![]() | This disambiguation page does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||
|
This disambiguation occupied the Wikidata object for the star Kappa Crucis, so I have deleted it. There were three articles connected with it, of which one was misdirected. EnWp and ZhWp was correct and should get a new Wikidata object. Can please one of the authors of these articles fix this in an appropriate way!? Deryni ( talk) 11:49, 14 September 2018 (UTC)
This article is currently a set index , a list of items of the same specific type (eg. a list of stars, see C Centauri). However, it links to two items which are not the same: one is a star and one is a cluster. I'm thinking it should be a real disambiguation page? Lithopsian ( talk) 14:03, 14 September 2018 (UTC)
From talk page in Wikidata for ValterVB.
Your editing of Kappa Crucis is incorrect. Kappa Crucis is a star, a Bayer object. You have directed Kappa Crucis to this disambiguation page. This page lead to Kappa Crucis, but also to the Jewel Box star cluster, which also is called Kappa Crucis cluster, but NOT Kappa Crucis. Please correct this. If there is need for a disambiguation page in EnWp I suggest it should be Kappa Crucis (different meanings) or whatever the syntax may be in EnWp, so that the Bayer object gets priority. Deryni ( talk) 10:13, 16 September 2018 (UTC)
Infovarius Strange. I can not imaging a single reason why en:Kappa Crucis shouldn't be a disambig (except technical _disambig_ which is an error I think)
The star Kappa Crucis should have precedence before the disambiguation as there is only one Kappa Crucis, namely the star. The star cluster, NGC 4755, or the Jewel Box, is also called Kappa Crucis Cluster, as Kappa Crucis is the prime member of the cluster. But it is not called Kappa Crucis. Therefore there is only one Kappa Crucis, the star. Strange to have a disambiguation for one article. Well, if you are pleased to have it this way, I will not take further notice, as I mainly work in the Swedish Wikipedia. But give me this: A disambiguation for one object!? I recommend that you change "en:Kappa Crucis (star)" to "Kappa Crucis". All the best. Deryni ( talk) 16:17, 20 September 2018 (UTC)
![]() | This disambiguation page does not require a rating on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||
|
This disambiguation occupied the Wikidata object for the star Kappa Crucis, so I have deleted it. There were three articles connected with it, of which one was misdirected. EnWp and ZhWp was correct and should get a new Wikidata object. Can please one of the authors of these articles fix this in an appropriate way!? Deryni ( talk) 11:49, 14 September 2018 (UTC)
This article is currently a set index , a list of items of the same specific type (eg. a list of stars, see C Centauri). However, it links to two items which are not the same: one is a star and one is a cluster. I'm thinking it should be a real disambiguation page? Lithopsian ( talk) 14:03, 14 September 2018 (UTC)
From talk page in Wikidata for ValterVB.
Your editing of Kappa Crucis is incorrect. Kappa Crucis is a star, a Bayer object. You have directed Kappa Crucis to this disambiguation page. This page lead to Kappa Crucis, but also to the Jewel Box star cluster, which also is called Kappa Crucis cluster, but NOT Kappa Crucis. Please correct this. If there is need for a disambiguation page in EnWp I suggest it should be Kappa Crucis (different meanings) or whatever the syntax may be in EnWp, so that the Bayer object gets priority. Deryni ( talk) 10:13, 16 September 2018 (UTC)
Infovarius Strange. I can not imaging a single reason why en:Kappa Crucis shouldn't be a disambig (except technical _disambig_ which is an error I think)
The star Kappa Crucis should have precedence before the disambiguation as there is only one Kappa Crucis, namely the star. The star cluster, NGC 4755, or the Jewel Box, is also called Kappa Crucis Cluster, as Kappa Crucis is the prime member of the cluster. But it is not called Kappa Crucis. Therefore there is only one Kappa Crucis, the star. Strange to have a disambiguation for one article. Well, if you are pleased to have it this way, I will not take further notice, as I mainly work in the Swedish Wikipedia. But give me this: A disambiguation for one object!? I recommend that you change "en:Kappa Crucis (star)" to "Kappa Crucis". All the best. Deryni ( talk) 16:17, 20 September 2018 (UTC)