| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| (Dis)Establishment three-way intersections |
no consensus |
December 14
|
| 1 and 2 article Municipal Award subcategories |
delete/merge as nominated |
December 1
|
| 19th-century Russian engineers |
do not merge |
December 22
|
| 19th-century Russian lawyers |
no consensus to merge |
December 22
|
|
Category:2010 Amharic television series |
rename |
December 4
|
|
Category:2020 identifications |
delete |
December 7
|
|
Category:20th-century Puerto Rican actresses |
do not merge. At the time of this close, the category had 41 articles in it |
December 21
|
|
Category:Academics who committed suicide |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:Accidental deaths by year |
merge |
December 26
|
|
Category:Activists who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Actors involved in motorsports |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Actresses who committed suicide |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Administrative divisions of India by state or state or union territory |
do not rename (in light of discussion above), but rename
Category:Administrative divisions of India by state or state or union territory to
Category:Administrative divisions of India by state or union territory |
December 23
|
|
Category:Administrative divisions |
merge. A nomination of
Category:Types of country subdivisions for renaming could be helpful in focusing in on the naming issue highlighted by this discussion |
December 23
|
|
Category:Advocates of conspiracy theories involving Jews |
delete |
December 6
|
|
Category:AfC pending submissions by age/2 weeks ago |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:Albums recorded at Abbey Road Studios |
delete |
December 10
|
| Aldermen in the Netherlands |
merge |
December 13
|
| American and Australian people of Shanghainese descent |
merge. Full consideration of
Category:People of Shanghainese descent and its other subcategories in a new nomination is strongly recommended. They should have all been nominated together. |
December 30
|
|
Category:American anti-communists |
delete without prejudice to re-creation, either with this name or "activists". – |
December 15
|
| American anti-socialists |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:American Baptists by state |
rename to
Category:Baptists from the United States by state or territory |
December 1
|
|
Category:American Basketball Association flagship television stations |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:American Catholic writers |
Merge as suggested. There is a consensus that they should be merged by no consensus on exact name. So, defaulting to the old name |
December 1
|
|
Category:American educator-politicians |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:American film score composers of Indian descent |
merge as nominated and to
Category:American film people of Indian descent |
December 13
|
|
Category:American Football Association (1978–1983) |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
December 16
|
| American infrastructure categories |
rename all except the New York state and city categories. This is without prejudice to a future discussion on the New York categories |
December 22
|
| American librarians of Asian descent |
do not merge |
December 30
|
| American male actors of Asian descent |
keep as container category. This is without prejudice to a future nomination that includes the subcategories |
December 30
|
|
Category:American military personnel who served in the Pacific theatre of World War II |
delete.
Category:Doolittle Raiders and
Category:Navajo code talkers have been placed in
Category:Pacific theatre of World War II |
December 25
|
|
Category:American novelists of Indian descent |
do not merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:American people of Wenzhounese descent |
merge. Full consideration of
Category:People of Wenzhounese descent and its other subcategories in a new nomination is strongly recommended. They should have all been nominated together. |
December 30
|
| American people of Wu descent |
merge. Full consideration of
Category:People of Wu descent and its other subcategories in a new nomination is strongly recommended. They should have all been nominated together |
December 30
|
| American people of Zhejiang descent |
merge. Full consideration of
Category:People of Zhejiang descent and its other subcategories in a new nomination is strongly recommended. They should have all been nominated together. |
December 30
|
|
Category:American scientists of Italian descent |
delete |
December 24
|
|
Category:American women novelists of Indian descent |
merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:American X of Y descent |
merge. Merging will result in the deletion of the nominated categories. Several of the "delete" comments were unclear as to whether the articles in the nominated categories should be merged as nominated. I have erred on the side of caution and performed a merge for the affected articles. The target categories were not nominated |
December 29
|
|
Category:Amharic crime drama television series |
rename |
December 4
|
|
Category:Andrey Danilko albums |
merge. There has been no effort to rename the article at this stage, but if it is renamed then the categories could be renamed to match |
December 8
|
| Anglican congregations |
delete |
December 6
|
|
Category:Animals in War & Peace Medal of Bravery |
delete |
December 12
|
|
Category:Animated television series featuring female protagonists |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Anthropornis |
merge |
December 2
|
|
Category:Anti-LGBT politicians who were outed |
delete |
December 2
|
|
Category:Apabhraṃśa-language literature |
delete |
December 30
|
| Arab-American feminists |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Archaeological type sites |
no consensus |
December 13
|
|
Category:Architects of the Liturgical Movement in the UK |
rename |
December 27
|
| Architecture and landmarks by city in Sri Lanka |
merge |
December 19
|
| Architecture and landmarks in Sri Lanka by district |
Merge all |
December 31
|
| Armenian diaspora categories |
merge |
December 5
|
|
Category:Articles containing Old English (ca. 450-1100)-language text |
withdrawn: see
here for more information |
December 23
|
|
Category:Articles with validated CAS Registry Numbers |
delete |
December 9
|
|
Category:Artists who committed suicide |
no consensus |
December 29
|
|
Category:Asia Minor disaster |
rename to
Category:Greco-Turkish War (1919–1922) leaving behind a
category redirect.
