 | This article includes a list of general
references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding
inline citations. (October 2023) |
| Kazakh–Russian ethnic conflicts | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Part of Ethnic conflicts in Kazakhstan | |||
| Date | 1989 (1990) — present | ||
| Location | Kazakhstan and Russia | ||
| Methods | Protests, demonstrations, persecution, uprisings, riots, employment discrimination (particularly in public sector jobs), hostility and harassment in everyday interactions | ||
| Status | Ongoing | ||
| Parties | |||
| Lead figures | |||
Jasaral Quanyşälin Alexander Martynov | |||
| Number | |||
| |||
| Casualties and losses | |||
| |||
| 2,000,000—3,000,000 Voluntarily left from Kazakhstan [3] [4] | |||
Kazakh–Russian ethnic conflicts refers to the ethnic clashes between Kazakhs and Russians that occurred from the late 20th to early 21st century. These clashes were accompanied by riots and disorder.
Events
Kazakh–Cossack conflict of 1990
In 1990, tensions escalated between local Cossacks and Kazakh nationalists in Uralsk. On August 27, the Cossacks held a rally in the city center, where a resolution was passed demanding the invalidation of the transfer of the Ural Oblast to Kazakhstan in 1920. The organizers of the rally were fined, but the Cossacks persisted in their demands. On September 4 of the same year, the Uralsk City Council declared the Russian language the local official language.
Ural events of 1991
On September 15, 1991 the Cossacks celebrated the 400th anniversary of their service to the Russian crown in Uralsk. It was essentially the first and now the last large-scale event of the revived Ural Cossacks in 1990. Despite objections from the local administration and the mobilization of the Kazakh nationalist-patriotic organization "Azat," the Cossack leaders persisted in their preparations for the celebration, inviting hundreds of Cossacks from the Russian Federation. In response the Kazakh authorities deployed hundreds of nationalist demonstrators to Uralsk, including thousands of students and young Kazakhs from the entire Uralsk region.
On that day thousands of Kazakhs continued their protests in the square in front of the city hall, while a picket of young Kazakhs was sent to the cultural center. However, when the Cossacks began their assembly, thousands of demonstrators from the square broke through to the cultural center. According to the Cossack researcher Nikolai Fokin in his book "The Final Tragedy: Urals Cossacks in the 20th Century," thousands of Russian workers and Cossacks at the Voroshilov Plant were ready to resist the "Azat" activists.
The leaders of the Cossacks present at the cultural center that day denied any proclamations of separatist slogans, stating that it was a festive concert. They mentioned that representatives of the authorities interrupted the meeting several times, expressing concerns about their ability to restrain the "Azat" supporters. Ultimately, the crowded hall of 700 seats was quickly evacuated through the fire exit by the Cossacks, numerous observers, journalists from Russia, and local officials. [1]
Uprising in Öskemen of 1994
In 1994 some 10,000 people gathered for a rally in Öskemen, organized by the local Slavic Culture Society, demanding the establishment of a Russian autonomy in Eastern Kazakhstan, the elevation of the Russian language to the status of a state language, and the implementation of dual citizenship. In response, the presidential decree "On Measures to Regulate the Activities of Free Economic Zones" was issued, effectively revoking the resolution on the establishment of the Eastern Kazakhstan and other free economic zones. This move effectively curbed the economic foundation for separatist sentiments. [2]
Almaty conflict of 1994–1995
During this period certain representatives of the Cossack community made statements about their "readiness to use force." The speeches of Cossack activists in November and December 1994 heightened tensions in Almaty and Eastern Kazakhstan. In the same month, the activities of the "Society for the Assistance of the Semirechye Cossacks" were suspended. [6] The escalation of relations between the Cossacks and the Kazakhstani authorities ultimately led to the arrest of the ataman of the Semirechye Cossacks, Nikolai Gunkin, in the autumn of 1995. [7]
Kökşetau uprising of 1996–1997
In spring 1996 the leaders of the "Kokchetav Division of the Siberian Cossack Host," brothers Yuri and Viktor Antoshko, attempted to organize an uprising in the Kokshetau Oblast, with the aim of establishing a "state" similar to Transnistria or Abkhazia. Viktor Antoshko traveled to cities in Russia to recruit supporters who would become the striking force of the future uprising. [8]
"In March 1997, the Semirechye Cossacks came to Moscow and asked us for help, either in terms of money or manpower. We lacked funds, so we formed a unit and went there. On May 2, a Cossack assembly was planned in Kokshetau, during which the independence of the Kokshetau region was to be declared. Subsequently, the local maslikhat was supposed to vote on this declaration. In the event of a failed peaceful resolution, an armed uprising was planned. The Kazakhstani authorities made serious preparations to counter the Russian Cossack uprising. All roads, railways, and the airport were blocked. A joint operation of Russian and Kazakhstani special services was conducted to suppress the uprising. Russian special services dismantled two rebel bases in the Kurgan and Omsk Oblasts."
