Follow-up discussion on Category:Art of the Passion
In categories, "in art" means in the
visual arts exclusively. Please don't add performing arts things to the category here. An "in the arts" container category can be set up if necessary.
Johnbod (
talk)
13:16, 13 March 2017 (UTC)reply
Thanks for pointing this out, Johnbod. I have carried out further changes, in effect un-merging the former contents of
Category:Passion (Christianity) and renaming it instead to
Category:Cultural depictions of the Passion of Jesus. (This gave a neat outcome in terms of category page history and wikidata links.) I am not wedded to "Cultural depictions" but it seemed a better fit than "Portrayals" or "... in the arts".
Marcocapelle, please excuse me for just doing it without waiting for your views – that was improper of me. At least I have sorted out the error introduced by my nomination. If you can support the current outcome, may I request that you add a note to your close stating that after discussions on talk pages, in which Johnbod made the above argument, the close was revised to rename the parent category instead of merging. –
FayenaticLondon21:38, 13 March 2017 (UTC)reply
Follow-up discussion on Category:Art of the Passion
In categories, "in art" means in the
visual arts exclusively. Please don't add performing arts things to the category here. An "in the arts" container category can be set up if necessary.
Johnbod (
talk)
13:16, 13 March 2017 (UTC)reply
Thanks for pointing this out, Johnbod. I have carried out further changes, in effect un-merging the former contents of
Category:Passion (Christianity) and renaming it instead to
Category:Cultural depictions of the Passion of Jesus. (This gave a neat outcome in terms of category page history and wikidata links.) I am not wedded to "Cultural depictions" but it seemed a better fit than "Portrayals" or "... in the arts".
Marcocapelle, please excuse me for just doing it without waiting for your views – that was improper of me. At least I have sorted out the error introduced by my nomination. If you can support the current outcome, may I request that you add a note to your close stating that after discussions on talk pages, in which Johnbod made the above argument, the close was revised to rename the parent category instead of merging. –
FayenaticLondon21:38, 13 March 2017 (UTC)reply