The result was Nomination withdrawn for meeting WP:GNG but not WP:NRU.. LibStar ( talk) 00:26, 17 June 2011 (UTC) reply
fails WP:NRU which clearly states that pre professional era of rugby, players must meet WP:GNG. although over 100 years ago, could not find anything in gbooks or google. maybe if he played a few tests but 1 test and no evidence of coverage. LibStar ( talk) 06:49, 16 June 2011 (UTC) reply
there's not in-depth coverage (as in a feature article only on him as the topic), but I think it might be ok for WP:GNG? it might not meet the "Significant coverage" part, but I'm not sure how much coverage was given to Rugby Union players at the time (eg did they have feature articles written about them).
The result was Nomination withdrawn for meeting WP:GNG but not WP:NRU.. LibStar ( talk) 00:26, 17 June 2011 (UTC) reply
fails WP:NRU which clearly states that pre professional era of rugby, players must meet WP:GNG. although over 100 years ago, could not find anything in gbooks or google. maybe if he played a few tests but 1 test and no evidence of coverage. LibStar ( talk) 06:49, 16 June 2011 (UTC) reply
there's not in-depth coverage (as in a feature article only on him as the topic), but I think it might be ok for WP:GNG? it might not meet the "Significant coverage" part, but I'm not sure how much coverage was given to Rugby Union players at the time (eg did they have feature articles written about them).