Pugachev's Rebellion of 1999
At the end of the last century Öskemen was in turmoil. Thousands of outraged people took to the square due to massive debts in wages, pensions, and social benefits. Some even attempted to leverage this situation for their own political gains, almost plunging the region into a civil confrontation. These events remain in the history of modern Kazakhstan as the "Pugachev Rebellion."
In the summer of 1998,Pugachev, also known as Kazimyrchuk, first appeared in Eastern Kazakhstan. He brought with him two letters of recommendation from Chernyshov to a well-known regional political figure and a radically inclined deputy of the oblast maslikhat, Ivanov, and a certain Dashkov, associated with the radical wing of the Cossack community.
In the summer of 1999 Pugachev and Chernyshov together traveled to Eastern Kazakhstan. As later established by the employees of the Department of the National Security Committee in East Kazakhstan, in coordination with the central apparatus of the agency, the leader of the "Rus" Public Opinion Organization had a plan to secede the region from Kazakhstan. However, he had not yet figured out how to implement it. During the period of Kazimyrchuk and Chernyshov's stay in Ust-Kamenogorsk, a public appeal from the East Kazakhstan region to the "Rus" Public Opinion Organization and the State Duma of the Russian Federation was prepared, primarily addressing the negative aspects of the socio-economic and political situation in the region. Requests for assistance were also included in this appeal. When Kazimyrchuk arrived in Moscow, he finally concluded that it was necessary to seize power in the East Kazakhstan region by force, for which he formed a group.
The backbone of this group consisted of Russian citizens, with one individual from Moldova. Several of Chernyshov's associates also joined them in Ust-Kamenogorsk. Weapons were purchased in Omsk: 270 rounds of 5.45 mm caliber, 4 AK-47 magazines, and an F-1 grenade–such data is preserved in the case materials.
Meanwhile,Pugachev's group made its way to Öskemen. By this time, the leader had clearly outlined to his team the specific goal of seizing power in Eastern Kazakhstan by force and establishing the autonomous formation of Russian Altai. Pugachev approached the achievement of his goal with utmost seriousness, introducing military elements into the group's management, issuing orders, reports, assigning roles internally, appointing himself as the commander, and designating his deputy and chief of staff. After the arrest, the National Security Committee conducted a search in the OPG headquarters and was surprised by the level of ideological and theoretical preparation for the coup. Among the confiscated items were books on the history and practice of anarchism, works by researchers of opposition political forces, "Declarative Positions of the Rus Public Opinion Organization," "Russian Nationalism and the National Question in Russia," "Declaration of the National Bloc," and others. [9]
On 8 June 2000 the Öskemen court sentenced 13 people, 11 Russians and 2 Kazakhs, convicted of planning to overthrow the local government and of illegal possession of weapons. The court sentenced the leader of the group, Vladimir Kazimirchuk, to 18-years imprisonment. [10]
North Kazakhstan crisis of 2000–2001
In 2000–2001 Eduard Limonov was accused of preparing an armed invasion in Kazakhstan to protect the Russian-speaking population.
In April 2001 he was imprisoned in the Lefortovo FSB investigative isolation facility on charges of possession of weapons and the creation of illegal armed formations (the charges were later dropped). On April 15, 2003, he was sentenced to 4 years of imprisonment.
