This page is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
Archives: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 ∞ |
The Guidance Barnstar | ||
For exceptional guidance towards a less-experienced Wikipedia editor, and for becoming a de-factor mentor; you have my eternal thanks! Ks64q2 ( talk) 02:11, 20 March 2009 (UTC) |
Noticing your listing of Linguistatlarge's nomination, per the standard procedure, you might want to remove the listing from the main RFA page. Nominations are normally not listed until the candidate has formally accepted the nomination and has completed answering the questions. Someguy1221 ( talk) 21:44, 20 March 2009 (UTC)
{{helpme}} Please could someone who understands image permissions look at the image on the German wikipedia on de:Esther von Kirchbach and, if appropriate, put it on the Wikimedia Commons site so that it appears in the article I've just translated here?
I notice the other commemorative stamps from the Women in German history series are all already on Wikimedia Commons, so I wonder if there's some specific reason why this one isn't. Thanks!
Hey,
What's your line of thinking RE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tea party (protest)? Ottre 16:34, 24 March 2009 (UTC)
Hi. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodeo in the United States is just one of several actions taken by Montanabw to interfere with Buttermilk1950, all appearing to stem from ownership on Montanabw's part. Would you endorse an RFC/User about Montanabw's behavior? -- Una Smith ( talk) 17:22, 25 March 2009 (UTC)
I'm not involved in this, and I really don't want to be. I've had no interactions with Montanabw or Buttermilk. But I'm prepared to comment at a RFC/User on the remarks made in that AfD.— S Marshall Talk/ Cont 08:38, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
I noticed in the AfD discussion on the Show-Me Institute article, you raised a question concerning the article on the group's co-founder, Rex Sinquefield. I believe that same question should apply to the article on the group's vice president, Jason Hannasch, which is why I have nominated the article on Hannasch for deletion. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this matter on the relevant AfD discussion page. -- TommyBoy ( talk) 14:04, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
In regards to the closing of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of possible exceptions to the democratic peace theory, shouldn't there be a mention on Talk:List of wars between democracies that it survived an AfD? Kingturtle ( talk) 14:36, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
Aside from the fact that the article gives the wrong name to the RICS four times - it is the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors not Institute, this article covers only one very small aspect of what chartered surveyors do in the UK. It describes what a valuer does but makes no mention of Chartered Surveyors working in any of the following specialised fields all of whom are chartered surveyors:
I recommend that the relevant sections of the article is merged into the Real Estate Valuation article. -- DavidCane ( talk) 14:40, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Those other articles are at a different level of abstraction. By analogy, Wikipedia quite properly has articles for Society of Automotive Engineers, Automotive design and Automotive industry (as well as Road transport, Automobile, and right down to BMW 7 series.)— S Marshall Talk/ Cont 18:24, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Just a comment about Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Real Girls Media. NOINDEX is disabled by the devs in the articlespace, so adding it to an article does nothing. Just a heads up. MBisanz talk 23:52, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Hi, you participated in a deletion review for the article Sheree Silver not to long ago, and I've been asking the participants if they're interested in commenting because the article recently went to Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Sheree_Silver_(2nd_nomination). If you get a chance, feel free. Spring12 ( talk) 20:21, 31 March 2009 (UTC)
I don't go much for thankspam, but I just wanted to drop in and give you a big and belated thanks for nominating me for adminship. I will do my best to use the tools in a trustworthy manner. Be sure to troutslap me if you see any inappropriate actions on my part. Thanks again, — LinguistAtLarge • Talk 15:47, 4 April 2009 (UTC)
For what it's worth, there's a class="xfd-closed"
class in the HTML generated by {{
subst:afd top}}, that can be used, by modifying one's chosen style sheet, to collapse closed discussions. There's no need for extra manual collapse markup.
Uncle G (
talk) 18:09, 8 April 2009 (UTC)
On behalf of the Kindness campaign, I just wanted to wish my fellow Wikipedians a Happy Easter! Sincerely, -- A Nobody My talk 07:54, 12 April 2009 (UTC)
Welcome S Marshall!
