The result was delete. Sr 13 09:02, 29 July 2007 (UTC) reply
Topic before the names is discussed in other articles. But the main problem is the list of names. Most of them are unnoteable and do not have WP articles. They just have links to their personal websites and/or books that they are selling. In addition, a lot of the names listed are living persons, hence being listed there violates WP:BLP Yeshivish 06:27, 24 July 2007 (UTC) reply
Retain - there are some great Jewish names in here and just because they don't fit into the framework of either the rabbis or of many Christians that is no reason to delete them!
Delete . Most aren't notable the list is only there to try say there is a lot of messianic jews and christian hebrews i could list every crackpot with a website who believes in holocaust denial to try to make it seem as though there is many who believe that delusion stop spreading lies -- Java7837 18:55, 26 July 2007 (UTC) reply
I'll raise you two more cents. :-) The way I have heard the expression "Hebrew Christian" used would be for a person born and raised Jewish (hence a "Hebrew") who converts to Christianity and joins a main-stream Christian church. Most of the time I have heard the expression come up is because the person in question is advocating that other Jews also convert.
A "Messianic Jew" on the other hand is not a Christian, in the normal sense the word "Christian" is used. They follow the practices of Judaism while believing in Jesus as the Messiah. As Christianity developed it rejected Messianic Judaism, and in fact persecuted it so that the movement passed away and was only restarted in modern times.
So to me it doesn't make much sense to put the two things on the same list. Other people may disagree of course. Steve Dufour 04:27, 29 July 2007 (UTC) reply
The result was delete. Sr 13 09:02, 29 July 2007 (UTC) reply
Topic before the names is discussed in other articles. But the main problem is the list of names. Most of them are unnoteable and do not have WP articles. They just have links to their personal websites and/or books that they are selling. In addition, a lot of the names listed are living persons, hence being listed there violates WP:BLP Yeshivish 06:27, 24 July 2007 (UTC) reply
Retain - there are some great Jewish names in here and just because they don't fit into the framework of either the rabbis or of many Christians that is no reason to delete them!
Delete . Most aren't notable the list is only there to try say there is a lot of messianic jews and christian hebrews i could list every crackpot with a website who believes in holocaust denial to try to make it seem as though there is many who believe that delusion stop spreading lies -- Java7837 18:55, 26 July 2007 (UTC) reply
I'll raise you two more cents. :-) The way I have heard the expression "Hebrew Christian" used would be for a person born and raised Jewish (hence a "Hebrew") who converts to Christianity and joins a main-stream Christian church. Most of the time I have heard the expression come up is because the person in question is advocating that other Jews also convert.
A "Messianic Jew" on the other hand is not a Christian, in the normal sense the word "Christian" is used. They follow the practices of Judaism while believing in Jesus as the Messiah. As Christianity developed it rejected Messianic Judaism, and in fact persecuted it so that the movement passed away and was only restarted in modern times.
So to me it doesn't make much sense to put the two things on the same list. Other people may disagree of course. Steve Dufour 04:27, 29 July 2007 (UTC) reply