Relations after the annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation
Alexander Chebotaryov notes that "the situation in Ukraine has intensified the assessments from national-patriotic forces regarding the extent of the Russian-speaking population's loyalty to the Kazakhstan state." The lack of support for the idea of the "Russian world" from Russia can be explained by Astana's generally pro-Russian policy. Russia and Kazakhstan are united by their membership in organizations such as the CIS, CSTO, SCO, and the EAEU. The preservation of positive Kazakhstan-Russia relations is explained by Russia's desire to become an energy superpower. [11]
Russian emigration and persecution of Russians in Kazakhstan
In September–October 2022, following Vladimir Putin's mobilization announcement in Russia, over 406,000 Russians entered Kazakhstan. While the average daily immigration of Russians had been around 8,000–9,000 per day, during these days, the average daily influx of Russians reached 30,000 individuals. Despite the significant flow of incoming Russians in the last decade of September, the border and migration services ensured uninterrupted operations. Since October 1, the average daily number of incoming Russians has stabilized and does not exceed 6,000–7,000 per day. As of September 21, 3578 applications for permanent residence and 965 for citizenship have been processed. [12]
After these events unknown individuals in Kazakhstan organized patrols that interrogate incoming Russians and then assault them. These "patrols" inquire about individuals' opinions on the territorial integrity of Ukraine. If the response from the Russian does not satisfy them, they inflict physical harm on the individuals. [13]
Statements by Russian politicians about Kazakhstan
On February 27, 2024, Russian Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu stated that non-governmental organizations in Central Asia have escalated anti-Russian activities amid Russian invasion of Ukraine. The Minister also stated that there are over 100 “large pro-Western non-governmental organizations” operating in Central Asia, with more than 16,000 branches and offices. [14]
Against the backdrop of the special military operation, these NGOs have significantly increased their anti-Russian activities aimed at undermining military-technical, economic, and cultural cooperation between the states of Central Asia and Russia. We are taking preemptive measures.
Between March 14 and 20, State Duma deputy Andrey Lugovoy released several documentary projects related to Kazakhstan. The originals of the projects were posted on Rutube under the title 'Kazakhstan's Turn' — a total of two parts were presented. In his projects, A. Lugovoy noted the increase in Russophobia in Kazakhstan and British interference in the politics of the Republic of Kazakhstan. [15]
Events after Crocus attack
After the terrorist attack on Crocus City Hall, which occurred on March 22, raids and sweeps by Russian security forces against migrants from Central Asia began in Russia. Following the detention of suspects in the attack, Russian ultranationalist and pro-war Telegram channels started calling for violence against migrants from Central Asia, suggesting deporting them along with their families." [16]
See also
References
- ^ a b c Уральские события 1991 года. Тайны и легенды
- ^
a
b Игорь Шестаков.
"Угрожает ли Казахстану региональный сепаратизм?". IAC EURASIA. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ Как русские стали «малым народом» в Казахстане
- ^ Русские в Казахстане: прошлое, настоящее и перспективы на будущее
- ^ Медведев обвинил власти Казахстана в геноциде русских и заявил о воссоздании СССР
- ^ Тимур Музаев (1999). Пограничные проблемы Российской Федерации. Информационно-экспертная группа Панорама. p. 44. Archived from the original on 2015-11-17. Retrieved 2023-10-30.
-
^ Михаил Калишевский (2014-08-22).
"Русские Казахстана – заложники "Русского Мира"?". Фергана.Ру. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) -
^ Виктор Дробин (29 November 1999).
"Аресты русских в Казахстане". 48 (313) (Завтра ed.). Archived from
the original on 2015-12-11.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ "Пугачевский бунт": Как в Восточно-Казахстанской области хотели устроить переворот
- ^ Russian 'separatists' highlight ethnic tensions Online Asia Times
-
^ Samantha Brletich (2015).
"The Crimea Model: Will Russia annex the Northern Region of Kazakhstan?" (1/2015) (Geopolitics, History, and International Relations ed.): 11–29. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ Почти 3 миллиона россиян въехало в Казахстан с начала года
- ^ В Казахстане неизвестные избивают россиян
- ^ Министр обороны России заявил, что НПО в Центральной Азии «нарастили антироссийскую деятельность»
- ^ Субъективный взгляд на «Казахстанский излом» Андрея Лугового
- ^ Залечь на дно в России. Мигранты ждут, чем закончатся призывы «усилить» и «ограничить»
External links
- A balanced narrative of Kazakh-Russian relations by a Russian emigrant from Kazakhstan
- Why Russians are leaving Kazakhstan (Central Asia Monitor)
- A first-hand account of anti-Russian sentiment in Shymkent, pointing out that Russians are more socially atomized compared to Kazakhs.
