The result was keep. Guerillero Parlez Moi 20:44, 3 May 2023 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
Fails WP:ORG and WP:GNG. 2 of the 5 sources relate to a racial incident at the hotel. Other sources are mainly local as per WP:AUD. LibStar ( talk) 06:38, 17 April 2023 (UTC)
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
CycloneYoris
talk! 20:55, 24 April 2023 (UTC)
Source | Significant? | Independent? | Reliable? | Secondary? | Reach | Pass/Fail | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
"38 Portland hotels that tell the Rose City's history". The Oregonian. | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | P | More of this history should be added to the article if it is kept. |
"Newest $40 million Red Lion largest hotel in Oregon". The Oregonian. | Might be significant but is potentially trivial coverage | yes | yes | yes | Regional | P/F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"List Leaders: Check in with Portland's 5 biggest hotels". Portland Business Journal. | No, fails under trivial coverage | yes | yes | yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, particularly in "best of", "top 100", "fastest growing" or similar lists is considered trivial |
"6 Portland Hotels with Outdoor Pools for Your Summer Staycation". Portland Monthly. | No | yes | yes | yes | Local | F | Per WP:PRODUCTREV: Brief and routine reviews do not qualify as significant coverage. Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, is considered trivial. |
"Photo essay: Outdoor swimming pools, public and private". Oregon Business. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | mentioned in one sentence |
"Portland Sheraton Hotel Job Progresses". Mail Tribune. Medford, Oregon. | No, | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local but UPI | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Grand opening today, Sheraton-Portland Hotel". The Register-Guard. Eugene, Oregon. | No | No | No | No | Regional | F | Paid Advertisement |
"Lloyd Corp. may change hotel firms". The Oregon Journal. p. 1. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Thunderbird–Red Lion buys Lloyd Sheraton". The Oregonian. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | |
"Red Lion Dining has arrived at Lloyd Center" (advertisement), in The Oregon Journal | No | No | No | No | statewide | F | |
"Red Lion considers 300 additional rooms". The Oregonian. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | |
"Doubletree To Pay $1.2 Billion For Red Lion". The Seattle Times. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article is on the chain, not this specific hotel |
"Downtown Red Lion Is Now Doubletree". The Spokesman-Review. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Last of Red Lion Inns' holdings to be sold to Ohio lodging company". The Columbian. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article is on the chain, not this specific hotel |
"DoubleTree by Hilton Introduces New Global Brand Identity, Creating One of Biggest Hotel Groups". Business Wire. | No | No | No | Yes | National | F | Article is on chain, not this hotel; Business Wire published press releases. See WP:ORGIND |
"Washington man arraigned in homicide at Portland's Doubletree Hotel". The Oregonian. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Articles are about a crime at this location, not the hotel itself. See WP:INHERITORG |
"Family suing Hilton hotel group, Backpage.com for enabling prostitution, daughter's murder". Statesman Journal. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | |
"Murder victim's family sues hotel chain after Portland killing". KATU. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | |
"Portland's outdoor hotel pools, ranked". The Oregonian | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, particularly in "best of", "top 100", "fastest growing" or similar lists is considered trivial |
Fodor's Pacific Northwest: with Oregon, Washington & Vancouver. Fodor's Travel. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | Per WP:PRODUCTREV: Brief and routine reviews do not qualify as significant coverage. Also, some of this content is routinely provided by the subject or its employee. See WP:ORGIND |
Fodor's Oregon. Fodor's Travel. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
. "DoubleTree by Hilton–Portland". Fodor's. Archived | Possibly | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
Moon Portland. Avalon Publishing. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
Number of significant sources | 1 (or 2) | both are from The Oregonian |
Source | Significant? | Independent? | Reliable? | Secondary? | Reach | Pass/Fail | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
"Portland hotel calls police on black guest talking to his mom on phone". KGW. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | Solid source, but too local to prove notablity |
"$10M lawsuit claims racial profiling at DoubleTree hotel". Portland Tribune | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | Solid source, but too local to prove notablity |
"Black Guest Kicked Out Of Portland DoubleTree In 2018 Sues Hotel For $10 Million". Oregon Public Broadcasting. | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | Statewide | P | |
"Tina Gordon on Making 'Praise This' Not Too 'Preachy'". Essence | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | F | Linked article does not mention the hotel |
"DoubleTree Portland Hotel fires 2 workers for calling police on black hotel guest". ABC News | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | P | |
"Oregon hotel fires employees seen on video evicting black guest". The Washington Post. | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | P | |
"DoubleTree by Hilton scrambles to repair image after black guest is removed in Oregon". Los Angeles Times | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article focuses on the chain, not this specific hotel |
Number of significant souces | 3 | Enough for notability if this event is the focus. see WP:EVENT |
Rublamb ( talk) 22:10, 25 April 2023 (UTC)
The result was keep. Guerillero Parlez Moi 20:44, 3 May 2023 (UTC)
[Hide this box] New to Articles for deletion (AfD)? Read these primers!
Fails WP:ORG and WP:GNG. 2 of the 5 sources relate to a racial incident at the hotel. Other sources are mainly local as per WP:AUD. LibStar ( talk) 06:38, 17 April 2023 (UTC)
Relisted to generate a more thorough discussion and clearer consensus.
