The result was delete. -- Cirt ( talk) 06:16, 29 October 2010 (UTC) reply
A declined speedy by NickOrnstein read, "Mary Dolan Dolan doesn't seem too "notable" in the outer world. The article doesn't note that she has been, for example a governor, nor a longevity record holder at minimum. While being employed in the economy, chances are you are more recognizable due to being in the media a lot more often. If she had been married, for example, 80 years it would make sense to keep the article - longevity record." This basic nonnotability argument is valid in that being 105 based on half an article does not a WP topic make. I say half an article because the one news reference is also being used to support Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Dolan (centenarian). JJB 04:24, 22 October 2010 (UTC)
Delete its only one article, besides, being the only living sibling of a 105 year old is not inherently notable, especially if shes only 103, what the point in her and her brother getting articles, 105 and 103 are not notable, if they were the oldest living siblings then maybe they would deserve an artclie, but even with that being said, Maggie renfro's siblings, both older then James Dolan, don't have articles, is James Dolan the oldest in his country, What made anyone think he and his sister should get articles? Longevitydude ( talk) 15:31, 25 October 2010 (UTC) reply
The result was delete. -- Cirt ( talk) 06:16, 29 October 2010 (UTC) reply
A declined speedy by NickOrnstein read, "Mary Dolan Dolan doesn't seem too "notable" in the outer world. The article doesn't note that she has been, for example a governor, nor a longevity record holder at minimum. While being employed in the economy, chances are you are more recognizable due to being in the media a lot more often. If she had been married, for example, 80 years it would make sense to keep the article - longevity record." This basic nonnotability argument is valid in that being 105 based on half an article does not a WP topic make. I say half an article because the one news reference is also being used to support Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/James Dolan (centenarian). JJB 04:24, 22 October 2010 (UTC)
Delete its only one article, besides, being the only living sibling of a 105 year old is not inherently notable, especially if shes only 103, what the point in her and her brother getting articles, 105 and 103 are not notable, if they were the oldest living siblings then maybe they would deserve an artclie, but even with that being said, Maggie renfro's siblings, both older then James Dolan, don't have articles, is James Dolan the oldest in his country, What made anyone think he and his sister should get articles? Longevitydude ( talk) 15:31, 25 October 2010 (UTC) reply