| This article includes a list of general
references, but it lacks sufficient corresponding
inline citations. (October 2023) |
| Kazakh–Russian ethnic conflicts | |||
|---|---|---|---|
| Part of Ethnic conflicts in Kazakhstan | |||
| Date | 1989 (1990) — present | ||
| Location | Kazakhstan and Russia | ||
| Methods | Protests, demonstrations, persecution, uprisings, riots, employment discrimination (particularly in public sector jobs), hostility and harassment in everyday interactions | ||
| Status | Ongoing | ||
| Parties | |||
| Lead figures | |||
Jasaral Quanyşälin Alexander Martynov | |||
| Number | |||
| |||
| Casualties and losses | |||
| |||
| 2,000,000—3,000,000 Voluntarily left from Kazakhstan [3] [4] | |||
Kazakh–Russian ethnic conflicts refers to the ethnic clashes between Kazakhs and Russians that occurred from the late 20th to early 21st century. These clashes were accompanied by riots and disorder.
Events
Kazakh–Cossack conflict of 1990
In 1990, tensions escalated between local Cossacks and Kazakh nationalists in Uralsk. On August 27, the Cossacks held a rally in the city center, where a resolution was passed demanding the invalidation of the transfer of the Ural Oblast to Kazakhstan in 1920. The organizers of the rally were fined, but the Cossacks persisted in their demands. On September 4 of the same year, the Uralsk City Council declared the Russian language the local official language.
Ural events of 1991
On September 15, 1991 the Cossacks celebrated the 400th anniversary of their service to the Russian crown in Uralsk. It was essentially the first and now the last large-scale event of the revived Ural Cossacks in 1990. Despite objections from the local administration and the mobilization of the Kazakh nationalist-patriotic organization "Azat," the Cossack leaders persisted in their preparations for the celebration, inviting hundreds of Cossacks from the Russian Federation. In response the Kazakh authorities deployed hundreds of nationalist demonstrators to Uralsk, including thousands of students and young Kazakhs from the entire Uralsk region.
On that day thousands of Kazakhs continued their protests in the square in front of the city hall, while a picket of young Kazakhs was sent to the cultural center. However, when the Cossacks began their assembly, thousands of demonstrators from the square broke through to the cultural center. According to the Cossack researcher Nikolai Fokin in his book "The Final Tragedy: Urals Cossacks in the 20th Century," thousands of Russian workers and Cossacks at the Voroshilov Plant were ready to resist the "Azat" activists.
The leaders of the Cossacks present at the cultural center that day denied any proclamations of separatist slogans, stating that it was a festive concert. They mentioned that representatives of the authorities interrupted the meeting several times, expressing concerns about their ability to restrain the "Azat" supporters. Ultimately, the crowded hall of 700 seats was quickly evacuated through the fire exit by the Cossacks, numerous observers, journalists from Russia, and local officials. [1]
Uprising in Öskemen of 1994
In 1994 some 10,000 people gathered for a rally in Öskemen, organized by the local Slavic Culture Society, demanding the establishment of a Russian autonomy in Eastern Kazakhstan, the elevation of the Russian language to the status of a state language, and the implementation of dual citizenship. In response, the presidential decree "On Measures to Regulate the Activities of Free Economic Zones" was issued, effectively revoking the resolution on the establishment of the Eastern Kazakhstan and other free economic zones. This move effectively curbed the economic foundation for separatist sentiments. [2]
Almaty conflict of 1994–1995
During this period certain representatives of the Cossack community made statements about their "readiness to use force." The speeches of Cossack activists in November and December 1994 heightened tensions in Almaty and Eastern Kazakhstan. In the same month, the activities of the "Society for the Assistance of the Semirechye Cossacks" were suspended. [6] The escalation of relations between the Cossacks and the Kazakhstani authorities ultimately led to the arrest of the ataman of the Semirechye Cossacks, Nikolai Gunkin, in the autumn of 1995. [7]
Kökşetau uprising of 1996–1997
In spring 1996 the leaders of the "Kokchetav Division of the Siberian Cossack Host," brothers Yuri and Viktor Antoshko, attempted to organize an uprising in the Kokshetau Oblast, with the aim of establishing a "state" similar to Transnistria or Abkhazia. Viktor Antoshko traveled to cities in Russia to recruit supporters who would become the striking force of the future uprising. [8]
"In March 1997, the Semirechye Cossacks came to Moscow and asked us for help, either in terms of money or manpower. We lacked funds, so we formed a unit and went there. On May 2, a Cossack assembly was planned in Kokshetau, during which the independence of the Kokshetau region was to be declared. Subsequently, the local maslikhat was supposed to vote on this declaration. In the event of a failed peaceful resolution, an armed uprising was planned. The Kazakhstani authorities made serious preparations to counter the Russian Cossack uprising. All roads, railways, and the airport were blocked. A joint operation of Russian and Kazakhstani special services was conducted to suppress the uprising. Russian special services dismantled two rebel bases in the Kurgan and Omsk Oblasts."