(non-admin closure) |
December 17
|
| Asian-American Biblical scholars |
merge. Some proposed categories were discussed. One or more of these can be pursued if editors think they would be meaningful categories within the categorization guidelines |
December 30
|
| Asian-American diplomats |
merge |
December 30
|
| Asian-American farmers |
delete
Category:Asian-American farmers; rename
Category:Japanese-American farmers to
Category:American farmers of Japanese descent |
December 30
|
| Asian-American female models |
delete, merging content to
Category:American female models. |
December 30
|
| Asian-American feminists |
delete |
December 30
|
| Asian-American skateboarders |
merge. There was consensus that the nominated category should not exist, but there was no consensus on whether it should be a merge or an outright deletion without a merge. I am defaulting to merge to retain the categorization information |
December 30
|
|
Category:Association football in the United States lists |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Automotive businesspeople |
Reverse merge.
(non-admin closure) |
December 3
|
|
Category:Aviators who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Aviti |
delete |
December 31
|
|
Category:AWAL singles |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:AwesomenessTV |
speedy Rename.
(non-admin closure) |
December 8
|
|
Category:Bad literature |
delete |
December 12
|
| Badulla |
merge/delete |
December 13
|
|
Category:Ballarat Red Devils players |
rename |
December 8
|
|
Category:Banijay Group franchises |
rename |
December 5
|
|
Category:Banijay Group |
rename |
December 3
|
|
Category:Banjar |
rename |
December 1
|
| Baptist congregations |
manual merge, based on the discussion here and related categories (noted in this discussion) that were discussed is separate nominations. Following the lead of
Fayenatic london, in the cases where the congregations were established in an earlier century than the buildings, I moved them up to, e.g.,
Category:Baptist organizations established in the 18th century |
December 23
|
|
Category:Baseball venues in Abilene, Texas |
merge to
Category:Sports venues in Abilene, Texas and
Category:Baseball in Abilene, Texas.
(non-admin closure) |
December 16
|
|
Category:Baseball venues in North Texas |
merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:Baseball venues in the Texas Panhandle |
merge |
December 18
|
| Basketball players by city or town in the United States |
no consensus |
December 1
|
|
Category:Basshunter unreleased songs |
delete |
December 4
|
|
Category:Billboard Hot Country Songs number-one singles |
delete |
December 15
|
| Black English people (continued) |
merge |
December 21
|
|
Category:Boating accident deaths |
keep, noting that this discussion has led to
Category:Water transport deaths being added as a helpful new parent over the nominated category and the target. – |
December 23
|
|
Category:Books about the Afrikaner Weerstandsbeweging |
merge |
December 31
|
|
Category:Bosnian Genocide deniers |
keep. Users can remove articles that do not belong. There was some support for a rename. This is probably best pursued in a new nomination which can focus on the renaming issue. |
December 1
|
|
Category:Bougainvillean activists |
do not merge
Category:Bougainvillean activists; merge
Category:Bougainvillean women's rights activists to
Category:Papua New Guinean women's rights activists and
Category:Bougainvillean activists |
December 14
|
|
Category:Broadway actors |
delete |
December 11
|
| Buyid governors |
merge |
December 19
|
|
Category:C-type stars |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Career-oriented social networking markets |
rename |
December 7
|
|
Category:Carroll College (Montana) |
do not rename |
December 18
|
|
Category:Category:Puerto-Rican television talk show hosts |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:Catholic Church councils in the Middle Ages |
delete |
December 19
|
|
Category:Centaurs (minor planets) |
rename |
December 24
|
| Centuries in Roman Egypt |
rename/merge |
December 21
|
|
Category:Chamber virtuosi of the Duke of Parma |
merge to
Category:Court musicians |
December 26
|
| Children of sultans |
delete |
December 18
|
|
Category:Children of Sunni monarchs |
delete, merging contents to
Category:Children of monarchs |
December 15
|
|
Category:Chilean neo-Nazis |
merge per nom and to
Category:Chilean fascists |
December 2
|
|
Category:China orchestras |
no consensus. There was good discussion and I feel that this was inching closer to a consensus. I would recommend a re-nomination in order to clarify the proposal that has been discussed. I think if the discussion was clearer on what the current proposal is it would attract more comments. Also,
Category:Chinese orchestras was not tagged with
Template:Cfr |
December 17
|
|
Category:China Shipping Group |
merge to
Category:COSCO. That category has been nominated for renaming
here. |
December 4
|
|
Category:Christmas Island support structures |
merge |
December 31
|
|
Category:Churches by patron saint |
delete |
December 31
|
|
Category:Clans of Hao |
delete. — |
December 3
|
|
Category:Clergy who committed suicide |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:Cnidarians of Ireland |
merge |
December 13
|
| Collegiate affiliations |
delete |
December 13
|
| Combined Asian American Resource Project |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Communes of the Province of Florence and similar |
merge |
December 13
|
|
Category:Conspiracy theorists |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
December 5
|
|
Category:Converge ICT |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:Corneal transplant recipients |
delete |
December 15
|
|
Category:Corsican nationalist assassins |
merge to
Category:Corsican nationalists and
Category:Nationalist assassins |
December 9
|
|
Category:COSCO |
rename |
December 12
|
|
Category:COVID Recovery Group members |
no consensus |
December 4
|
|
Category:Crazy Taxi |
delete; merging contents as appropriate to subcategories' |
December 20
|
|
Category:Cricket in Sri Lanka by province |
rename |
December 17
|
|
Category:Criminals who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Croatian independence activists |
no consensus |
December 8
|
|
Category:Cuban atheists |
Delete.
