The result was delete. -- Cirt ( talk) 03:06, 30 October 2010 (UTC) reply
A declined speedy by NickOrnstein read, "There is no reason to create an article on her now. It would make more sense if she were a supercentenarian and/or if she was the oldest living resident in her country. An article on Wikipedia is being used as a source, which is against the rules." Nick also said here, "Eva McConnell is not the oldest after Australia's formation, which was on January 1, 1901. Mary Rothstein born February 27, 1901 is the oldest (known) and oldest born after." I add that Nick has access to sources like the Gerontology Research Group to back up this statement, which combined with not yet being a supercentenarian pretty much gives the lie to notability. There's also that circular sourcing going on. JJB 04:21, 22 October 2010 (UTC)
Delete Being fourth oldest person in her country does not provide inherent notability. Edison ( talk) 20:36, 22 October 2010 (UTC) reply
DeleteThere are three people older than her living in Austrailia, and the oldest person living there, a supercentenarian, doesnt have an article, so it seems odd for her to have an article when the oldest person living there, a supercentenarian, doesnt. Longevitydude ( talk) 15:23, 25 October 2010 (UTC) reply
The result was delete. -- Cirt ( talk) 03:06, 30 October 2010 (UTC) reply
A declined speedy by NickOrnstein read, "There is no reason to create an article on her now. It would make more sense if she were a supercentenarian and/or if she was the oldest living resident in her country. An article on Wikipedia is being used as a source, which is against the rules." Nick also said here, "Eva McConnell is not the oldest after Australia's formation, which was on January 1, 1901. Mary Rothstein born February 27, 1901 is the oldest (known) and oldest born after." I add that Nick has access to sources like the Gerontology Research Group to back up this statement, which combined with not yet being a supercentenarian pretty much gives the lie to notability. There's also that circular sourcing going on. JJB 04:21, 22 October 2010 (UTC)
Delete Being fourth oldest person in her country does not provide inherent notability. Edison ( talk) 20:36, 22 October 2010 (UTC) reply
DeleteThere are three people older than her living in Austrailia, and the oldest person living there, a supercentenarian, doesnt have an article, so it seems odd for her to have an article when the oldest person living there, a supercentenarian, doesnt. Longevitydude ( talk) 15:23, 25 October 2010 (UTC) reply