Weak Keep. Although a few clouds in the middle left of the image are somewhat blurred, the overall image is astounding. Amazing cloud formation. The remainer of photo is of FPC quality. --
AJ2417:48, 17 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Keep Size and artifacting is the only really valid (as far as the criteria for a FP are concerned) issue with the image , the fact that it's unreproduceable doesn't mean anything since many FP's are situations that are unreproduceable and somebody put a {{FP}} tag on the image page, which you can do yourself in the future if you want.
Pegasus1138Talk |
Contribs |
Email ----
21:32, 18 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Keep it's a very nice photo with exception of being slightly on the small side I feel it should be a FP, as far as being reproducable, it may be, but it would be hard to do.
PPGMD22:03, 18 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Comment. I could support an edited version of the shot LiquidGhoul found, but both it and Edit 1 have an unnatural color cast that should be cleaned up. Also it could use some careful sharpening. I could give it a try later today, if nobody else does. --
moondigger13:38, 19 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Weak Keep. Although a few clouds in the middle left of the image are somewhat blurred, the overall image is astounding. Amazing cloud formation. The remainer of photo is of FPC quality. --
AJ2417:48, 17 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Keep Size and artifacting is the only really valid (as far as the criteria for a FP are concerned) issue with the image , the fact that it's unreproduceable doesn't mean anything since many FP's are situations that are unreproduceable and somebody put a {{FP}} tag on the image page, which you can do yourself in the future if you want.
Pegasus1138Talk |
Contribs |
Email ----
21:32, 18 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Keep it's a very nice photo with exception of being slightly on the small side I feel it should be a FP, as far as being reproducable, it may be, but it would be hard to do.
PPGMD22:03, 18 July 2006 (UTC)reply
Comment. I could support an edited version of the shot LiquidGhoul found, but both it and Edit 1 have an unnatural color cast that should be cleaned up. Also it could use some careful sharpening. I could give it a try later today, if nobody else does. --
moondigger13:38, 19 July 2006 (UTC)reply