The result was keep. No sense in keeping this open any longer, per IAR NW ( Talk) 03:50, 21 September 2010 (UTC) reply
Fails
WP:Notable. This is a television documentary shown on a notable outlet, the
BBC; created by a notable person,
Louis Theroux; and about a notable subject, the
Westboro Baptist Church. However it itself is not notable. No secondary sources are given in the article. It is sourced to the program itself. Other sources are provided to give information on the church but they do not mention the TV program. This is a single TV show. Although, like most such shows it has been given coverage in notable reliable news media, it by its very nature is not notable or a proper topic for an encyclopedia article according to
Wikipedia:Notability (films). WP should use this program as a source for other articles (and could also be an external link), but does not need an article on it.
Wolfview (
talk)
16:06, 14 September 2010 (UTC)
reply
The result was keep. No sense in keeping this open any longer, per IAR NW ( Talk) 03:50, 21 September 2010 (UTC) reply
Fails
WP:Notable. This is a television documentary shown on a notable outlet, the
BBC; created by a notable person,
Louis Theroux; and about a notable subject, the
Westboro Baptist Church. However it itself is not notable. No secondary sources are given in the article. It is sourced to the program itself. Other sources are provided to give information on the church but they do not mention the TV program. This is a single TV show. Although, like most such shows it has been given coverage in notable reliable news media, it by its very nature is not notable or a proper topic for an encyclopedia article according to
Wikipedia:Notability (films). WP should use this program as a source for other articles (and could also be an external link), but does not need an article on it.
Wolfview (
talk)
16:06, 14 September 2010 (UTC)
reply