The result was Keep. Claims of notability are at best weakly established and set out in the article, but better described here. Editors are encouraged to improve the stub. The Math departments bulletin (currently at the MIT Math department website linked in the article), notes a promotion to Associate Professor on page 2, right after a pair of tenure awards. At MIT this rank can be tenured or non-tenured, and in this context I interpret as not yet tenured, contrary to the IP editor's statement below. The MacTutor test is nowhere described as one of our standard tests. (See the proposal WP:PROF and the guidelines WP:BIO and WP:NOTE for what the standard tests are.) GRBerry 03:54, 10 January 2007 (UTC) reply
This mathematician does not appear to have sufficient notability. It was never the Wikipedia policy to include all faculty of all universities -- the university websites are sufficient for that purpose. I suggest to stick to really notable mathematicians, like Fields medals or important historical figures. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Nabla2006 ( talk • contribs) 20:32, 3 January 2007
The result was Keep. Claims of notability are at best weakly established and set out in the article, but better described here. Editors are encouraged to improve the stub. The Math departments bulletin (currently at the MIT Math department website linked in the article), notes a promotion to Associate Professor on page 2, right after a pair of tenure awards. At MIT this rank can be tenured or non-tenured, and in this context I interpret as not yet tenured, contrary to the IP editor's statement below. The MacTutor test is nowhere described as one of our standard tests. (See the proposal WP:PROF and the guidelines WP:BIO and WP:NOTE for what the standard tests are.) GRBerry 03:54, 10 January 2007 (UTC) reply
This mathematician does not appear to have sufficient notability. It was never the Wikipedia policy to include all faculty of all universities -- the university websites are sufficient for that purpose. I suggest to stick to really notable mathematicians, like Fields medals or important historical figures. — Preceding unsigned comment added by Nabla2006 ( talk • contribs) 20:32, 3 January 2007