The result was no consensus. Weak-ish keep, bordering on no consensus. Keeper | 76 14:01, 17 March 2013 (UTC) reply
Self-published biographical article which lacks reliable sourcing. DeeplyInspired52 ( talk) 22:10, 5 March 2013 (UTC) reply
NOTE: This deletion request has been closed as "Keep" twice before by two different editors and those decisions have been reverted by the involved editor SudoGhost. An admin should close this as a "speedy keep." The article added local sources to show local notability (item 7, in notability requirements). For the record I've never heard of him or the band he used to also tour with but the San Diego Tribune has and those sources are present. The Keep arguments are overwhelmingly more compelling than Delete arguments. The article appears well written with sources and consensus is to Keep. — Preceding unsigned comment added by DHeyward ( talk • contribs)
Notice This AfD was closed twice and the closings reverted without a notice of the removal being posted in the discussion. The discussion was then closed for both a third time and a fourth time using a "Close in progress" banner. A comment was refactored without a notice being posted in the discussion. The detail of these edits is available in the edit history. The edit that added this notice was used to remove the "Close in progress" banner and the Category:Requests for Close. Further comments should go on the talk page of the AfD, or to the talk page of the closing administrator. Unscintillating ( talk) 15:39, 17 March 2013 (UTC) reply |
The result was no consensus. Weak-ish keep, bordering on no consensus. Keeper | 76 14:01, 17 March 2013 (UTC) reply
Self-published biographical article which lacks reliable sourcing. DeeplyInspired52 ( talk) 22:10, 5 March 2013 (UTC) reply
NOTE: This deletion request has been closed as "Keep" twice before by two different editors and those decisions have been reverted by the involved editor SudoGhost. An admin should close this as a "speedy keep." The article added local sources to show local notability (item 7, in notability requirements). For the record I've never heard of him or the band he used to also tour with but the San Diego Tribune has and those sources are present. The Keep arguments are overwhelmingly more compelling than Delete arguments. The article appears well written with sources and consensus is to Keep. — Preceding unsigned comment added by DHeyward ( talk • contribs)
Notice This AfD was closed twice and the closings reverted without a notice of the removal being posted in the discussion. The discussion was then closed for both a third time and a fourth time using a "Close in progress" banner. A comment was refactored without a notice being posted in the discussion. The detail of these edits is available in the edit history. The edit that added this notice was used to remove the "Close in progress" banner and the Category:Requests for Close. Further comments should go on the talk page of the AfD, or to the talk page of the closing administrator. Unscintillating ( talk) 15:39, 17 March 2013 (UTC) reply |