The result of the debate was speedy keep (only recently survived VFD nomination).
Lame page used for POV pointscoring and attacking users This is the ultimate nonsense page.
There are some edit wars that can deserve criticism but this page seems more about taking the piss on users than actually doing anything useful. Any attempt to enter into serious debate about the issues, or to stop the page being used itself as a weapon in edit wars becomes futile. This page in its current form is neither NPOV nor accurate, but filled with POV score-settling, often from people who are more interested in ridiculing fellow Wikipedians than in actually doing serious work themselves. It is the lamest of lame pages and deserves to be binned. FearÉIREANN\ (caint) 05:09, 29 August 2005 (UTC) reply
Other users too have been targeted on that page that way. One frequent contributor hides behind an IP rather than use his account to add in attacks on people who get in his way. It isn't a Lamest edit wars ever page as much as an Attacks on users by other users page. FearÉIREANN\ (caint) 06:57, 29 August 2005 (UTC) reply
The result of the debate was speedy keep (only recently survived VFD nomination).
Lame page used for POV pointscoring and attacking users This is the ultimate nonsense page.
There are some edit wars that can deserve criticism but this page seems more about taking the piss on users than actually doing anything useful. Any attempt to enter into serious debate about the issues, or to stop the page being used itself as a weapon in edit wars becomes futile. This page in its current form is neither NPOV nor accurate, but filled with POV score-settling, often from people who are more interested in ridiculing fellow Wikipedians than in actually doing serious work themselves. It is the lamest of lame pages and deserves to be binned. FearÉIREANN\ (caint) 05:09, 29 August 2005 (UTC) reply
Other users too have been targeted on that page that way. One frequent contributor hides behind an IP rather than use his account to add in attacks on people who get in his way. It isn't a Lamest edit wars ever page as much as an Attacks on users by other users page. FearÉIREANN\ (caint) 06:57, 29 August 2005 (UTC) reply