This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
How best to handle this claim is unclear:
Consensus decision-making may be able to resolve the plausible questions raised by these sentences. -- Tenmei ( talk) 00:01, 4 August 2009 (UTC)
PROPOSED TEXT + Notes & References to be added
The inscription on the
Suda Hachiman Shrine Mirror has been construed to suggest a Korean connection;1 and some scholars have taken this further by theorizing an implied fraternal relationship between the Muryeong and this legendary Emperor of Japan.2 Korean scholars have theorized that Emperor Keitai may be
Konchi of Baekje (곤지, 昆支), who was a brother of
Muryeong of Baekje. If so, then this legendary figure would also be the son of
Munju of Baekje.3
Regardless of speculation about Keitai's parentage, it is well-settled that there was an extended period of disputes over the succession which developed after Keitai's death. The confrontation between adherents of two branches of the Yamato, pitting the supporters of sons who would become known as
Emperor Ankan and
Emperor Senka against those who were backers of the son who would become known as
Emperor Kimmei.4
Notes
1 Seeley, Christopher. (2000). A History of Writing in Japan, p. 19 n10.
2 Kim Yong Woon, 현대 일본어는 백제어에서 출발 Chosun Ilbo (Seoul). July 21, 2009; So Jin Cheol (원광대 객원교수). 금석문으로 본 백제 무녕왕의 세계 (May 22, 1997). Wonkwang University Museum. ; SearchChina.co: 韓国で「日本語起源は百済語」説、中国で「またか!」の声
3 야마토 왕조의 중시조, 게이타이천황은 무령왕의 아우 (Emperor Keitai is a brother of King Muryeong of Baekje). Pressian (Seoul). December 5, 2008;
4 Hall, John Whitney. The Cambridge history of Japan: Ancient Japan, Vol. I., p. 154.
References
I found one more reference on Keitai and Muryeong's brotherhood. A lecture of Wonkwang University in Korea presents the brotherhood. It's based on inscriptions on Suda Hachiman Shrine Mirror. You can find '이 때 사마는 왜국에 있는 자신의 신하인‘男弟王’(『日本書紀」의 繼體天皇으로 보임)에게 鏡을‘하사’하면서 그의 장수를 기원했던 것이다.', which means 'Sima gave the mirror to his brother King(Keitai in Nihon shoki)' -- Cheol ( talk) 06:44, 5 August 2009 (UTC)
This article is rated Start-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
How best to handle this claim is unclear:
Consensus decision-making may be able to resolve the plausible questions raised by these sentences. -- Tenmei ( talk) 00:01, 4 August 2009 (UTC)
PROPOSED TEXT + Notes & References to be added
The inscription on the
Suda Hachiman Shrine Mirror has been construed to suggest a Korean connection;1 and some scholars have taken this further by theorizing an implied fraternal relationship between the Muryeong and this legendary Emperor of Japan.2 Korean scholars have theorized that Emperor Keitai may be
Konchi of Baekje (곤지, 昆支), who was a brother of
Muryeong of Baekje. If so, then this legendary figure would also be the son of
Munju of Baekje.3
Regardless of speculation about Keitai's parentage, it is well-settled that there was an extended period of disputes over the succession which developed after Keitai's death. The confrontation between adherents of two branches of the Yamato, pitting the supporters of sons who would become known as
Emperor Ankan and
Emperor Senka against those who were backers of the son who would become known as
Emperor Kimmei.4
Notes
1 Seeley, Christopher. (2000). A History of Writing in Japan, p. 19 n10.
2 Kim Yong Woon, 현대 일본어는 백제어에서 출발 Chosun Ilbo (Seoul). July 21, 2009; So Jin Cheol (원광대 객원교수). 금석문으로 본 백제 무녕왕의 세계 (May 22, 1997). Wonkwang University Museum. ; SearchChina.co: 韓国で「日本語起源は百済語」説、中国で「またか!」の声
3 야마토 왕조의 중시조, 게이타이천황은 무령왕의 아우 (Emperor Keitai is a brother of King Muryeong of Baekje). Pressian (Seoul). December 5, 2008;
4 Hall, John Whitney. The Cambridge history of Japan: Ancient Japan, Vol. I., p. 154.
References
I found one more reference on Keitai and Muryeong's brotherhood. A lecture of Wonkwang University in Korea presents the brotherhood. It's based on inscriptions on Suda Hachiman Shrine Mirror. You can find '이 때 사마는 왜국에 있는 자신의 신하인‘男弟王’(『日本書紀」의 繼體天皇으로 보임)에게 鏡을‘하사’하면서 그의 장수를 기원했던 것이다.', which means 'Sima gave the mirror to his brother King(Keitai in Nihon shoki)' -- Cheol ( talk) 06:44, 5 August 2009 (UTC)