Please add new comments below this notice. Thanks,
CycloneYoris
talk! 20:55, 24 April 2023 (UTC)
Source | Significant? | Independent? | Reliable? | Secondary? | Reach | Pass/Fail | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
"38 Portland hotels that tell the Rose City's history". The Oregonian. | Yes | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | P | More of this history should be added to the article if it is kept. |
"Newest $40 million Red Lion largest hotel in Oregon". The Oregonian. | Might be significant but is potentially trivial coverage | yes | yes | yes | Regional | P/F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"List Leaders: Check in with Portland's 5 biggest hotels". Portland Business Journal. | No, fails under trivial coverage | yes | yes | yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, particularly in "best of", "top 100", "fastest growing" or similar lists is considered trivial |
"6 Portland Hotels with Outdoor Pools for Your Summer Staycation". Portland Monthly. | No | yes | yes | yes | Local | F | Per WP:PRODUCTREV: Brief and routine reviews do not qualify as significant coverage. Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, is considered trivial. |
"Photo essay: Outdoor swimming pools, public and private". Oregon Business. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | mentioned in one sentence |
"Portland Sheraton Hotel Job Progresses". Mail Tribune. Medford, Oregon. | No, | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local but UPI | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Grand opening today, Sheraton-Portland Hotel". The Register-Guard. Eugene, Oregon. | No | No | No | No | Regional | F | Paid Advertisement |
"Lloyd Corp. may change hotel firms". The Oregon Journal. p. 1. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Thunderbird–Red Lion buys Lloyd Sheraton". The Oregonian. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | |
"Red Lion Dining has arrived at Lloyd Center" (advertisement), in The Oregon Journal | No | No | No | No | statewide | F | |
"Red Lion considers 300 additional rooms". The Oregonian. | Assume so, but falls under trivial | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | |
"Doubletree To Pay $1.2 Billion For Red Lion". The Seattle Times. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article is on the chain, not this specific hotel |
"Downtown Red Lion Is Now Doubletree". The Spokesman-Review. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: standard notices, brief announcements, and routine coverage of expansions, acquisitions, mergers, sales, or closure of the business is considered trivial |
"Last of Red Lion Inns' holdings to be sold to Ohio lodging company". The Columbian. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article is on the chain, not this specific hotel |
"DoubleTree by Hilton Introduces New Global Brand Identity, Creating One of Biggest Hotel Groups". Business Wire. | No | No | No | Yes | National | F | Article is on chain, not this hotel; Business Wire published press releases. See WP:ORGIND |
"Washington man arraigned in homicide at Portland's Doubletree Hotel". The Oregonian. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Articles are about a crime at this location, not the hotel itself. See WP:INHERITORG |
"Family suing Hilton hotel group, Backpage.com for enabling prostitution, daughter's murder". Statesman Journal. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | |
"Murder victim's family sues hotel chain after Portland killing". KATU. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | |
"Portland's outdoor hotel pools, ranked". The Oregonian | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Regional | F | Per WP:CORPDEPTH: inclusion in lists of similar organizations, particularly in "best of", "top 100", "fastest growing" or similar lists is considered trivial |
Fodor's Pacific Northwest: with Oregon, Washington & Vancouver. Fodor's Travel. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | Per WP:PRODUCTREV: Brief and routine reviews do not qualify as significant coverage. Also, some of this content is routinely provided by the subject or its employee. See WP:ORGIND |
Fodor's Oregon. Fodor's Travel. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
. "DoubleTree by Hilton–Portland". Fodor's. Archived | Possibly | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
Moon Portland. Avalon Publishing. | No | Assumed, but not always | Yes | Yes | International | F | |
Number of significant sources | 1 (or 2) | both are from The Oregonian |
Source | Significant? | Independent? | Reliable? | Secondary? | Reach | Pass/Fail | Notes |
---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
"Portland hotel calls police on black guest talking to his mom on phone". KGW. | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | Solid source, but too local to prove notablity |
"$10M lawsuit claims racial profiling at DoubleTree hotel". Portland Tribune | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Local | F | Solid source, but too local to prove notablity |
"Black Guest Kicked Out Of Portland DoubleTree In 2018 Sues Hotel For $10 Million". Oregon Public Broadcasting. | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | Statewide | P | |
"Tina Gordon on Making 'Praise This' Not Too 'Preachy'". Essence | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | F | Linked article does not mention the hotel |
"DoubleTree Portland Hotel fires 2 workers for calling police on black hotel guest". ABC News | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | P | |
"Oregon hotel fires employees seen on video evicting black guest". The Washington Post. | Yes for the incident | Yes | Yes | Yes | National | P | |
"DoubleTree by Hilton scrambles to repair image after black guest is removed in Oregon". Los Angeles Times | No | Yes | Yes | Yes | Out of state | F | Article focuses on the chain, not this specific hotel |
Number of significant souces | 3 | Enough for notability if this event is the focus. see WP:EVENT |
Rublamb ( talk) 22:10, 25 April 2023 (UTC)