(non-admin closure) |
December 16
|
|
Category:Currencies of the Kingdom of Damot |
delete |
December 10
|
|
Category:Currencies of the Kingdom of Wolaita |
merge to
Category:Currencies of Africa.
(non-admin closure) |
December 2
|
| Dambulla |
withdrawn (
non-admin closure) |
December 6
|
|
Category:Danielle Johnson (musician) albums |
rename |
December 15
|
|
Category:Deadpool films |
merge |
December 10
|
|
Category:Death of Sohrabuddin Sheikh |
delete |
December 27
|
|
Category:Deaths from plague (disease) |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
December 29
|
|
Category:Defunct Right Opposition Marxist–Leninist parties in the United States |
merge to
Category:Defunct Marxist–Leninist parties in the United States.
(non-admin closure) |
December 5
|
|
Category:Degree Colleges in Kashmir |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:Deniers of Serbian genocide in Croatia |
rename |
December 18
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Bulgaria |
merge |
December 13
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Croatia |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Egypt |
merge |
December 13
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Kyiv |
rename |
December 21
|
|
Category:Destroyed landmarks in Romania |
merge |
December 13
|
|
Category:Detention |
speedy rename. – |
December 23
|
|
Category:Diplomats by ethnicity |
merge/delete as nominated |
December 26
|
|
Category:Diseases in the trenches |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Doctors who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Dream Chronicles |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Drivers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:Dunkin' Brands |
merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:Duolingo users |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:Eastern Region, Macedonia geography stubs |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:Economics of service industries |
rename to
Category:Services sector of the economy |
December 29
|
|
Category:Ediacaran biota |
rename |
December 9
|
|
Category:Education sites affected by shootings in the United States |
delete. (It looks to me like these are already listed at
List of school shootings in the United States.) |
December 16
|
|
Category:Endangered species of the British Isles |
delete |
December 11
|
|
Category:Entertainers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 31
|
|
Category:Eponymous priests of Alexander |
rename |
December 6
|
| Establishments in Slovakia during the Kingdom of Hungary (11th century through 1918) |
no consensus. As in various similar cases, several editors argue that even though these categories are anachronistic, they are of use to some readers of the encyclopedia. The suggestion to use "Upper Hungary" as an approximate forerunner territory to Slovakia might be a useable compromise in this case, but it did not receive much comment here and would require a fresh nomination. – |
December 11
|
| Establishments in Slovakia |
no consensus |
December 9
|
|
Category:Ethically disputed scientific practices |
rename to
Category:Ethically disputed research practices |
December 25
|
|
Category:Etimesgut Şekerspor footballers |
rename as nominated.– |
December 30
|
|
Category:Extended centaurs |
merge to
Category:Centaurs (minor planets) and
Category:Trans-Neptunian objects, but in light of the result of the discussion immediately below this one, merge to
Category:Centaurs (small Solar System bodies) and
Category:Trans-Neptunian objects |
December 24
|
|
Category:Female suicides |
convert to container category, which will hold
Category:Female suicide bombers and
Category:People who committed sati. Remove the articles from the category. This category can be renominated for further discussion as needed. |
December 31
|
| Fiction about astronomical locations |
rename |
December 24
|
|
Category:Fiction about Earth |
do not rename |
December 24
|
| Fictional Asian-American people |
no consensus to rename or delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Fictional male deities |
rename |
December 26
|
|
Category:Fictional males by occupation |
keep |
December 26
|
|
Category:Fictional murdered people |
keep. – |
December 1
|
|
Category:Fictional space pilots |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
December 8
|
|
Category:Fictional victims of kidnapping |
delete |
December 9
|
|
Category:Fictional victims |
delete, merging contents per
Fayenatic london's suggestion |
December 8
|
|
Category:Films about nuclear accidents and incidents |
do not rename |
December 18
|
|
Category:Films by demographic |
merge |
December 7
|
|
Category:Films featuring anthropomorphic mice |
rename to
Category:Animated films about mice. There is a rough consensus to rename to "Animated films about ..." something. In considering "mice and rats" or "rodents", I noted that
Category:Animated films about rats already exists and is separate from the categories about mice. So renaming to the mice option for now; users could propose that it be merged with
Category:Animated films about rats in a future nomination, because the parent category is a combined
Category:Films about mice and rats. |
December 17
|
|
Category:Films who won Saturn Award for Best Science Fiction Film |
rename, or at least merge confirmed. A fresh nomination to focus solely on whether or not to keep
Category:Best Science Fiction Film Saturn Award winners could be held, as not all participants gave views on that |
December 31
|
|
Category:Finnish neo-Nazis |
merge to
Category:Neo-Nazis.
