This article has not yet been rated on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
see all links and sources
also there is nothing about heron simurgh
only anqa referenced as heron
as I stated before, Anqa is Confused and actually associated with all mythical birds
because anqa term used as example for non-existent birds in arab parables
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 03:22, 28 August 2019 (UTC)
also anqa can't be simurgh or phoenix
because all three birds have their own myths in Arabian and Persian Culture
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 03:22, 28 August 2019 (UTC)
sīmorgh. It further includes a link to their article for Phoenix, which says
In Islamic mythology the phoenix was identified with the ʿanqāʾ (Persian: sīmorgh), a huge mysterious bird (probably a heron). The Columbia source includes a definition for anqa, which reads as follows:
ʿanqā : '(fem. of aʿnaq , 'long-necked'; rt. ʿanq 'to be long in the neck'), s.m. A fabulous bird, the phœnix; a rara avis (syn. sīmurġh ); —adj. Scarce, rare, hard to get or find; wonderful, curious' (Platts p.766). So we've got a reliable source (Britannica) and a source of unclear reliability (Columbia, although it seems like it's quoting a third source, Platts, which is likely reliable) saying that they are synonyms, and no contemporary sources saying that they aren't synonyms. If you have modern reliable sources (non-English is fine) that argue that simorgh and anqa are two distinct concepts, they would help establish a case that these concepts should not be covered in the same article.
I have many modern sources
I will send all source in talk-page
but it is still your Reliable source say that anqa has many radical differences with Simurgh
Simurgh is Peacock while Anqa is Heron
I think anqa is arabian version of phoenix not simurgh
I don't know why are confusing Simurgh with Phoenix, there are many radical differences, only common feature being mythical Avian
how is simurgh close to phoenix
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 12:26, 12 September 2019 (UTC)
One source claims that Qazwini mentions that Anqa lives at Mount Qaf. Where exactly does he mention it? The given source is weak and not clear. 137.22.90.2 ( talk) 18:35, 16 April 2023 (UTC)
This article has not yet been rated on Wikipedia's
content assessment scale. It is of interest to the following WikiProjects: | |||||||||||||||||||||
|
see all links and sources
also there is nothing about heron simurgh
only anqa referenced as heron
as I stated before, Anqa is Confused and actually associated with all mythical birds
because anqa term used as example for non-existent birds in arab parables
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 03:22, 28 August 2019 (UTC)
also anqa can't be simurgh or phoenix
because all three birds have their own myths in Arabian and Persian Culture
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 03:22, 28 August 2019 (UTC)
sīmorgh. It further includes a link to their article for Phoenix, which says
In Islamic mythology the phoenix was identified with the ʿanqāʾ (Persian: sīmorgh), a huge mysterious bird (probably a heron). The Columbia source includes a definition for anqa, which reads as follows:
ʿanqā : '(fem. of aʿnaq , 'long-necked'; rt. ʿanq 'to be long in the neck'), s.m. A fabulous bird, the phœnix; a rara avis (syn. sīmurġh ); —adj. Scarce, rare, hard to get or find; wonderful, curious' (Platts p.766). So we've got a reliable source (Britannica) and a source of unclear reliability (Columbia, although it seems like it's quoting a third source, Platts, which is likely reliable) saying that they are synonyms, and no contemporary sources saying that they aren't synonyms. If you have modern reliable sources (non-English is fine) that argue that simorgh and anqa are two distinct concepts, they would help establish a case that these concepts should not be covered in the same article.
I have many modern sources
I will send all source in talk-page
but it is still your Reliable source say that anqa has many radical differences with Simurgh
Simurgh is Peacock while Anqa is Heron
I think anqa is arabian version of phoenix not simurgh
I don't know why are confusing Simurgh with Phoenix, there are many radical differences, only common feature being mythical Avian
how is simurgh close to phoenix
أبو السعد 22 ( talk) 12:26, 12 September 2019 (UTC)
One source claims that Qazwini mentions that Anqa lives at Mount Qaf. Where exactly does he mention it? The given source is weak and not clear. 137.22.90.2 ( talk) 18:35, 16 April 2023 (UTC)