Saifullah Khan listed on
WP:VFD Jul 7 to Jul 15 2004, consensus was to delete if not improved. Was not improved in that time. Discussion:
Could've probably been a speedy, but someone else thought it cleanup worthy. I couldn't find any notable people with this name, so I'm putting it here.
Ambivalenthysteria 11:35, 7 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Incomprehensible substub with no context to work with. Delete. --
Cyrius|
✎ 14:54, 7 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Delete - the context is easy enough to find, but it says nothing that itsn't already in its parent article. -
Mustafaa 04:01, 8 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Comment: I'm the one who added this to cleanup. I figured that anyone titled "Sword of Allah," who had a city named after him, probably is worthy of an article. Granted, there is almost nothing in English on the web about this person, but a stub might be seen by someone who knows more... Oh, BTW, "Saifullah" is a title and "Saifullah Khan" is part of several notable people's names, but it is highly unlikely to be the entire name. One web site I found
[1] says "Saifullah Khan had supported the people of Buner in defending their soil against British expansionist designs, having taken active part in the battle of Sukawa." I'm just researching -- not opposed to deletion until more detail can be added, but not opposed to keeping a stub, either.
SWAdair |
Talk 06:55, 8 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Would vote to keep if content were more than just interpretation of title. Will vote to keep if more is added to this subsubstub.
Denni☯ 01:59, 2004 Jul 11 (UTC)
Keep. It's fine as a stub to attract the attention of someone who knows more about the subject.
Jamesday 05:41, 12 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Saifullah Khan listed on
WP:VFD Jul 7 to Jul 15 2004, consensus was to delete if not improved. Was not improved in that time. Discussion:
Could've probably been a speedy, but someone else thought it cleanup worthy. I couldn't find any notable people with this name, so I'm putting it here.
Ambivalenthysteria 11:35, 7 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Incomprehensible substub with no context to work with. Delete. --
Cyrius|
✎ 14:54, 7 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Delete - the context is easy enough to find, but it says nothing that itsn't already in its parent article. -
Mustafaa 04:01, 8 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Comment: I'm the one who added this to cleanup. I figured that anyone titled "Sword of Allah," who had a city named after him, probably is worthy of an article. Granted, there is almost nothing in English on the web about this person, but a stub might be seen by someone who knows more... Oh, BTW, "Saifullah" is a title and "Saifullah Khan" is part of several notable people's names, but it is highly unlikely to be the entire name. One web site I found
[1] says "Saifullah Khan had supported the people of Buner in defending their soil against British expansionist designs, having taken active part in the battle of Sukawa." I'm just researching -- not opposed to deletion until more detail can be added, but not opposed to keeping a stub, either.
SWAdair |
Talk 06:55, 8 Jul 2004 (UTC)
Would vote to keep if content were more than just interpretation of title. Will vote to keep if more is added to this subsubstub.
Denni☯ 01:59, 2004 Jul 11 (UTC)
Keep. It's fine as a stub to attract the attention of someone who knows more about the subject.
Jamesday 05:41, 12 Jul 2004 (UTC)