The result was no consensus. As far as policy-based rationales go, the valid parts of the nomination appear to be concerns vis-a-vis WP:BLP1E. Other aspects of the nomination are subjective, and not guideline- or policy-based. WP:BLP1E concerns have been countered by the !vote by User:Frietjes per the subject's appearance on multiple seasons of Survivor. The !vote from User:ApprenticeFan suggests notability, but doesn't specifically delineate how this is so. The "strong delete" !vote by User: Dobbyelf62 is not guideline- or policy-based. Ultimately, there's no consensus in the discussion at this time. (Non-administrator closure.) Northamerica1000 (talk) 08:37, 30 January 2014 (UTC)
I can't believe how all these Survivor bio articles keep showing up again after they've been redirected. I much as I've loved Survivor since I was a boy, I just see no reason to keep some of these articles on the contestants :( Tina is clearly not known for anything other than Survivor, and being a three time contestant doesn't make someone notable. Teaching outdoor survival classes and publishing a book are both good accomplishments, but those things don't automatically constitute encyclopedic notability. She's just another person who's lived a cool life. Survivorfan1995 ( talk) 19:39, 5 January 2014 (UTC)
The result was no consensus. As far as policy-based rationales go, the valid parts of the nomination appear to be concerns vis-a-vis WP:BLP1E. Other aspects of the nomination are subjective, and not guideline- or policy-based. WP:BLP1E concerns have been countered by the !vote by User:Frietjes per the subject's appearance on multiple seasons of Survivor. The !vote from User:ApprenticeFan suggests notability, but doesn't specifically delineate how this is so. The "strong delete" !vote by User: Dobbyelf62 is not guideline- or policy-based. Ultimately, there's no consensus in the discussion at this time. (Non-administrator closure.) Northamerica1000 (talk) 08:37, 30 January 2014 (UTC)
I can't believe how all these Survivor bio articles keep showing up again after they've been redirected. I much as I've loved Survivor since I was a boy, I just see no reason to keep some of these articles on the contestants :( Tina is clearly not known for anything other than Survivor, and being a three time contestant doesn't make someone notable. Teaching outdoor survival classes and publishing a book are both good accomplishments, but those things don't automatically constitute encyclopedic notability. She's just another person who's lived a cool life. Survivorfan1995 ( talk) 19:39, 5 January 2014 (UTC)