The result was delete. MBisanz talk 09:05, 18 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Self-Promotion, Autobiography, Notability Cazbahrocker ( talk) 19:54, 14 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete. I've been monitoring the Category:Heavy metal singers and Category:Female metal singers, and came across the page for Lilith Astaroth, which has little evidence to classify her as a Female Metal Singer. Upon further investigation, it appears as if all edits were contributed by the subject herself ( WP:YOURSELF). PROD was contested by the subject of the article, and I believe theres a real conflict of interest ( WP:CONFLICT).
As a result, this page is nothing more then a list of personal accomplishments ( WP:RESUME), which are not notable to the general public:
With all that said, I am new to this delete process. I've been editing Wikipedia for about 2-3 months, mainly very minor edits. I registered recently when I came across this article as I was interested in editing Wikipedia further. I believe I'm following the policies of Wikipedia properly, but I'd be happy to learn more. Cazbahrocker ( talk) 21:04, 14 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete of course. You did well:) Could have been speedy deleted- no notability at all. [1] To clarify- the refs used are IMDB, youtube, myspace, a blog and some goth websites. The documentary she was in was by a company with no notability whatsoever itself. [2], she was on local access television once, and I think on a national chat show once where you just have to be eccentrically dressed enough to get an appearance. Will we add every person who's been on The Dr. Keith Ablow Show once to this encyclopedia? Not that I've heard of that, being in the UK.:) Sticky Parkin 11:42, 15 October 2008 (UTC) reply
The result was delete. MBisanz talk 09:05, 18 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Self-Promotion, Autobiography, Notability Cazbahrocker ( talk) 19:54, 14 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete. I've been monitoring the Category:Heavy metal singers and Category:Female metal singers, and came across the page for Lilith Astaroth, which has little evidence to classify her as a Female Metal Singer. Upon further investigation, it appears as if all edits were contributed by the subject herself ( WP:YOURSELF). PROD was contested by the subject of the article, and I believe theres a real conflict of interest ( WP:CONFLICT).
As a result, this page is nothing more then a list of personal accomplishments ( WP:RESUME), which are not notable to the general public:
With all that said, I am new to this delete process. I've been editing Wikipedia for about 2-3 months, mainly very minor edits. I registered recently when I came across this article as I was interested in editing Wikipedia further. I believe I'm following the policies of Wikipedia properly, but I'd be happy to learn more. Cazbahrocker ( talk) 21:04, 14 October 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete of course. You did well:) Could have been speedy deleted- no notability at all. [1] To clarify- the refs used are IMDB, youtube, myspace, a blog and some goth websites. The documentary she was in was by a company with no notability whatsoever itself. [2], she was on local access television once, and I think on a national chat show once where you just have to be eccentrically dressed enough to get an appearance. Will we add every person who's been on The Dr. Keith Ablow Show once to this encyclopedia? Not that I've heard of that, being in the UK.:) Sticky Parkin 11:42, 15 October 2008 (UTC) reply