Disambiguation | ||||
|
I can't say that I think that it is responsible to give links here to anyone with the first name Julie. The current list includes maybe ten links to people with that name, but there are undoubtedly zounds of other people with the first name Julie who deserve to be on this list. Therefore, I think it is inappropriate at best to include a list of people whose first name is/was Julie, because the list would be too too long.
My instincts tell me to delete the list of Julies, but I feel I should at least give people some time to respond... HammerHeadHuman 17:34, 18 February 2007 (UTC)
Add a list of Julie's please! My name is Julie and there are lots of other Julie's that need to be recognized! please! ---Julie Raspler —Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.129.83.106 ( talk • contribs)
Ya thats what I did for Julie Andrews, but I forgot her last name was Andrew's so I put Julie and got this. I understand Wikipedia isnt for recognition but there are other name pages, like Nora, which list Nora's. Why can't the Julie page be like that? It's not like, a HUGE concern of mine but why cant it be like that. It wouldn't hurt. ---Julie Raspler
:My issue has nothing to do with the relevance of such a list, I think the list itself is a fine idea but it does not belong on this page, it should be a separate page. In fact, after this comment is posted I will create a page call
List of people with the first name Julie, and add a link on the
Julie page. Also, the list of Julies that I deleted from the page has been moved there; the list is far from complete. -
HammerHeadHuman
(talk)
(work) 02:38, 6 April 2007 (UTC)
Cool ----Julie Raspler —Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.129.70.169 ( talk • contribs) (Julie, you should add ~~~~ to your messages to create a signature like: (John User:Jwy talk) 15:03, 6 April 2007 (UTC)
Disambiguation | ||||
|
I can't say that I think that it is responsible to give links here to anyone with the first name Julie. The current list includes maybe ten links to people with that name, but there are undoubtedly zounds of other people with the first name Julie who deserve to be on this list. Therefore, I think it is inappropriate at best to include a list of people whose first name is/was Julie, because the list would be too too long.
My instincts tell me to delete the list of Julies, but I feel I should at least give people some time to respond... HammerHeadHuman 17:34, 18 February 2007 (UTC)
Add a list of Julie's please! My name is Julie and there are lots of other Julie's that need to be recognized! please! ---Julie Raspler —Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.129.83.106 ( talk • contribs)
Ya thats what I did for Julie Andrews, but I forgot her last name was Andrew's so I put Julie and got this. I understand Wikipedia isnt for recognition but there are other name pages, like Nora, which list Nora's. Why can't the Julie page be like that? It's not like, a HUGE concern of mine but why cant it be like that. It wouldn't hurt. ---Julie Raspler
:My issue has nothing to do with the relevance of such a list, I think the list itself is a fine idea but it does not belong on this page, it should be a separate page. In fact, after this comment is posted I will create a page call
List of people with the first name Julie, and add a link on the
Julie page. Also, the list of Julies that I deleted from the page has been moved there; the list is far from complete. -
HammerHeadHuman
(talk)
(work) 02:38, 6 April 2007 (UTC)
Cool ----Julie Raspler —Preceding unsigned comment added by 84.129.70.169 ( talk • contribs) (Julie, you should add ~~~~ to your messages to create a signature like: (John User:Jwy talk) 15:03, 6 April 2007 (UTC)