General user info Username: Phantomsteve User groups: accountcreator, rollbacker First edit: May 25, 2005 19:12:20 Unique articles edited: 9,514 Average edits per page: 1.95 Total edits (including deleted): 18,514 Deleted edits: 912 Live edits: 17,602 Namespace totals Article 7587 43.10% Talk 515 2.93% User 959 5.45% User talk 5290 30.05% Wikipedia 2876 16.34% Wikipedia talk 223 1.27% File 23 0.13% File talk 2 0.01% Template 51 0.29% Template talk 45 0.26% Help 1 0.01% Help talk 9 0.05% Category 15 0.09% Category talk 5 0.03% Portal 1 0.01% Graph Month counts 2005/05 5 2005/06 6 2005/07 24 2005/08 1 2005/09 0 2005/10 0 2005/11 0 2005/12 1 2006/01 1 2006/02 0 2006/03 1 2006/04 0 2006/05 7 2006/06 16 2006/07 1 2006/08 1 2006/09 0 2006/10 1 2006/11 0 2006/12 0 2007/01 0 2007/02 0 2007/03 0 2007/04 22 2007/05 0 2007/06 0 2007/07 22 2007/08 2 2007/09 4 2007/10 5 2007/11 10 2007/12 0 2008/01 2 2008/02 12 2008/03 6 2008/04 11 2008/05 5 2008/06 2 2008/07 14 2008/08 1 2008/09 11 2008/10 11 2008/11 8 2008/12 17 2009/01 32 2009/02 7 2009/03 3 2009/04 3 2009/05 15 2009/06 189 2009/07 1003 2009/08 1199 2009/09 8916 2009/10 1429 2009/11 1888 2009/12 1445 2010/01 1216 2010/02 27 Logs Accounts created: 90 Pages moved: 86 Pages patrolled: 155 Files uploaded: 5 Top edited articles Article * 119 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor) * 58 - World_Aircraft_Information_Files * 42 - CBeebies * 36 - Dhvani_Desai * 33 - Classics_Illustrated_Junior * 29 - Classics_Illustrated * 28 - Pavel_Popovich * 21 - Gilbert_Thomas_Carter * 18 - Thornton_Heath * 18 - Something_Special_(TV_series) Talk * 81 - List_of_surviving_veterans_of_World_War_I * 32 - World_Aircraft_Information_Files * 18 - American_Technologies_Network_Corporation * 11 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor) * 10 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor)/GA1 * 9 - Step_(software) * 6 - Samuel_Zoll * 6 - Some_Mothers_Do_'Ave_'Em * 6 - Frank_Spencer's_Lullaby * 6 - Lee_Jun_Ki User * 201 - Phantomsteve * 89 - Phantomsteve/monobook.js * 77 - Phantomsteve/Rfx_contributions * 75 - Phantomsteve/welcome * 48 - Phantomsteve/Deletions * 28 - Phantomsteve/WMF_Projects * 22 - Phantomsteve/user-box/ww1-in-memoriam * 22 - Phantomsteve/Coaching * 20 - Phantomsteve/welcome/doc * 18 - Phantomsteve/er-done User talk * 477 - Phantomsteve * 32 - Juliancolton * 14 - Wiki_Greek_Basketball * 13 - Cecn * 13 - Havis1 * 12 - Dwayneflanders * 11 - Kernel.package * 10 - Silver22553 * 10 - Orangemike * 9 - Mattmartinelli8 Wikipedia * 1100 - Help_desk * 262 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 99 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents * 73 - New_contributors'_help_page * 46 - Admin_coaching/Requests_for_Coaching * 36 - Huggle/Whitelist * 29 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention * 24 - Requests_for_comment/Biographies_of_living_people * 20 - Editor_review * 17 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents/Wiki_Greek_B... Wikipedia talk * 30 - Editor_review * 25 - Requests_for_adminship * 20 - Admin_coaching/Requests_for_Coaching * 15 - Community_de-adminship/Draft_RfC * 11 - WikiProject_Automobiles * 9 - WikiProject_Biography * 7 - Help_desk * 6 - Userboxes/New_Userboxes * 5 - Noticeboard_for_India-related_topics * 4 - Requests_for_adminship/Ironholds_4 File * 4 - Iei-logo.jpg * 3 - Cambridge_House_logo.jpg * 3 - Emu_Export_Logo.jpg * 2 - SIEW_logo.jpg * 1 - Holy_Trinity_Trowbridge_north_window.JPG * 1 - Pyrotronicdisintegrator.gif * 1 - Kix_logo.jpg * 1 - Billsmallbw.jpg * 1 - Plies_Becky.jpg * 1 - American_Technologies_Network_Corporation_Logo.gif File talk * 2 - Emu_Export_Logo.jpg Template * 8 - Help_desk_templates * 5 - HD/not-saved * 4 - Schools_in_Croydon * 3 - Editor-review * 3 - Oldafdfull/doc * 3 - HD/doc * 2 - Start_date/doc * 2 - Rd3 * 2 - HD/re-attribute * 1 - User_CICS Template talk * 35 - Did_you_know * 2 - HD * 2 - Texas * 2 - Unreferenced * 1 - Solar_System_Infobox/Sun * 1 - HD/dyoh * 1 - Wikipedialang * 1 - Portal Help * 1 - Minor_edit Help talk * 9 - Template Category * 3 - Articles_lacking_sources * 2 - Mouseketeers * 1 - Children's_novels * 1 - Upcoming_mixed_martial_arts_events * 1 - Weekly_magazines * 1 - High-importance_chemicals_articles * 1 - Communism_in_the_United_States * 1 - Zambian_expatriates_in_Namibia * 1 - Guatemalans_of_Norwegian_descent * 1 - Computer_telephony_integration Category talk * 1 - Big_Brother_(UK_TV_series) * 1 - Christ's_Hospital_Old_Blues * 1 - Defunct_fast-food_chains * 1 - Guatemalans_of_Norwegian_descent * 1 - Zambian_expatriates_in_Namibia Portal * 1 - Google