Thank you for voting.
If you wish, you may retain the following receipt as evidence of your vote:
SPID: 1573 -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux) hQQOAzWmQkC5j9heEA//QHQCX8jdd6h+r3PkLLI73EsVicmvfnNZTTadMzEYDc6O oYR/gW7vSkxjQ5Gzt9HtC3KJN9mAtHMlumphN6Wbj9YLmtu3VwlXo0MtS6iawS5c p8VLsa7xJYr7hmRl97USWbq5Wll956rSOQ82l6qcNwLbGMqz8p2mjU6Iud2XrolB sByl1AcyQzQkIMtOOf8WOl7HZCCS3+jF02JNXxAmN5Z3CpbCSgP3e0S7wYJAgp8o AJYZufu5Fx4GMlF3q6SjGYtf2kAWzssrtI+ZNYO3+bY6I+d00xWrpcfpGh1LUNgg P/9TzoJK5ccrvBTJJSwEr1kCO52fCDlGri/3ckyQs6fnGrGy5LIKxihTSCJ0vNks x/QTRT79wGSj+lUFdAWAUjam12ut8LIXTIaybvykRehwUK7kMqYO7x3EJDrx6aI9 kiT209Bk5cvDY21XvFz0KGpU9JL74HyEuiVysA1OOjTxZY4x6vXrKBWjIu4jSGUf Tml2RxWTD8YuvV9Vyf632+RV4ya6HQG4gJjaYckY0+DDxkATwdLcr6xklieyG0gR TGyO6KTb14hAJtiYhKXEVz/InKgIjCXTYofrDdSiPnUR/70fIGac9iAGhXI8yNVZ N39v3fE2uJ7rZXrjxdbB7y80L87ROa5Zj3zuPHAQpLJ5mc0AzuHUua/C7MsoEcoQ AJFQqBNBaix9V4LWIuw3fvLO0P/0hb9cG1Kf2Y6YnnN6JbHlL2anbkHI2rwC2OYz eJ2HYfOyB11TnbaRiZihabPeoMwwelLLoV6vBZwR7f+yVd4x70qqDSdFhsiV1hGF n1FWdEbZshEOMz3WEI7q6B5yKMvAmo/g+3IWkH0a61PWQRIMVZYUT8cHHfn9nlSC voPaZu5z35SALWfZ/bx6ud8du92Hm+e1oFkEk3LwunajDIypOYHHhZ7KjL0DYODQ hK4sOZU3gOCP/TJ3oSHWaH0IXy5JfWZ/soPL7XpzmMtUwPrLVFgOxSAfeGKMtGvj 4BL7rM4y2Lc0fcs4kaZDJet5lPR94etR1BVG796zf9+B6FR6fmDZvTUcrYN+T4RA f+/kqdSou9vpGFOmE6d2m6k8SJ4msIRtkukAH33+VUsqAN3gzO/h0Y9dNc97KnBV AVB7BLLmsTQK7WTGTT/Jvsr6WfqX2YqJVf2Gr7nXijKoc/gj/v+AOGaJgXw8mnPA n0RcvjxMv0acnrEnPNtlHfCn7nTQQvQw2RSgn55BvbLUgW2USNrHz/c4Pr9mcPzs wHusgE0OP+9yZ+aICH4EciZXmDwRwUrDlvnGFBO5zTQVGPVDTDdybE5sMIPiSu4m AmuN8wxRxxwO0TyQxNvaPaMH4ctNJTnoy3QYhVVVlbyX0pkBI6cLC4u2R5AufHu1 4qOnz4k1G2SFeBtj+ouhDYQ4dJJzzbjptsSKq5N7gAGcjsLsJGsJDfacnKGc9Mg+ uJBBzW7rSVlj+G3HOt8HPVul17XN/IP30Zqj5rhBlrJ4L/wpolQlLQD+oY43shpL EJO9KJQXl6/5k2xrSkAEkqoFdIMWR1KlxVZdnO9vDxap8XcQgRkncYn8x+c= =UX/N -----END PGP MESSAGE-----
Thanks for clearing it up, I'll stick to tagging as vandalism then. Cheers! Nicktfx ( talk) 22:04, 15 April 2009 (UTC)
Thank you for participating in my recent RfA, which was unable pass with a final tally of (45/39/9). I plan on addressing the concerns raised and working to improve in the next several months. Hopefully, if/when I have another RfA I will win your support. Special thanks go to MBisanz, GT5162, and MC10 for nominating me. Thanks again, - down load ׀ sign! 01:34, 13 May 2009 (UTC) |