(non-admin closure) |
December 2
|
|
Category:Footballers from Milan |
do not merge, pending the upcoming RFC |
December 21
|
| Footballers who switched code |
no consensus |
December 4
|
|
Category:Formerly missing people found dead |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Formerly unidentified murder victims |
delete |
December 6
|
|
Category:Formerly unidentified people |
delete |
December 4
|
|
Category:Fortified frontiers |
merge |
December 24
|
|
Category:Fortnite Battle Royale guest characters |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:Fossil insects of Africa |
Rename as nominated, to match "prehistoric" parents.
(non-admin closure) |
December 5
|
|
Category:Freemen of the City of Canterbury |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:Fútbol Alcobendas Sport players |
rename |
December 31
|
|
Category:Game development |
delete |
December 14
|
|
Category:Game Source Entertainment |
delete |
December 7
|
|
Category:Genocide deniers |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:Genocide of Serbs in the Independent State of Croatia denial |
merge |
December 19
|
|
Category:German service people |
merge. Whether to categorize
Bayume Mohamed Husen in the target category can be hashed out on the article talk page, if needed |
December 2
|
|
Category:Giro d'Italia cyclists |
delete. The subcategories were moved to
Category:Giro d'Italia.
Category:Tour de France cyclists and
Category:Vuelta a España cyclists were mentioned as parallel cases but were not nominated in this nomination. |
December 16
|
| Gliese 682 |
delete, merging content to
Category:Gliese and GJ objects |
December 31
|
|
Category:Grand Crosses of the National Order of the Ivory Coast |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Grand Masters of the Order of Petrovic Njegos |
delete |
December 7
|
|
Category:Grand Order of King Tomislav recipients |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:Handel Medallion recipients |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:Harisu |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:HBO Family |
upmerge to
Category:HBO original programming, now that it has been purged, with thanks to |
December 30
|
|
Category:Helvia (gens) |
rename to
Category:Helvii (Romans)
|
December 6
|
| Heterocyclic compounds according to element |
keep |
December 3
|
|
Category:Higher-level bird taxa restricted to the Oriental region |
rename to
Category:Endemic birds of East Asia |
December 9
|
|
Category:Historic places in Brazil |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Historic places in Estonia |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Hochschule für Musik und Tanz Köln alumni |
reverse merge without prejudice to switch back if the article is renamed to the English name |
December 2
|
|
Category:Homeland War Memorial Medal recipients |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:Hong Kong Pegasus FC |
rename |
December 8
|
|
Category:Honorary Members of Xirka Ġieħ ir-Repubblika |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:House of Leuven |
merge; do not rename to "Reginarids" |
December 27
|
|
Category:Houses of scientists in Russia |
merge |
December 6
|
|
Category:Houses of scientists in Ukraine |
merge |
December 10
|
|
Category:Human body diagrams |
merge |
December 15
|
|
Category:Hungarian neo-Nazis |
merge to
Category:Neo-Nazis.
