The result was delete all. Related discussion and closing rationale at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Coeur Saignant and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commune Ango Keeper | 76 | Disclaimer 21:04, 7 July 2008 (UTC) reply
Procedural Nomination for article re-PROD'd after having had a declined PROD. There are two main concerns: a) verifiability of the place's existence and b) notability of the place. It is my understanding that if an inhabited place is verifiable, that place is intrinsically notable.
I am also nominating the following related pages because the reason for AfD, edit history and editors involved are essentially identical:
More nominations
As I understood that you would be interested in places very small even though there is not much or nothing to be said about them, I made an in-depth check of the names listed above at the back of my IGN maps. It appears that they all come from there but that many of them are not correctly copied. It also appears that the localisation given in other databases is not always accurate. We have:
You should have a look at Géoportail for these first-hand maps. If you keep in mind that the names might not be accurate, maybe will you find the others. From my point of view, none is notable, indeed. I mean: what will the article say if even the locals don't know anything? Can't we simply use redirects to Category:Communes of Réunion? Whatever, I hope I helped you. Thierry Caro ( talk) 12:55, 30 June 2008 (UTC) reply
The result was delete all. Related discussion and closing rationale at Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Le Coeur Saignant and Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Commune Ango Keeper | 76 | Disclaimer 21:04, 7 July 2008 (UTC) reply
Procedural Nomination for article re-PROD'd after having had a declined PROD. There are two main concerns: a) verifiability of the place's existence and b) notability of the place. It is my understanding that if an inhabited place is verifiable, that place is intrinsically notable.
I am also nominating the following related pages because the reason for AfD, edit history and editors involved are essentially identical:
More nominations
As I understood that you would be interested in places very small even though there is not much or nothing to be said about them, I made an in-depth check of the names listed above at the back of my IGN maps. It appears that they all come from there but that many of them are not correctly copied. It also appears that the localisation given in other databases is not always accurate. We have:
You should have a look at Géoportail for these first-hand maps. If you keep in mind that the names might not be accurate, maybe will you find the others. From my point of view, none is notable, indeed. I mean: what will the article say if even the locals don't know anything? Can't we simply use redirects to Category:Communes of Réunion? Whatever, I hope I helped you. Thierry Caro ( talk) 12:55, 30 June 2008 (UTC) reply