Unfortunately, my RFA was closed today with a final tally of 75 ½/38/10. Though it didn't succeed, I wanted to thank you for your participation in it. I intend to review the support, oppose, and neutral !votes and see what I can do to address those concerns. Special thanks go to Schmidt, MICHAEL Q., TomStar81, and henrik for their co-nominations and support. — BQZip01 — talk 20:15, 15 May 2009 (UTC) |
FlyingToaster Barnstar
Hello S Marshall! Thank you so much for your support in my
recent RfA, which passed with a tally of 126/32/5. I am truly humbled by the trust you placed in me, and will endeavor to live up to that trust.
Flying
Toaster
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dispatches (magazine). Later (or, "toodlepips"), Drmies ( talk) 05:07, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
I have restored an earlier version of Budj cat after your edits. If you look at the page history, the original article was tagged as {{ db-vandalism}}, which the page author improperly removed. Rather than {{ prod}} this article, the {{ db-vandalism}} should be restored, as this is exactly the type of nonsense the vandalism tag is intended to avoid. WikiDan61 ChatMe! ReadMe!! 20:19, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
This page is an archive of past discussions. Do not edit the contents of this page. If you wish to start a new discussion or revive an old one, please do so on the current talk page. |
Archives: 1 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 26 27 28 29 30 31 32 33 34 35 36 37 38 39 40 41 42 43 44 ∞ |
The Guidance Barnstar | ||
For exceptional guidance towards a less-experienced Wikipedia editor, and for becoming a de-factor mentor; you have my eternal thanks! Ks64q2 ( talk) 02:11, 20 March 2009 (UTC) |
Noticing your listing of Linguistatlarge's nomination, per the standard procedure, you might want to remove the listing from the main RFA page. Nominations are normally not listed until the candidate has formally accepted the nomination and has completed answering the questions. Someguy1221 ( talk) 21:44, 20 March 2009 (UTC)
{{helpme}} Please could someone who understands image permissions look at the image on the German wikipedia on de:Esther von Kirchbach and, if appropriate, put it on the Wikimedia Commons site so that it appears in the article I've just translated here?
I notice the other commemorative stamps from the Women in German history series are all already on Wikimedia Commons, so I wonder if there's some specific reason why this one isn't. Thanks!
