The result was no consensus. Sandstein 09:07, 28 December 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete nn film, fails WP:NOTFILM Mayalld ( talk) 13:02, 23 December 2008 (UTC) reply
Gratified that WP:AGF allows you to read my mind. How many fingers am I holding up now? Well... and despite your telepathic abilities, I do not believe notability is inherited, and am saddened that that is all you were able to discern from my response. Am also saddened that you seem to interpret WP:AGF in a manner that benefits only yours and no other's opinions. Conversely, you now underscore my own concern in your belief that because the article is difficult to source then it ipso-facto non-notable. I note that each guideline begins with the caveat that they should be "best treated with common sense and the occasional exception." I am voicing my belief that because of the notable and award-winning director who created the project AND and because of the number of Telugu notables involved in the project, that non-English sources are likely to exist. I am not saying that their being notable makes the project also notable, only that because of their participation, non-English sources quite likely exist. Further, the involvement of these notables allows me the presumption that 37 years ago (PRE-INTERNET / PRE-WIKIPEDIA) there were likely innumerable Telugu reliable HARDCOPY sources speaking toward notability. That these hardcopy sources have not found themselves in English film or news archives does not mean they did not then exist. Since notability is not temporary, I will accept an aged notability as having then existed. WP:NF does not mandate the sources be used... only that a logical presumption of their existance be made. Allowing a little leeway for a Telegu film because of the lack of English sources is "common sense" and is the "occasional exception" to which guidelines refer. I do not expect you to agree in the slightest. I fully expect you to once again attack my reasoning. That incivility is yours and not mine. Thank you and Merry Christmas. Schmidt, MICHAEL Q. 21:56, 26 December 2008 (UTC) reply
The result was no consensus. Sandstein 09:07, 28 December 2008 (UTC) reply
Delete nn film, fails WP:NOTFILM Mayalld ( talk) 13:02, 23 December 2008 (UTC) reply
Gratified that WP:AGF allows you to read my mind. How many fingers am I holding up now? Well... and despite your telepathic abilities, I do not believe notability is inherited, and am saddened that that is all you were able to discern from my response. Am also saddened that you seem to interpret WP:AGF in a manner that benefits only yours and no other's opinions. Conversely, you now underscore my own concern in your belief that because the article is difficult to source then it ipso-facto non-notable. I note that each guideline begins with the caveat that they should be "best treated with common sense and the occasional exception." I am voicing my belief that because of the notable and award-winning director who created the project AND and because of the number of Telugu notables involved in the project, that non-English sources are likely to exist. I am not saying that their being notable makes the project also notable, only that because of their participation, non-English sources quite likely exist. Further, the involvement of these notables allows me the presumption that 37 years ago (PRE-INTERNET / PRE-WIKIPEDIA) there were likely innumerable Telugu reliable HARDCOPY sources speaking toward notability. That these hardcopy sources have not found themselves in English film or news archives does not mean they did not then exist. Since notability is not temporary, I will accept an aged notability as having then existed. WP:NF does not mandate the sources be used... only that a logical presumption of their existance be made. Allowing a little leeway for a Telegu film because of the lack of English sources is "common sense" and is the "occasional exception" to which guidelines refer. I do not expect you to agree in the slightest. I fully expect you to once again attack my reasoning. That incivility is yours and not mine. Thank you and Merry Christmas. Schmidt, MICHAEL Q. 21:56, 26 December 2008 (UTC) reply