(non-admin closure) |
December 2
|
|
Category:Hunter Marine |
rename |
December 3
|
|
Category:Hydroelectric power plants in the United States by state |
rename |
December 3
|
|
Category:Höfner |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:Illegitimate children of Ottoman sultans |
merge |
December 18
|
|
Category:Illegitimate children of Roman monarchs |
merge |
December 18
|
| Immigrants to the Thirteen Colonies |
keep. – |
December 15
|
|
Category:Imperial Austrian emigrants |
rename |
December 4
|
| Imperial Russian physicians |
rename to
Category:Physicians of the Russian Empire. This has already been implemented because the nominator also included this category in the nomination at
Wikipedia:Categories_for_discussion/Log/2020_December_3#Russian_Empire_people. – |
December 15
|
| Imperial Russian principals |
rename |
December 9
|
| Imperial Russian prisoners of war |
rename |
December 14
|
|
Category:Incest in video games |
delete |
December 22
|
| Indian magnetic persons |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Indinan Town Templates |
delete |
December 4
|
|
Category:Industrial City |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:Industry (manufacturing) |
rename, keep a redirect |
December 29
|
| Industry |
rename |
December 20
|
| Internal exiles |
keep. – |
December 15
|
|
Category:Invasive fish species in Ukraine |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Iranian artifacts abroad |
delete |
December 19
|
|
Category:Iryna Bilyk |
delete |
December 10
|
| Italian communes |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Italian language outside Italy |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:Italian painters by city |
rename |
December 18
|
|
Category:Jammu |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:Jewish Japanologists |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:Jimmie Rodgers (country singer) |
delete |
December 14
|
|
Category:JoJo Siwa |
delete |
December 7
|
|
Category:Jose Mari Chan |
speedy delete per
G5 |
December 31
|
|
Category:Jurists who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
| Katagami, Aichi |
(speedy) delete |
December 31
|
|
Category:Korea Image Awards Winners |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Kratovo, Macedonia |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:Latin American Spring |
delete |
December 23
|
| Latinx-American skakeboarders |
merge. There was consensus that the nominated category should not exist, but there was no consensus on whether it should be a merge or an outright deletion without a merge. I am defaulting to merge to retain the categorization information |
December 30
|
|
Category:Lemniscatic elliptic functions |
delete |
December 17
|
|
Category:List of celebrities who served in the Indian military |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:List of ethnic enclaves in the Philippine Cities |
convert |
December 10
|
|
Category:Lists of association football stadiums in the United States |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Lists of Polish gminas |
delete, merging content to
Category:Lists of municipalities |
December 5
|
|
Category:Live Well Network affiliates |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Lost fossils |
delete |
December 6
|
| Lutheran congregations |
merge |
December 18
|
|
Category:Male actors who committed suicide |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Male suicides |
delete |
December 31
|
|
Category:Male writers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Maskil |
merge. Nominated category was empty at close. |
December 19
|
|
Category:Maskilim |
no consensus to delete. A proposal to rename as discussed by some editors could be made in a new nomination |
December 31
|
| Mayors in Overijssel |
merge |
December 8
|
| Mayors in South Holland |
merge |
December 23
|
| Mayors in Utrecht (province) |
merge |
December 3
|
| Mayors of places in Azerbaijan |
merge |
December 20
|
| Mayors of places in Brazil |
merge |
December 26
|
| Mayors of places in France |
merge |
December 28
|
| Mayors of places in Indonesia |
Merge all |
December 31
|
| Mayors of places in Israel |
merge |
December 12
|
| Mayors of places in Japan |
merge |
December 18
|
| Mayors of places in Madhya Pradesh |
merge |
December 6
|
| Mayors of places in Russia |
merge |
December 30
|
| Mayors of places in Slovenia |
merge |
December 25
|
| Mayors of places in Ukraine |
merge |
December 29
|
| Mayors of places in West Virginia |
merge |
December 27
|
|
Category:Members of the Provincial-Council of the Netherlands by province |
rename |
December 12
|
|
Category:Members of the Provincial-Executive of the Netherlands by province |
rename |
December 13
|
| Michigan ballot proposals |
merge |
December 4
|
|
Category:Midnight Club |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Military decorations and medals of South Africa in order of precedence |
delete |
December 23
|
| Military personnel who committed suicide |
no consensus |
December 29
|
|
Category:Models who committed suicide |
delete |
December 23
|
|
Category:Modern names of Latin origin |
delete |
December 19
|
|
Category:Morgan Prize winners |
delete |
December 10
|
|
Category:Mosques converted from churches by the Republic of Turkey |
It was difficult to find a consensus here, but I think there is one that is admittedly "rough". There seems to be consensus to rename
Category:Mosques converted from churches by the Republic of Turkey to
Category:Mosques converted from churches in Turkey. There is no consensus to merge
Category:Mosques converted from churches by the Ottoman Empire into that same category, so by default I am keeping the "Ottoman Empire", which results in
Category:Mosques converted from churches in the Ottoman Empire. This is without prejudice to a nomination for
Category:Mosques converted from churches in the Ottoman Empire which can focus more on the "what country to use" question |
December 30
|
|
Category:Movie Central original programming |
merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:Movie memes |
delete |
December 24
|
|
Category:Mr Nigeria |
delete |
December 4
|
|
Category:Multiple Units of India |
speedy rename
WP:C2C. – |
December 30
|
| Murder victims by occupation |
it was a bit difficult to take the comments and summarize them into a coherent close, but the suggestions by the nominator seem appropriate to me. So that's delete
Category:Murdered artists,
Category:Murdered bankers,
Category:Murdered designers,
Category:Murdered filmmakers,
Category:Murdered models, and
Category:Murdered physicians. Withdrawn nominations for
Category:Murdered explorers,
Category:Murdered lawyers, and
Category:Murdered revolutionaries. |
December 21
|
|
Category:Murdered Milanese mobsters |
merge |
December 18
|
|
Category:Musicians who committed suicide |
delete |
December 24
|
|
Category:Nadeem Beyg |
rename |
December 13
|
|
Category:Named corners of raceways |
rename per amended nomination |
December 13
|
|
Category:Named squadrons of the Royal Navy |
merge |
December 6
|
|
Category:Nation of Language EPs |
delete |
December 10
|
|
Category:National Basketball Association over-the-air television broadcasters |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:National Basketball Players Association vice presidents |
delete |
December 11
|
| Nationalist assassins |
merge |
December 11
|
| Nazis who committed suicide by method |
merge |
December 30
|
|
Category:New Radiant SC players |
rename for now. If the article moves to
New Radiant SC then this and the related categories that were mentioned can be moved |
December 8
|
|
Category:New Zealand neo-Nazis |
merge to
Category:New Zealand fascists.
