The result was keep. No particular consensus has arisen to delete this article, and it certainly seems implied that the awards listed are sufficiently prominent to warrant inclusion. The acrimonious wider discussion about the sourcing of articles in this area does not seem to have reached any particularly decisive conclusion, but in this particular case there is clearly insufficient support for deletion. ~ mazca talk 14:47, 21 March 2010 (UTC) reply
As there has been a sustained attempt to source this article, and the sources supplied have been repeatedly deleted for Dave Awards and Gay Erotic Video Awards (both being reliant on the Adam Gay Video Directory as a source), there seems little prospect of appropriate sources being found in the near future. Consequently the article fails to meet WP:PORNBIO as currently stated. As the creator of the article, I would appreciate a discussion in order to set a precedent for this topic so that I do not waste future effort creating articles or stubs likely to be deleted or the center of lengthy dispute over interpretation of the sourcing and notability policies. Ash ( talk) 18:58, 12 March 2010 (UTC) reply
The result was keep. No particular consensus has arisen to delete this article, and it certainly seems implied that the awards listed are sufficiently prominent to warrant inclusion. The acrimonious wider discussion about the sourcing of articles in this area does not seem to have reached any particularly decisive conclusion, but in this particular case there is clearly insufficient support for deletion. ~ mazca talk 14:47, 21 March 2010 (UTC) reply
As there has been a sustained attempt to source this article, and the sources supplied have been repeatedly deleted for Dave Awards and Gay Erotic Video Awards (both being reliant on the Adam Gay Video Directory as a source), there seems little prospect of appropriate sources being found in the near future. Consequently the article fails to meet WP:PORNBIO as currently stated. As the creator of the article, I would appreciate a discussion in order to set a precedent for this topic so that I do not waste future effort creating articles or stubs likely to be deleted or the center of lengthy dispute over interpretation of the sourcing and notability policies. Ash ( talk) 18:58, 12 March 2010 (UTC) reply