(62/10/5); Final Andre ( talk) 02:41, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
RockMFR ( talk · contribs) - RockMFR has been with us since September 2006 and contributed over 13,000 edits to Wikipedia, including 7,000 to the article namespace. I believe him to be highly suited to adminship - this will not surprise those who remember that I have nominated him before. My nomination statement in March (see Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/RockMFR) contains a pretty detailed breakdown of his contributions in various admin-related areas so I'll just summarise this time. Rock makes highly sensible comments across the range of XfDs and his deleted edits show a sound knowledge of the speedy deletion criteria. He is also a decent content writer, having helped to bring GameFAQs to FA status and a regular participant at Wikipedia:Featured article candidates.
I was disappointed that his last nomination was unsuccessful. Opposition centred around the fact that Rock expressed himself unwisely during the DRV discussions of Wikipedia:Esperanza. I have kept an eye on his contributions in the months since that RfA and have seen no other example of a failure to assume good faith, but I will leave him to address this point more fully. Similarly, the criticisms of his comments on other's RfAs seem to have been taken on board. I have always thought that a person's response to an unsuccessful RfA tells us a lot about them. Those whose first response is to storm off the project in a tantrum have always concerned me whereas those that knuckle down and continue quietly contributing show precisely the attitude that we should be looking for in our admins. I am please to say RockMFR proved to be in the latter category - the time since the last nom has only solidified my impression that he will make a fine admin. WjB scribe 20:29, 6 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Yes. Thanks again. --- RockMFR 02:36, 7 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Dear candidate, thank you for offering to serve Wikipedia as an administrator. You may wish to answer the following optional questions to provide guidance for participants:
Optional question by User:Vodak
Please keep criticism constructive and polite. If you are unfamiliar with the nominee, please thoroughly review Special:Contributions/RockMFR before commenting.
Support
Oppose
Neutral
(62/10/5); Final Andre ( talk) 02:41, 14 August 2007 (UTC) reply
RockMFR ( talk · contribs) - RockMFR has been with us since September 2006 and contributed over 13,000 edits to Wikipedia, including 7,000 to the article namespace. I believe him to be highly suited to adminship - this will not surprise those who remember that I have nominated him before. My nomination statement in March (see Wikipedia:Requests for adminship/RockMFR) contains a pretty detailed breakdown of his contributions in various admin-related areas so I'll just summarise this time. Rock makes highly sensible comments across the range of XfDs and his deleted edits show a sound knowledge of the speedy deletion criteria. He is also a decent content writer, having helped to bring GameFAQs to FA status and a regular participant at Wikipedia:Featured article candidates.
I was disappointed that his last nomination was unsuccessful. Opposition centred around the fact that Rock expressed himself unwisely during the DRV discussions of Wikipedia:Esperanza. I have kept an eye on his contributions in the months since that RfA and have seen no other example of a failure to assume good faith, but I will leave him to address this point more fully. Similarly, the criticisms of his comments on other's RfAs seem to have been taken on board. I have always thought that a person's response to an unsuccessful RfA tells us a lot about them. Those whose first response is to storm off the project in a tantrum have always concerned me whereas those that knuckle down and continue quietly contributing show precisely the attitude that we should be looking for in our admins. I am please to say RockMFR proved to be in the latter category - the time since the last nom has only solidified my impression that he will make a fine admin. WjB scribe 20:29, 6 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Yes. Thanks again. --- RockMFR 02:36, 7 August 2007 (UTC) reply
Dear candidate, thank you for offering to serve Wikipedia as an administrator. You may wish to answer the following optional questions to provide guidance for participants:
Optional question by User:Vodak
Please keep criticism constructive and polite. If you are unfamiliar with the nominee, please thoroughly review Special:Contributions/RockMFR before commenting.
Support
Oppose
Neutral