@ Sergecross73 Okay, I'd like to talk this out rather than entering a hectic edit war, and clarify possible misunderstandings. I didn't say that Sano and Miyake did one or two songs max, I said the other credited composers who aren't in the infobox only did one or two songs max, such as Hiroyuki Maruyama or metalmouse, who have both only claimed doing one song respectively. This is why I did not add the full list of composers - the game has around 10 of them, and I understand fine well that infoboxes do not need to list every person involved. Sano and Miyake have both claimed doing three to four songs (although privately, so it may violate WP:OR), which is quite a lot considering the amount of composers involved. As for Kobayashi and Hirota, well Kobayashi has claimed four songs as her work and as far as I know, Hirota has never disclosed the exact capacity in which he was involved. So I don't understand why those two are listed and not Sano and Miyake if they contributed in a similar capacity.
I know there's more important issues on Wikipedia to tackle, but I'm just confused why you consider those Kobayashi and Hirota more significant than Sano or Miyake here in particular. It seems rather arbitrary to me. Is it to keep the list as small as possible? I have seen many infoboxes that list more than two composers, so I'm not sure. User:Meadowtron ( talk) 14:36, 30 March 2024 (UTC)
![]() | This article is rated C-class on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | ||||||||||||||||||||||||
|
@ Sergecross73 Okay, I'd like to talk this out rather than entering a hectic edit war, and clarify possible misunderstandings. I didn't say that Sano and Miyake did one or two songs max, I said the other credited composers who aren't in the infobox only did one or two songs max, such as Hiroyuki Maruyama or metalmouse, who have both only claimed doing one song respectively. This is why I did not add the full list of composers - the game has around 10 of them, and I understand fine well that infoboxes do not need to list every person involved. Sano and Miyake have both claimed doing three to four songs (although privately, so it may violate WP:OR), which is quite a lot considering the amount of composers involved. As for Kobayashi and Hirota, well Kobayashi has claimed four songs as her work and as far as I know, Hirota has never disclosed the exact capacity in which he was involved. So I don't understand why those two are listed and not Sano and Miyake if they contributed in a similar capacity.
I know there's more important issues on Wikipedia to tackle, but I'm just confused why you consider those Kobayashi and Hirota more significant than Sano or Miyake here in particular. It seems rather arbitrary to me. Is it to keep the list as small as possible? I have seen many infoboxes that list more than two composers, so I'm not sure. User:Meadowtron ( talk) 14:36, 30 March 2024 (UTC)