(non-admin closure) |
December 2
|
|
Category:Nobel laureates absent at the ceremony |
delete and reparent respectively |
December 11
|
|
Category:Nord-du-Québec in fiction |
delete |
December 9
|
| Northeastern and Southeastern Iranian |
merge both to
Category:Eastern Iranian languages |
December 30
|
|
Category:Northeastern Region, Macedonia geography stubs |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:NZIA Gold Medal-winning buildings |
delete |
December 18
|
|
Category:Obselete denominations of the Philippine peso |
rename |
December 19
|
|
Category:Organizations in 2000 |
delete |
December 27
|
|
Category:Outright Scotland people |
delete |
December 9
|
| Over&underpopulated stub cats |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Panamanian medical doctors |
rename to
Category:Panamanian physicians.
(non-admin closure) |
December 10
|
|
Category:Participants in the Moscow Victory Day Parade of 1945 |
delete |
December 25
|
|
Category:Participants in the Norway Debate |
delete |
December 25
|
| People by populated place in Austria |
merge |
December 4
|
|
Category:People from Fyli (municipality) |
merge |
December 6
|
|
Category:People from Ioannina (municipality) |
merge (taking into account the
discussion below). |
December 4
|
|
Category:People from Katerini (municipality) |
merge |
December 4
|
|
Category:People from Kratovo, Macedonia |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:People from Moreau, New York |
merge |
December 24
|
|
Category:People from Providence, New York |
merge |
December 28
|
|
Category:People frοm Arta (municipality) |
no consensus.
(non-admin closure) |
December 15
|
|
Category:People murdered by the Kansas City crime family |
delete |
December 5
|
|
Category:People with acquired Belgian citizenship |
merge |
December 23
|
|
Category:Period post Ninth Crusade |
rename to
Category:Military history of the Crusader states after Lord Edward's crusade. There was a strong consensus to rename, but the issue that was never really resolved was what name should be selected. Since there was a consensus to rename to something, I have used the form that matches those selected in
this discussion. As with the previous discussion, future nominations can be made to tweak the names, if desired. |
December 9
|
|
Category:Philosophers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Physical properties |
merge |
December 16
|
|
Category:Places named for Christopher Columbus |
delete |
December 5
|
|
Category:Planners |
rename to
Category:Planners (games). No consensus on deletion. I would suggest any further discussion on the matter should be done together with other categories in the tree.
(non-admin closure) |
December 30
|
|
Category:Players of American football from Detroit |
Withdrawn. pending outcome of an RfC.
(non-admin closure) |
December 16
|
|
Category:Poisonous plants |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Politicians by regional unit of Greece |
merge |
December 3
|
|
Category:Politicians by second-level administrative country subdivision |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Politicians from Corfu (regional unit) |
merge |
December 5
|
|
Category:Politicians from Hopkinton, Rhode Island |
merge |
December 24
|
| Politicians who committed suicide |
no consensus |
December 29
|
|
Category:Pornographic film actors who committed suicide |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Postage stamps of the Republic of Ireland |
keep |
December 6
|
| Presbyterian congregations |
merge and rename to "churches", i.e. to
Category:18th-century Presbyterian churches,
Category:19th-century Presbyterian churches and
Category:20th-century Presbyterian churches. – |
December 21
|
|
Category:Prix de Flore winners |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Problem solving television series |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:Professional Rugby union leagues in Americas |
manually merge. Everybody (including nominator) wants to delete the mis-named category. The question is whether there is an agreed destination. At the time of closing, there are only 2 entries remaining. Therefore manual merge.