Generated from X!'s tool. Pmlineditor ∞ 08:41, 2 February 2010 (UTC)
Oppose. For someone planning to work on xfDs not enough relevant experience. Lambanog ( talk) 17:12, 2 February 2010 (UTC)
I would be curious for you to provide diffs showing where I have diverged from the principles? I always look for sources of information, and I am quite happy to add these to articles if I have found them, or at the very least !vote "keep". On articles for which I cannot find sources, I am more likely to !vote "delete". If you look at my contributions, although I may not very often salvage articles which have been tagged for deletion, there are some occasions where I have done this (a recent example is Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Gorman which I sourced). I am more likely to do it with non-tagged articles such as Gilbert Thomas Carter and Pooja_Gor - also Endemism where all the references in the Ecoregions with high endemism section were found and added by myself.
I am a great believer in keeping articles which can be sourced, and removing those for which no reliable sources can be found. I am also open to changing my mind over the deletion of an article following information which gives "reasonable doubt" on the non-existence of reliable sources (such as Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gumrah (1993 film), where I initially !voted to delete, but changed to keep following persuasive arguments from SpacemanSpiff and Shreevatsa) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamada Gaku). I am also more conscious of the fact that Indian, Japanese, etc subjects may be inherently harder to source online, and the need to bear this in mind. Anyway, that's all I want to say. I understand (even if I do not agree with!) your rationale for opposing, and I would thank you for making your thoughts known in more detail. -- PhantomSteve/ talk| contribs\ 12:31, 8 February 2010 (UTC)
General user info Username: Phantomsteve User groups: accountcreator, rollbacker First edit: May 25, 2005 19:12:20 Unique articles edited: 9,514 Average edits per page: 1.95 Total edits (including deleted): 18,514 Deleted edits: 912 Live edits: 17,602 Namespace totals Article 7587 43.10% Talk 515 2.93% User 959 5.45% User talk 5290 30.05% Wikipedia 2876 16.34% Wikipedia talk 223 1.27% File 23 0.13% File talk 2 0.01% Template 51 0.29% Template talk 45 0.26% Help 1 0.01% Help talk 9 0.05% Category 15 0.09% Category talk 5 0.03% Portal 1 0.01% Graph Month counts 2005/05 5 2005/06 6 2005/07 24 2005/08 1 2005/09 0 2005/10 0 2005/11 0 2005/12 1 2006/01 1 2006/02 0 2006/03 1 2006/04 0 2006/05 7 2006/06 16 2006/07 1 2006/08 1 2006/09 0 2006/10 1 2006/11 0 2006/12 0 2007/01 0 2007/02 0 2007/03 0 2007/04 22 2007/05 0 2007/06 0 2007/07 22 2007/08 2 2007/09 4 2007/10 5 2007/11 10 2007/12 0 2008/01 2 2008/02 12 2008/03 6 2008/04 11 2008/05 5 2008/06 2 2008/07 14 2008/08 1 2008/09 11 2008/10 11 2008/11 8 2008/12 17 2009/01 32 2009/02 7 2009/03 3 2009/04 3 2009/05 15 2009/06 189 2009/07 1003 2009/08 1199 2009/09 8916 2009/10 1429 2009/11 1888 2009/12 1445 2010/01 1216 2010/02 27 Logs Accounts created: 90 Pages moved: 86 Pages patrolled: 155 Files uploaded: 5 Top edited articles Article * 119 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor) * 58 - World_Aircraft_Information_Files * 42 - CBeebies * 36 - Dhvani_Desai * 33 - Classics_Illustrated_Junior * 29 - Classics_Illustrated * 28 - Pavel_Popovich * 21 - Gilbert_Thomas_Carter * 18 - Thornton_Heath * 18 - Something_Special_(TV_series) Talk * 81 - List_of_surviving_veterans_of_World_War_I * 32 - World_Aircraft_Information_Files * 18 - American_Technologies_Network_Corporation * 11 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor) * 10 - William_Stanley_(Victorian_inventor)/GA1 * 9 - Step_(software) * 6 - Samuel_Zoll * 6 - Some_Mothers_Do_'Ave_'Em * 6 - Frank_Spencer's_Lullaby * 6 - Lee_Jun_Ki User * 201 - Phantomsteve * 89 - Phantomsteve/monobook.js * 77 - Phantomsteve/Rfx_contributions * 75 - Phantomsteve/welcome * 48 - Phantomsteve/Deletions * 28 - Phantomsteve/WMF_Projects * 22 - Phantomsteve/user-box/ww1-in-memoriam * 22 - Phantomsteve/Coaching * 20 - Phantomsteve/welcome/doc * 18 - Phantomsteve/er-done User talk * 477 - Phantomsteve * 32 - Juliancolton * 14 - Wiki_Greek_Basketball * 13 - Cecn * 13 - Havis1 * 12 - Dwayneflanders * 11 - Kernel.package * 10 - Silver22553 * 10 - Orangemike * 9 - Mattmartinelli8 Wikipedia * 1100 - Help_desk * 262 - Administrator_intervention_against_vandalism * 99 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents * 73 - New_contributors'_help_page * 46 - Admin_coaching/Requests_for_Coaching * 36 - Huggle/Whitelist * 29 - Usernames_for_administrator_attention * 24 - Requests_for_comment/Biographies_of_living_people * 20 - Editor_review * 17 - Administrators'_noticeboard/Incidents/Wiki_Greek_B... Wikipedia talk * 30 - Editor_review * 25 - Requests_for_adminship * 20 - Admin_coaching/Requests_for_Coaching * 15 - Community_de-adminship/Draft_RfC * 11 - WikiProject_Automobiles * 9 - WikiProject_Biography * 7 - Help_desk * 6 - Userboxes/New_Userboxes * 5 - Noticeboard_for_India-related_topics * 4 - Requests_for_adminship/Ironholds_4 File * 4 - Iei-logo.jpg * 3 - Cambridge_House_logo.jpg * 3 - Emu_Export_Logo.jpg * 2 - SIEW_logo.jpg * 1 - Holy_Trinity_Trowbridge_north_window.JPG * 1 - Pyrotronicdisintegrator.gif * 1 - Kix_logo.jpg * 1 - Billsmallbw.jpg * 1 - Plies_Becky.jpg * 1 - American_Technologies_Network_Corporation_Logo.gif File talk * 2 - Emu_Export_Logo.jpg Template * 8 - Help_desk_templates * 5 - HD/not-saved * 4 - Schools_in_Croydon * 3 - Editor-review * 3 - Oldafdfull/doc * 3 - HD/doc * 2 - Start_date/doc * 2 - Rd3 * 2 - HD/re-attribute * 1 - User_CICS Template talk * 35 - Did_you_know * 2 - HD * 2 - Texas * 2 - Unreferenced * 1 - Solar_System_Infobox/Sun * 1 - HD/dyoh * 1 - Wikipedialang * 1 - Portal Help * 1 - Minor_edit Help talk * 9 - Template Category * 3 - Articles_lacking_sources * 2 - Mouseketeers * 1 - Children's_novels * 1 - Upcoming_mixed_martial_arts_events * 1 - Weekly_magazines * 1 - High-importance_chemicals_articles * 1 - Communism_in_the_United_States * 1 - Zambian_expatriates_in_Namibia * 1 - Guatemalans_of_Norwegian_descent * 1 - Computer_telephony_integration Category talk * 1 - Big_Brother_(UK_TV_series) * 1 - Christ's_Hospital_Old_Blues * 1 - Defunct_fast-food_chains * 1 - Guatemalans_of_Norwegian_descent * 1 - Zambian_expatriates_in_Namibia Portal * 1 - Google
Generated from X!'s tool. Pmlineditor ∞ 08:41, 2 February 2010 (UTC)
Oppose. For someone planning to work on xfDs not enough relevant experience. Lambanog ( talk) 17:12, 2 February 2010 (UTC)
I would be curious for you to provide diffs showing where I have diverged from the principles? I always look for sources of information, and I am quite happy to add these to articles if I have found them, or at the very least !vote "keep". On articles for which I cannot find sources, I am more likely to !vote "delete". If you look at my contributions, although I may not very often salvage articles which have been tagged for deletion, there are some occasions where I have done this (a recent example is Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Larry Gorman which I sourced). I am more likely to do it with non-tagged articles such as Gilbert Thomas Carter and Pooja_Gor - also Endemism where all the references in the Ecoregions with high endemism section were found and added by myself.
I am a great believer in keeping articles which can be sourced, and removing those for which no reliable sources can be found. I am also open to changing my mind over the deletion of an article following information which gives "reasonable doubt" on the non-existence of reliable sources (such as Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Gumrah (1993 film), where I initially !voted to delete, but changed to keep following persuasive arguments from SpacemanSpiff and Shreevatsa) and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Hamada Gaku). I am also more conscious of the fact that Indian, Japanese, etc subjects may be inherently harder to source online, and the need to bear this in mind. Anyway, that's all I want to say. I understand (even if I do not agree with!) your rationale for opposing, and I would thank you for making your thoughts known in more detail. -- PhantomSteve/ talk| contribs\ 12:31, 8 February 2010 (UTC)