Hydra (mythology) →
Lernaean Hydra -- Delete because no one will ever accidentally stumble upon "Hydra (mythology)". There are no links to it, and
Hydra is already a disambig page with a link to
Lernaean Hydra.
Tufflaw 00:35, May 26, 2005 (UTC)
Yeah, but I can easily see someone typing in [[Hydra (mythology)|Hydra]] when they are writing another article. (Trust me, plenty of people don't search, or don't bother to check that their links link to what they think they link to - I've fixed too many duplicate pages, and links to disambig pages...) Seems harmless enough, why not prevent creation of a duplicate article?
Noel(talk)01:25, 26 May 2005 (UTC)reply
Agreed - strong keep. [[Foo (mythology)]] is the standard disambiguator for mythology articles, and relevant redirects with that parenthetical should always be kept. -
Sean Curtin 01:09, May 28, 2005 (UTC)
Hydra (mythology) →
Lernaean Hydra -- Delete because no one will ever accidentally stumble upon "Hydra (mythology)". There are no links to it, and
Hydra is already a disambig page with a link to
Lernaean Hydra.
Tufflaw 00:35, May 26, 2005 (UTC)
Yeah, but I can easily see someone typing in [[Hydra (mythology)|Hydra]] when they are writing another article. (Trust me, plenty of people don't search, or don't bother to check that their links link to what they think they link to - I've fixed too many duplicate pages, and links to disambig pages...) Seems harmless enough, why not prevent creation of a duplicate article?
Noel(talk)01:25, 26 May 2005 (UTC)reply
Agreed - strong keep. [[Foo (mythology)]] is the standard disambiguator for mythology articles, and relevant redirects with that parenthetical should always be kept. -
Sean Curtin 01:09, May 28, 2005 (UTC)