(non-admin closure) |
December 1
|
|
Category:Prominent members of the Oxford University L'Chaim Society |
delete |
December 12
|
|
Category:Proposed monuments |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Proposed states and territories of India |
rename |
December 20
|
| Protestant congregations established in the 16th century |
split |
December 27
|
| Protestant congregations established in the 17th-20th century |
manual merge |
December 27
|
|
Category:Protoscience |
delete. (All of the articles in it at the time of this close are in
Category:History of science or a subcategory of it.) |
December 7
|
|
Category:Pupils of Nadia Boulanger |
Delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Radio City Music Hall Rockettes |
rename to
Category:The Rockettes |
December 2
|
|
Category:Recipients of Geuzenpenning |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Bledisloe Medal |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Gottlieb Duttweiler Prize |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Indira Gandhi Peace Prize |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Recipients of the National Order of Benin |
delete |
December 4
|
|
Category:Recipients of the National Order of Chad |
delete |
December 2
|
|
Category:Recipients of the National Order of Madagascar |
delete |
December 17
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Altruism |
delete |
December 14
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Boyaca |
delete |
December 19
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Charity (Ottoman Empire) |
delete |
December 3
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of José Marti |
delete |
December 11
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Justice (Iran) |
delete |
December 29
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Merit (Cameroon) |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Mono |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Saemaeul Service Merit |
delete |
December 2
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of St. Alexander Nevsky |
delete |
December 17
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Cloud and Banner |
delete |
December 10
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Liberator |
delete |
December 18
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Patriotic War, 1st class |
delete |
December 27
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Queen of Sheba |
delete |
December 12
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Seal of Solomon |
delete |
December 21
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Star of Anjouan |
delete |
December 19
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Two Niles |
delete |
December 20
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the White Double Cross |
delete |
December 24
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Prime Minister's Medal of Appreciation |
delete |
December 24
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Royal Order of Cambodia |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Royal Order of the Intare |
delete |
December 22
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Silver Beaver Award |
delete |
December 14
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Silver Buffalo Award |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Silver Wolf Award (The Scout Association) |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Through Art – to Peace and Understanding |
delete |
December 21
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Timor-Leste Solidarity Medal |
delete |
December 7
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Warsaw Cross of the Uprising |
merge |
December 27
|
|
Category:Records |
Rename. World records is currently a subcategory.
(non-admin closure) |
December 2
|
|
Category:Redirects from historic names |
merge. If the target category is not ideally named, it could be nominated for renaming |
December 6
|
|
Category:Right Livelihood Award laureates |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Rightly Guided Caliphs of Sunni Islam |
speedy delete G5, |
December 15
|
|
Category:Royalty who committed suicide |
delete;
Marcocapelle has helpfully suggested where the contents should be merged to upon category deletion, so I will do that |
December 23
|
| Russian Empire people |
rename to
Category:People of the Russian Empire, etc, but using "from" rather than "of" for historians, geographers, geologists and emigrants per siblings. – |
December 3
|
| Russian officials in Congress Poland |
rename to
Category:Government officials of Congress Poland. – |
December 10
|
| Saint Mary's Redmen football |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:San Marino and Rimini's Coast motorcycle Grand Prix |
rename |
December 28
|
|
Category:Sanskrit declension |
merge to
Category:Declension.
(non-admin closure) |
December 30
|
|
Category:Sanskrit language and history |
merge to
Category:Sanskrit.
(non-admin closure) |
December 30
|
|
Category:Sanskrit-language activists |
merge |
December 30
|
|
Category:Screenplay (TV series) |
rename to
Category:ScreenPlay |
December 30
|
|
Category:Scripts by Paruchuri Brothers |
rename to
Category:Films with screenplays by the Paruchuri brothers |
December 21
|
|
Category:Sex-related article shared content templates |
merge (no opposition), but nominated category was empty at the time of this close |
December 26
|
|
Category:Silver Crosses of the Order of Honour (Greece) |
withdrawn by nominator.
(non-admin closure) Zeke, the Mad Horrorist |
December 4
|
|
Category:Six western palaces |
merge to
Category:Forbidden City.
(non-admin closure) |
December 4
|
|
Category:Software that uses installCore |
delete |
December 5
|
|
Category:Song recordings produced by Anthony M. Jones |
keep, only because it contains a non-redirect article. It can be nominated again if users think it is still too small. |
December 29
|
|
Category:Song recordings produced by Dave Longstreth |
keep, only because now it contains non-redirect articles |
December 29
|
|
Category:Song recordings produced by Shea Taylor |
keep, only because it is well populated now |
December 29
|
|
Category:Song recordings produced by Sir Dylan |
keep, only because it contains a non-redirect article. It can be nominated again if users think it is still too small |
December 29
|
|
Category:South Korean television series based on non-South Korean television series |
merge to
Category:South Korean television series based on non-South Korean television series.