Pugachev's Rebellion of 1999
At the end of the last century Öskemen was in turmoil. Thousands of outraged people took to the square due to massive debts in wages, pensions, and social benefits. Some even attempted to leverage this situation for their own political gains, almost plunging the region into a civil confrontation. These events remain in the history of modern Kazakhstan as the "Pugachev Rebellion."
In the summer of 1998,Pugachev, also known as Kazimyrchuk, first appeared in Eastern Kazakhstan. He brought with him two letters of recommendation from Chernyshov to a well-known regional political figure and a radically inclined deputy of the oblast maslikhat, Ivanov, and a certain Dashkov, associated with the radical wing of the Cossack community.
In the summer of 1999 Pugachev and Chernyshov together traveled to Eastern Kazakhstan. As later established by the employees of the Department of the National Security Committee in East Kazakhstan, in coordination with the central apparatus of the agency, the leader of the "Rus" Public Opinion Organization had a plan to secede the region from Kazakhstan. However, he had not yet figured out how to implement it. During the period of Kazimyrchuk and Chernyshov's stay in Ust-Kamenogorsk, a public appeal from the East Kazakhstan region to the "Rus" Public Opinion Organization and the State Duma of the Russian Federation was prepared, primarily addressing the negative aspects of the socio-economic and political situation in the region. Requests for assistance were also included in this appeal. When Kazimyrchuk arrived in Moscow, he finally concluded that it was necessary to seize power in the East Kazakhstan region by force, for which he formed a group.
The backbone of this group consisted of Russian citizens, with one individual from Moldova. Several of Chernyshov's associates also joined them in Ust-Kamenogorsk. Weapons were purchased in Omsk: 270 rounds of 5.45 mm caliber, 4 AK-47 magazines, and an F-1 grenade–such data is preserved in the case materials.
Meanwhile,Pugachev's group made its way to Öskemen. By this time, the leader had clearly outlined to his team the specific goal of seizing power in Eastern Kazakhstan by force and establishing the autonomous formation of Russian Altai. Pugachev approached the achievement of his goal with utmost seriousness, introducing military elements into the group's management, issuing orders, reports, assigning roles internally, appointing himself as the commander, and designating his deputy and chief of staff. After the arrest, the National Security Committee conducted a search in the OPG headquarters and was surprised by the level of ideological and theoretical preparation for the coup. Among the confiscated items were books on the history and practice of anarchism, works by researchers of opposition political forces, "Declarative Positions of the Rus Public Opinion Organization," "Russian Nationalism and the National Question in Russia," "Declaration of the National Bloc," and others. [9]
On 8 June 2000 the Öskemen court sentenced 13 people, 11 Russians and 2 Kazakhs, convicted of planning to overthrow the local government and of illegal possession of weapons. The court sentenced the leader of the group, Vladimir Kazimirchuk, to 18-years imprisonment. [10]
North Kazakhstan crisis of 2000–2001
In 2000–2001 Eduard Limonov was accused of preparing an armed invasion in Kazakhstan to protect the Russian-speaking population.
In April 2001 he was imprisoned in the Lefortovo FSB investigative isolation facility on charges of possession of weapons and the creation of illegal armed formations (the charges were later dropped). On April 15, 2003, he was sentenced to 4 years of imprisonment.