Hey,
What's your line of thinking RE Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Tea party (protest)? Ottre 16:34, 24 March 2009 (UTC)
Hi. Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Rodeo in the United States is just one of several actions taken by Montanabw to interfere with Buttermilk1950, all appearing to stem from ownership on Montanabw's part. Would you endorse an RFC/User about Montanabw's behavior? -- Una Smith ( talk) 17:22, 25 March 2009 (UTC)
I'm not involved in this, and I really don't want to be. I've had no interactions with Montanabw or Buttermilk. But I'm prepared to comment at a RFC/User on the remarks made in that AfD.— S Marshall Talk/ Cont 08:38, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
I noticed in the AfD discussion on the Show-Me Institute article, you raised a question concerning the article on the group's co-founder, Rex Sinquefield. I believe that same question should apply to the article on the group's vice president, Jason Hannasch, which is why I have nominated the article on Hannasch for deletion. Please feel free to share your thoughts on this matter on the relevant AfD discussion page. -- TommyBoy ( talk) 14:04, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
In regards to the closing of Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/List of possible exceptions to the democratic peace theory, shouldn't there be a mention on Talk:List of wars between democracies that it survived an AfD? Kingturtle ( talk) 14:36, 26 March 2009 (UTC)
Aside from the fact that the article gives the wrong name to the RICS four times - it is the Royal Institution of Chartered Surveyors not Institute, this article covers only one very small aspect of what chartered surveyors do in the UK. It describes what a valuer does but makes no mention of Chartered Surveyors working in any of the following specialised fields all of whom are chartered surveyors:
I recommend that the relevant sections of the article is merged into the Real Estate Valuation article. -- DavidCane ( talk) 14:40, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Those other articles are at a different level of abstraction. By analogy, Wikipedia quite properly has articles for Society of Automotive Engineers, Automotive design and Automotive industry (as well as Road transport, Automobile, and right down to BMW 7 series.)— S Marshall Talk/ Cont 18:24, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Just a comment about Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Real Girls Media. NOINDEX is disabled by the devs in the articlespace, so adding it to an article does nothing. Just a heads up. MBisanz talk 23:52, 28 March 2009 (UTC)
Hi, you participated in a deletion review for the article Sheree Silver not to long ago, and I've been asking the participants if they're interested in commenting because the article recently went to Wikipedia:Articles_for_deletion/Sheree_Silver_(2nd_nomination). If you get a chance, feel free. Spring12 ( talk) 20:21, 31 March 2009 (UTC)
I don't go much for thankspam, but I just wanted to drop in and give you a big and belated thanks for nominating me for adminship. I will do my best to use the tools in a trustworthy manner. Be sure to troutslap me if you see any inappropriate actions on my part. Thanks again, — LinguistAtLarge • Talk 15:47, 4 April 2009 (UTC)
For what it's worth, there's a class="xfd-closed"
class in the HTML generated by {{
subst:afd top}}, that can be used, by modifying one's chosen style sheet, to collapse closed discussions. There's no need for extra manual collapse markup.
Uncle G (
talk) 18:09, 8 April 2009 (UTC)
