![]() | This discussion was subject to a
deletion review on 2013 January 13. For an explanation of the process, see Wikipedia:Deletion review. |
The result was no consensus. A close call here, and I note that Sandstein (who generally contributes to AFD by closing discussions instead of participating) entered a keep vote where he dissented from what appeared to be consensus at the time. I have reviewed that vote and find that it has sufficient merit to block there from being a consensus. In particular, citing WP:CSB as a deletion argument and "doesn't look notable to me, regardless of sourcing" seems rather irrelevant.
There is quite a bit more merit to Jreferee's argument who pointed out that many of the sources really about the site's founder Joly MacFie, and he argued that a biographical article on MacFie would be better. Having looked at this article, I see that a substantial portion of it is about MacFie's accomplishments already, and it seems like a viable option to simply rename the article and change the lead sentence so that it becomes an article about MacFie. The combination of Sandstein's well-reasoned objection, and the possible option of a biographical article on Joly MacFie seems like sufficient grounds to call this a "no consensus" despite the 4-2 majority for deletion. Sjakkalle (Check!) 11:05, 12 January 2013 (UTC) reply
This page seems to read like an advertisement. There is only one major contributor, WWWwhatsup,whereas if you Google punkcast, the first link says it is sponsored by WWWwhatsup. MarioNovi ( talk) 00:31, 4 January 2013 (UTC) reply
![]() | This discussion was subject to a
deletion review on 2013 January 13. For an explanation of the process, see Wikipedia:Deletion review. |
The result was no consensus. A close call here, and I note that Sandstein (who generally contributes to AFD by closing discussions instead of participating) entered a keep vote where he dissented from what appeared to be consensus at the time. I have reviewed that vote and find that it has sufficient merit to block there from being a consensus. In particular, citing WP:CSB as a deletion argument and "doesn't look notable to me, regardless of sourcing" seems rather irrelevant.
There is quite a bit more merit to Jreferee's argument who pointed out that many of the sources really about the site's founder Joly MacFie, and he argued that a biographical article on MacFie would be better. Having looked at this article, I see that a substantial portion of it is about MacFie's accomplishments already, and it seems like a viable option to simply rename the article and change the lead sentence so that it becomes an article about MacFie. The combination of Sandstein's well-reasoned objection, and the possible option of a biographical article on Joly MacFie seems like sufficient grounds to call this a "no consensus" despite the 4-2 majority for deletion. Sjakkalle (Check!) 11:05, 12 January 2013 (UTC) reply
This page seems to read like an advertisement. There is only one major contributor, WWWwhatsup,whereas if you Google punkcast, the first link says it is sponsored by WWWwhatsup. MarioNovi ( talk) 00:31, 4 January 2013 (UTC) reply