The result was Delete, consensus is that he fails the notability guidelines at this time. Davewild ( talk) 10:37, 1 January 2008 (UTC) reply
Contested PROD. Original concern was "No evidence that the player meets notability criteria for sportspeople as laid down at WP:BIO". The PROD was removed with the reasoning "BBC article reference does prove that he has been signed by Liverpool, a pro team". The mere fact that he has been signed by a professional team does not mean that he is a notable footballer, as he may still have his career cut short for some reason, and he has, as yet, nothing notable to his name. If he had been given a squad number and played a match for a pro club, then he would be notable, but at the minute he's not worthy of an article. – Pee Jay 19:56, 26 December 2007 (UTC) reply
The result was Delete, consensus is that he fails the notability guidelines at this time. Davewild ( talk) 10:37, 1 January 2008 (UTC) reply
Contested PROD. Original concern was "No evidence that the player meets notability criteria for sportspeople as laid down at WP:BIO". The PROD was removed with the reasoning "BBC article reference does prove that he has been signed by Liverpool, a pro team". The mere fact that he has been signed by a professional team does not mean that he is a notable footballer, as he may still have his career cut short for some reason, and he has, as yet, nothing notable to his name. If he had been given a squad number and played a match for a pro club, then he would be notable, but at the minute he's not worthy of an article. – Pee Jay 19:56, 26 December 2007 (UTC) reply