Relations after the annexation of Crimea by the Russian Federation
Alexander Chebotaryov notes that "the situation in Ukraine has intensified the assessments from national-patriotic forces regarding the extent of the Russian-speaking population's loyalty to the Kazakhstan state." The lack of support for the idea of the "Russian world" from Russia can be explained by Astana's generally pro-Russian policy. Russia and Kazakhstan are united by their membership in organizations such as the CIS, CSTO, SCO, and the EAEU. The preservation of positive Kazakhstan-Russia relations is explained by Russia's desire to become an energy superpower. [11]
Russian emigration and persecution of Russians in Kazakhstan
In September–October 2022, following Vladimir Putin's mobilization announcement in Russia, over 406,000 Russians entered Kazakhstan. While the average daily immigration of Russians had been around 8,000–9,000 per day, during these days, the average daily influx of Russians reached 30,000 individuals. Despite the significant flow of incoming Russians in the last decade of September, the border and migration services ensured uninterrupted operations. Since October 1, the average daily number of incoming Russians has stabilized and does not exceed 6,000–7,000 per day. As of September 21, 3578 applications for permanent residence and 965 for citizenship have been processed. [12]
After these events unknown individuals in Kazakhstan organized patrols that interrogate incoming Russians and then assault them. These "patrols" inquire about individuals' opinions on the territorial integrity of Ukraine. If the response from the Russian does not satisfy them, they inflict physical harm on the individuals. [13]
Statements by Russian politicians about Kazakhstan
On February 27, 2024, Russian Minister of Defense Sergei Shoigu stated that non-governmental organizations in Central Asia have escalated anti-Russian activities amid Russian invasion of Ukraine. The Minister also stated that there are over 100 “large pro-Western non-governmental organizations” operating in Central Asia, with more than 16,000 branches and offices. [14]
Against the backdrop of the special military operation, these NGOs have significantly increased their anti-Russian activities aimed at undermining military-technical, economic, and cultural cooperation between the states of Central Asia and Russia. We are taking preemptive measures.
Between March 14 and 20, State Duma deputy Andrey Lugovoy released several documentary projects related to Kazakhstan. The originals of the projects were posted on Rutube under the title 'Kazakhstan's Turn' — a total of two parts were presented. In his projects, A. Lugovoy noted the increase in Russophobia in Kazakhstan and British interference in the politics of the Republic of Kazakhstan. [15]
Events after Crocus attack
After the terrorist attack on Crocus City Hall, which occurred on March 22, raids and sweeps by Russian security forces against migrants from Central Asia began in Russia. Following the detention of suspects in the attack, Russian ultranationalist and pro-war Telegram channels started calling for violence against migrants from Central Asia, suggesting deporting them along with their families." [16]
See also
References
- ^ a b c Уральские события 1991 года. Тайны и легенды
- ^
a
b Игорь Шестаков.
"Угрожает ли Казахстану региональный сепаратизм?". IAC EURASIA. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ Как русские стали «малым народом» в Казахстане
- ^ Русские в Казахстане: прошлое, настоящее и перспективы на будущее
- ^ Медведев обвинил власти Казахстана в геноциде русских и заявил о воссоздании СССР
- ^ Тимур Музаев (1999). Пограничные проблемы Российской Федерации. Информационно-экспертная группа Панорама. p. 44. Archived from the original on 2015-11-17. Retrieved 2023-10-30.
-
^ Михаил Калишевский (2014-08-22).
"Русские Казахстана – заложники "Русского Мира"?". Фергана.Ру. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) -
^ Виктор Дробин (29 November 1999).
"Аресты русских в Казахстане". 48 (313) (Завтра ed.). Archived from
the original on 2015-12-11.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ "Пугачевский бунт": Как в Восточно-Казахстанской области хотели устроить переворот
- ^ Russian 'separatists' highlight ethnic tensions Online Asia Times
-
^ Samantha Brletich (2015).
"The Crimea Model: Will Russia annex the Northern Region of Kazakhstan?" (1/2015) (Geopolitics, History, and International Relations ed.): 11–29. Archived from
the original on 2015-11-17.
{{ cite journal}}: Cite journal requires|journal=( help) - ^ Почти 3 миллиона россиян въехало в Казахстан с начала года
- ^ В Казахстане неизвестные избивают россиян
- ^ Министр обороны России заявил, что НПО в Центральной Азии «нарастили антироссийскую деятельность»
- ^ Субъективный взгляд на «Казахстанский излом» Андрея Лугового
- ^ Залечь на дно в России. Мигранты ждут, чем закончатся призывы «усилить» и «ограничить»
External links
- A balanced narrative of Kazakh-Russian relations by a Russian emigrant from Kazakhstan
- Why Russians are leaving Kazakhstan (Central Asia Monitor)
- A first-hand account of anti-Russian sentiment in Shymkent, pointing out that Russians are more socially atomized compared to Kazakhs.