The result was keep. Consensus is clear that subject satisfies GNG for multiple accomplishments. BLP1E is inapplicable regardless to a subject's voluntary participation for nineteen days on a nationally broadcast television program, so neither the letter nor spirit of BLP1E would be served by applying it here. It's not "BLP1THINGOFANYKIND". postdlf ( talk) 18:45, 1 August 2014 (UTC)
Article was deleted following discussion 26 October 2010 based upon WP:BLP1E arguments. Article was undeleted and userfied 9 December 2011 following request for undeletion on the basis that as the founder of National History Bee and Bowl, the subject met WP:N requirements. Article moved from user space to live article 13 December 2011.
Since restoration, article has not been improved to a good state, and WP:BLP issues have still not been addressed. Relationship to National History Bee and Bowl is mentioned only in passing, and focus of article remains his appearances on Jeopardy!, which circle back to WP:BLP1E.
Google serach for "david madden national history bee and bowl" provides no results that meet WP:BLPPRIMARY or WP:SIGCOV. WP:BIO does not provide guidelines for founders of quiz bowls, and while the individual is tangently related to academia, WP:ACADEMIC does not apply to Madden as he is not a scholar or researcher. AldezD ( talk) 17:53, 6 July 2014 (UTC)
WP:BLP1E does not apply because sources like the Billings Gazette article and The Daily Gazette article show that Madden has received media coverage from his involvement in National History Bee and Bowl.
The result was keep. Consensus is clear that subject satisfies GNG for multiple accomplishments. BLP1E is inapplicable regardless to a subject's voluntary participation for nineteen days on a nationally broadcast television program, so neither the letter nor spirit of BLP1E would be served by applying it here. It's not "BLP1THINGOFANYKIND". postdlf ( talk) 18:45, 1 August 2014 (UTC)
Article was deleted following discussion 26 October 2010 based upon WP:BLP1E arguments. Article was undeleted and userfied 9 December 2011 following request for undeletion on the basis that as the founder of National History Bee and Bowl, the subject met WP:N requirements. Article moved from user space to live article 13 December 2011.
Since restoration, article has not been improved to a good state, and WP:BLP issues have still not been addressed. Relationship to National History Bee and Bowl is mentioned only in passing, and focus of article remains his appearances on Jeopardy!, which circle back to WP:BLP1E.
Google serach for "david madden national history bee and bowl" provides no results that meet WP:BLPPRIMARY or WP:SIGCOV. WP:BIO does not provide guidelines for founders of quiz bowls, and while the individual is tangently related to academia, WP:ACADEMIC does not apply to Madden as he is not a scholar or researcher. AldezD ( talk) 17:53, 6 July 2014 (UTC)
WP:BLP1E does not apply because sources like the Billings Gazette article and The Daily Gazette article show that Madden has received media coverage from his involvement in National History Bee and Bowl.