On behalf of the Kindness campaign, I just wanted to wish my fellow Wikipedians a Happy Easter! Sincerely, -- A Nobody My talk 07:54, 12 April 2009 (UTC)
Welcome S Marshall!
Thank you for voting.
If you wish, you may retain the following receipt as evidence of your vote:
SPID: 1573 -----BEGIN PGP MESSAGE----- Version: GnuPG v1.4.1 (GNU/Linux) hQQOAzWmQkC5j9heEA//QHQCX8jdd6h+r3PkLLI73EsVicmvfnNZTTadMzEYDc6O oYR/gW7vSkxjQ5Gzt9HtC3KJN9mAtHMlumphN6Wbj9YLmtu3VwlXo0MtS6iawS5c p8VLsa7xJYr7hmRl97USWbq5Wll956rSOQ82l6qcNwLbGMqz8p2mjU6Iud2XrolB sByl1AcyQzQkIMtOOf8WOl7HZCCS3+jF02JNXxAmN5Z3CpbCSgP3e0S7wYJAgp8o AJYZufu5Fx4GMlF3q6SjGYtf2kAWzssrtI+ZNYO3+bY6I+d00xWrpcfpGh1LUNgg P/9TzoJK5ccrvBTJJSwEr1kCO52fCDlGri/3ckyQs6fnGrGy5LIKxihTSCJ0vNks x/QTRT79wGSj+lUFdAWAUjam12ut8LIXTIaybvykRehwUK7kMqYO7x3EJDrx6aI9 kiT209Bk5cvDY21XvFz0KGpU9JL74HyEuiVysA1OOjTxZY4x6vXrKBWjIu4jSGUf Tml2RxWTD8YuvV9Vyf632+RV4ya6HQG4gJjaYckY0+DDxkATwdLcr6xklieyG0gR TGyO6KTb14hAJtiYhKXEVz/InKgIjCXTYofrDdSiPnUR/70fIGac9iAGhXI8yNVZ N39v3fE2uJ7rZXrjxdbB7y80L87ROa5Zj3zuPHAQpLJ5mc0AzuHUua/C7MsoEcoQ AJFQqBNBaix9V4LWIuw3fvLO0P/0hb9cG1Kf2Y6YnnN6JbHlL2anbkHI2rwC2OYz eJ2HYfOyB11TnbaRiZihabPeoMwwelLLoV6vBZwR7f+yVd4x70qqDSdFhsiV1hGF n1FWdEbZshEOMz3WEI7q6B5yKMvAmo/g+3IWkH0a61PWQRIMVZYUT8cHHfn9nlSC voPaZu5z35SALWfZ/bx6ud8du92Hm+e1oFkEk3LwunajDIypOYHHhZ7KjL0DYODQ hK4sOZU3gOCP/TJ3oSHWaH0IXy5JfWZ/soPL7XpzmMtUwPrLVFgOxSAfeGKMtGvj 4BL7rM4y2Lc0fcs4kaZDJet5lPR94etR1BVG796zf9+B6FR6fmDZvTUcrYN+T4RA f+/kqdSou9vpGFOmE6d2m6k8SJ4msIRtkukAH33+VUsqAN3gzO/h0Y9dNc97KnBV AVB7BLLmsTQK7WTGTT/Jvsr6WfqX2YqJVf2Gr7nXijKoc/gj/v+AOGaJgXw8mnPA n0RcvjxMv0acnrEnPNtlHfCn7nTQQvQw2RSgn55BvbLUgW2USNrHz/c4Pr9mcPzs wHusgE0OP+9yZ+aICH4EciZXmDwRwUrDlvnGFBO5zTQVGPVDTDdybE5sMIPiSu4m AmuN8wxRxxwO0TyQxNvaPaMH4ctNJTnoy3QYhVVVlbyX0pkBI6cLC4u2R5AufHu1 4qOnz4k1G2SFeBtj+ouhDYQ4dJJzzbjptsSKq5N7gAGcjsLsJGsJDfacnKGc9Mg+ uJBBzW7rSVlj+G3HOt8HPVul17XN/IP30Zqj5rhBlrJ4L/wpolQlLQD+oY43shpL EJO9KJQXl6/5k2xrSkAEkqoFdIMWR1KlxVZdnO9vDxap8XcQgRkncYn8x+c= =UX/N -----END PGP MESSAGE-----
Thanks for clearing it up, I'll stick to tagging as vandalism then. Cheers! Nicktfx ( talk) 22:04, 15 April 2009 (UTC)
Thank you for participating in my recent RfA, which was unable pass with a final tally of (45/39/9). I plan on addressing the concerns raised and working to improve in the next several months. Hopefully, if/when I have another RfA I will win your support. Special thanks go to MBisanz, GT5162, and MC10 for nominating me. Thanks again, - down load ׀ sign! 01:34, 13 May 2009 (UTC) |
Unfortunately, my RFA was closed today with a final tally of 75 ½/38/10. Though it didn't succeed, I wanted to thank you for your participation in it. I intend to review the support, oppose, and neutral !votes and see what I can do to address those concerns. Special thanks go to Schmidt, MICHAEL Q., TomStar81, and henrik for their co-nominations and support. — BQZip01 — talk 20:15, 15 May 2009 (UTC) |
FlyingToaster Barnstar
Hello S Marshall! Thank you so much for your support in my
recent RfA, which passed with a tally of 126/32/5. I am truly humbled by the trust you placed in me, and will endeavor to live up to that trust.
Flying
Toaster
Wikipedia:Articles for deletion/Dispatches (magazine). Later (or, "toodlepips"), Drmies ( talk) 05:07, 20 April 2009 (UTC)
I have restored an earlier version of Budj cat after your edits. If you look at the page history, the original article was tagged as {{ db-vandalism}}, which the page author improperly removed. Rather than {{ prod}} this article, the {{ db-vandalism}} should be restored, as this is exactly the type of nonsense the vandalism tag is intended to avoid. WikiDan61 ChatMe! ReadMe!! 20:19, 20 April 2009 (UTC)