![]() | Disambiguation | |||
|
There are much stronger reasons for redirecting this page to Magog (disambiguation). First, take another look at that disambiguate page. There is a town in Quebec, and a number of other meanings a reader might have in mind when typing in "Magog" in the search box. That is exactly what disambigs are for: to help people. Taking him right away to Gog and Magog, which is a mediocre and highly unstable article anyway, is just too presumptive. I have now corrected the disambig to make Magog (Bible) the primary reference, since "Gog and Magog" appears only in extra-biblical folklore derived from the Bible, not in the Old Testament itself. Despite popular belief, Ezekiel refers to "prince Gog of Magog", whereas the phrase "Gog and Magog" appears only in the New Testament book of Revelation.
Please also take a look at the links on this page, Magog. A majority of these links will ultimately need to be disambiguated. Most of these would not go to Gog and Magog either, but in the meantime, it is far better that they go to a disambig, than to Gog and Magog.
By the way, I am also opposed to the merging of Magog (Bible) with Gog and Magog, for reasons I have explained at [[Talk:Magog (Bible)]. This proposal has not received much support anyway, and should probably be retired by now. Til Eulenspiegel 13:27, 6 November 2007 (UTC)
-"gog +and magog" noah magog "gog +and magog" -noah
I have sorted out the links to this page, below:
See also:
![]() | Disambiguation | |||
|
There are much stronger reasons for redirecting this page to Magog (disambiguation). First, take another look at that disambiguate page. There is a town in Quebec, and a number of other meanings a reader might have in mind when typing in "Magog" in the search box. That is exactly what disambigs are for: to help people. Taking him right away to Gog and Magog, which is a mediocre and highly unstable article anyway, is just too presumptive. I have now corrected the disambig to make Magog (Bible) the primary reference, since "Gog and Magog" appears only in extra-biblical folklore derived from the Bible, not in the Old Testament itself. Despite popular belief, Ezekiel refers to "prince Gog of Magog", whereas the phrase "Gog and Magog" appears only in the New Testament book of Revelation.
Please also take a look at the links on this page, Magog. A majority of these links will ultimately need to be disambiguated. Most of these would not go to Gog and Magog either, but in the meantime, it is far better that they go to a disambig, than to Gog and Magog.
By the way, I am also opposed to the merging of Magog (Bible) with Gog and Magog, for reasons I have explained at [[Talk:Magog (Bible)]. This proposal has not received much support anyway, and should probably be retired by now. Til Eulenspiegel 13:27, 6 November 2007 (UTC)
-"gog +and magog" noah magog "gog +and magog" -noah
I have sorted out the links to this page, below:
See also: