userbox, signatures that contain no reference to the username are strongly discouraged. Keepscases ( talk) 01:55, 16 July 2011 (UTC)
( ←) I wouldn't have opposed if that was always their sig. The new sig isn't the point. If someone complained about the "x" in my sig (let's say they thought it should say "talk"), I don't think they would find it reasonable for me to change it to: Swarm TALK to the aforementioned Wikipedia user. I think they would feel patronized by the new, excessive version. I think they would acknowledge that yes, their concern was technically addressed, but it was not done in a reasonable way. There's the analogy to this situation. The problem is no longer with the sig, the problem was with their unreasonable response to a complaint, which, if done to intentionally patronize is a behavioral problem and if done in good faith is a judgement problem. Swarm X 19:03, 19 July 2011 (UTC)