Index
|
|
This page has archives. Sections older than 1.5 days may be automatically archived by ClueBot III when more than 2 sections are present. |
Hey Cutlass. To say the least, I was shocked to wake up to an AfD for the article which I was planning to GAN this morning… But nonetheless, I wanted to give you a quick reminder on WP:BEFORE since you AfDed the article, no discussion and no PROD less than 26 hours after it was created. Coincidentally, you used WP:LASTING as one of your arguments, but you somehow seem to forgot the event occurred 3 days ago? How on earth could there be lasting coverage when it occurred 3 days ago?? I wrote the article 2 days after the event occurred, giving it enough time to see some lasting-level coverage. Out of curiosity, I casually did a Google search and one hour ago is an entire news article about the tornado ( [1]). All of that was to say you might want to check out WP:BEFORE and consider alternatives to deletion (in this case, merging into Tornado outbreak of December 9–10, 2023, the parent outbreak article OR Tornadoes of 2023, the parent of the outbreak article) or at the very least wait to actually see if there isn’t lasting coverage. Cheers! The Weather Event Writer ( Talk Page) 17:51, 12 December 2023 (UTC)
Hey Cutlass. I wanted to ask if you could withdraw your AfD nomination for the 2024 Sumedang tornado. The AfD already has 2 delete !votes (plus yours). If you withdraw the AfD, I would be more than happy to bold merge/redirect that article. Due to past issues, I cannot and will not redirect/merge the article while the AfD is ongoing, meaning deleting it is being held up on the technicality of the seven-day AfD. So please, withdraw the AfD so myself or you even could merge/redirect the article to Tornadoes of 2024. The Weather Event Writer ( Talk Page) 03:01, 23 February 2024 (UTC)
Index
|
|
This page has archives. Sections older than 1.5 days may be automatically archived by ClueBot III when more than 2 sections are present. |
Hey Cutlass. To say the least, I was shocked to wake up to an AfD for the article which I was planning to GAN this morning… But nonetheless, I wanted to give you a quick reminder on WP:BEFORE since you AfDed the article, no discussion and no PROD less than 26 hours after it was created. Coincidentally, you used WP:LASTING as one of your arguments, but you somehow seem to forgot the event occurred 3 days ago? How on earth could there be lasting coverage when it occurred 3 days ago?? I wrote the article 2 days after the event occurred, giving it enough time to see some lasting-level coverage. Out of curiosity, I casually did a Google search and one hour ago is an entire news article about the tornado ( [1]). All of that was to say you might want to check out WP:BEFORE and consider alternatives to deletion (in this case, merging into Tornado outbreak of December 9–10, 2023, the parent outbreak article OR Tornadoes of 2023, the parent of the outbreak article) or at the very least wait to actually see if there isn’t lasting coverage. Cheers! The Weather Event Writer ( Talk Page) 17:51, 12 December 2023 (UTC)
Hey Cutlass. I wanted to ask if you could withdraw your AfD nomination for the 2024 Sumedang tornado. The AfD already has 2 delete !votes (plus yours). If you withdraw the AfD, I would be more than happy to bold merge/redirect that article. Due to past issues, I cannot and will not redirect/merge the article while the AfD is ongoing, meaning deleting it is being held up on the technicality of the seven-day AfD. So please, withdraw the AfD so myself or you even could merge/redirect the article to Tornadoes of 2024. The Weather Event Writer ( Talk Page) 03:01, 23 February 2024 (UTC)