The result was Keep -- User:Whpq hit it on the head: there is evidence that the subject is notable, but you have to – pardon the pun – comb through the references to find something that meets WP:RS standards. The article is, admittedly, in need of help, and I am going to list this article on WP:CLEANUP to get assistance in fixing it. Pastor Theo ( talk) 12:03, 23 July 2009 (UTC) reply
Advertisement/resume written by subject. Despite being seemingly "well sourced", not a single of the 19 different "references" actually show any notability. Half of them are dead links, the rest are either personal sites, salon directories and a two local news papers/blogs. BJ Talk 23:37, 15 July 2009 (UTC) reply
[1] New York Times (newspaper) [2]Guest of a guest
As shown in the Daily news, new york newspaper, Rodolfo Valentin, thru his foundation, gives FREE hair prosthesis that cost almost 4 thousand dollars to cancer patients who cannot afford to buy one. And the most exemplary thing is that he does not use it as a tax deduction. He is an extraordinary human being who deserves respect. He uses his own money for this charitable deed to keep a promise to his mother who also died from cancer. See the attached Daily News article [3] Keeping a promise [4] Leukemia society [5] the queens courier ( Newspaper) [6] Prestigious, ROBB REPORT MAGAZINE [7] Amarillo, website
[8]New York Magazine, rated 10 out of 10jormarie 17:09, 18 July 2009 (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by Rodoval ( talk • contribs)
I was trying very hard to correct the links ( some of them have been moved to other files or archives, but for some reason I am not able to do it. I will fix them, when the system let me.
the user [
[9]] Bjweeks, is making an statement that Rodolfo Valentin is only showing "in a couple of local newspapers"...when in reality Rodolfo is named by the press as the "celebrity hairstylist" of New York as it is showing in the last article written about him last month.
[10]Guest of a guest---It is very offensive. I think Bjweeks has some kind of interest in hurting Rodolfo Valentin name. Anyone can just type RODOLFO VALENTIN in google, yahoo, msn or any other search engine, to find almost 1 million search results, thousands of them related to television, magazines and newspapers articles
68.161.91.72 (
talk) 18:36, 18 July 2009 (UTC)
reply
The result was Keep -- User:Whpq hit it on the head: there is evidence that the subject is notable, but you have to – pardon the pun – comb through the references to find something that meets WP:RS standards. The article is, admittedly, in need of help, and I am going to list this article on WP:CLEANUP to get assistance in fixing it. Pastor Theo ( talk) 12:03, 23 July 2009 (UTC) reply
Advertisement/resume written by subject. Despite being seemingly "well sourced", not a single of the 19 different "references" actually show any notability. Half of them are dead links, the rest are either personal sites, salon directories and a two local news papers/blogs. BJ Talk 23:37, 15 July 2009 (UTC) reply
[1] New York Times (newspaper) [2]Guest of a guest
As shown in the Daily news, new york newspaper, Rodolfo Valentin, thru his foundation, gives FREE hair prosthesis that cost almost 4 thousand dollars to cancer patients who cannot afford to buy one. And the most exemplary thing is that he does not use it as a tax deduction. He is an extraordinary human being who deserves respect. He uses his own money for this charitable deed to keep a promise to his mother who also died from cancer. See the attached Daily News article [3] Keeping a promise [4] Leukemia society [5] the queens courier ( Newspaper) [6] Prestigious, ROBB REPORT MAGAZINE [7] Amarillo, website
[8]New York Magazine, rated 10 out of 10jormarie 17:09, 18 July 2009 (UTC) —Preceding unsigned comment added by Rodoval ( talk • contribs)
I was trying very hard to correct the links ( some of them have been moved to other files or archives, but for some reason I am not able to do it. I will fix them, when the system let me.
the user [
[9]] Bjweeks, is making an statement that Rodolfo Valentin is only showing "in a couple of local newspapers"...when in reality Rodolfo is named by the press as the "celebrity hairstylist" of New York as it is showing in the last article written about him last month.
[10]Guest of a guest---It is very offensive. I think Bjweeks has some kind of interest in hurting Rodolfo Valentin name. Anyone can just type RODOLFO VALENTIN in google, yahoo, msn or any other search engine, to find almost 1 million search results, thousands of them related to television, magazines and newspapers articles
68.161.91.72 (
talk) 18:36, 18 July 2009 (UTC)
reply