(non-admin closure) |
December 1
|
|
Category:Southeastern Region, Macedonia geography stubs |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:Southwestern Region, Macedonia geography stubs |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:Speeches by writer |
rename |
December 15
|
|
Category:Sports events held in a bubble due to the COVID-19 pandemic |
delete. — |
December 18
|
|
Category:Sportseople from West Nusa Tenggara |
speedy delete per criterion R3, which while it says "recently created"
WP:COMMONSENSE/
WP:IAR applies here |
December 15
|
|
Category:Sportspeople by city or town in Greece |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
December 5
|
|
Category:Sportspeople who committed suicide |
delete |
December 27
|
|
Category:Starfleet doctors |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Starfleet nurses |
merge with
Category:Starfleet doctors into a new
Category:Starfleet medical personnel |
December 23
|
|
Category:Starman films |
rename |
December 5
|
|
Category:States-Provincial of the Netherlands |
rename |
December 11
|
|
Category:Street Fighter (1970s series) films |
rename |
December 20
|
|
Category:Students who committed suicide |
no consensus |
December 23
|
|
Category:Subdivisions of India |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Subdivisions of Russia |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Subdivisions of the United States |
rename |
December 23
|
|
Category:Suburbs in Colombo District |
delete |
December 3
|
| Suicide by period |
rename |
December 24
|
|
Category:Suicides by method |
keep/do not merge |
December 18
|
| Suicides by occupation |
delete |
December 12
|
|
Category:Suicides by occupation |
Procedural withdrawal by relister, as all subcategories have not yet been nominated, and there was no consensus on those discussed. Individual subcategories should be renominated.
(non-admin closure) |
December 21
|
|
Category:Taipei Metro stations by line |
merge to
Category:Taipei Metro stations.
(non-admin closure) |
December 11
|
| Taito arcade system board categories |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
December 29
|
|
Category:Tamil archaeologists |
delete, merging content to
Category:Indian archaeologists. |
December 1
|
|
Category:Television series about suburbia |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:Television series based on Street Fighter |
rename |
December 20
|
|
Category:Ten Outstanding Young Persons of the World |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:The Dragon Prince characters |
delete |
December 8
|
|
Category:The Masked Singer (American TV series) contestants |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:The NHL Network (1975–79) affiliates |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:The WB network affiliates |
delete |
December 16
|
|
Category:Tour de France cyclists |
delete and reparent the subcategories as indicated |
December 27
|
|
Category:Train drivers |
keep |
December 15
|
|
Category:Transcendental Meditation practitioners |
delete |
December 30
|
|
Category:Treasurer of Berwick |
rename (option A) |
December 8
|
|
Category:Tributes by person |
do as nominated (no opposition, open for almost a month) |
December 9
|
|
Category:Tropical cyclone effects by region |
merge to
Category:Lists of tropical cyclones by area |
December 27
|
|
Category:TVS Television Network affiliates |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Two-thousanders of Macedonia |
rename |
December 27
|
|
Category:UD Granadilla Tenerife Sur players |
rename |
December 10
|
|
Category:UK Lockdown Critics |
delete |
December 2
|
|
Category:United States topic navigational boxes |
no consensus.
(non-admin closure) |
December 23
|
|
Category:United States Women's Land Army members (World War II) |
rename to
Category:Woman's Land Army of America members. Note "Woman's" not "Women's" as that is the correct spelling the subject used |
December 14
|
| Universities by city and district in Sri Lanka |
merge/delete as nominated |
December 24
|
| University of South Florida Athletic Hall of Fame |
delete |
December 1
|
|
Category:Vertebrates of Algeria |
Delete |
December 9
|
|
Category:Video game leaks |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:War crimes committed by the Home Army |
no consensus. However, the category was empty when I closed it, so I have deleted it. Due to the no consensus result, the category may be re-created if populated. Given the nature of the category, care should be taken in populating it – these things should be well-sourced |
December 23
|
|
Category:Water Polo players at the 1955 Pan American Games |
rename |
December 3
|
| Water supply companies in Malaysia |
merge |
December 13
|
|
Category:West Texas |
delete
Category:West Texas, merge
Category:Baseball venues in West Texas to
Category:Baseball venues in Texas |
December 17
|
|
Category:Wikisource Administrators |
delete |
December 27
|
|
Category:Women writers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
|
Category:Writers who committed suicide by nationality |
delete |
December 28
|
| Writers who committed suicide |
delete |
December 28
|
| XFL categories |
delete. If anyone wants to create disambiguation categories for any of these, it could be done |
December 30
|
|
Category:XIX Entertainment singles |
delete |
December 26
|
|
Category:Yakuza films |
withdrawn |
December 3
|