18:5418:54, 11 April 2024diffhist−47
Battle of Shuja'iyya (2023)
Undid revision
1218400528 by
Based guyy (
talk) The original
Battle of Shuja'iyya is listed as an Israeli military victory despite the IDF later withdrawing. If the IDF achieved its goals there then it doesn't necessarily mean it was defeated, even if Hamas later returned. This is debatable, create a discussion and reach a consensus if you think it should be listed as such.Tag: Undo
13:0813:08, 11 April 2024diffhist+141
Battle of Shuja'iyya (2023)
Adding in the Israeli claim, which is mentioned in Hebrew Wikipedia. Also, again the idea it was a Palestinian victory, as in the other battles, should be discussed in the talk page. From Israel's point of view destroying the local Hamas battalion may have been a victory.
17:3817:38, 10 April 2024diffhist−2
Siege of Khan Yunis
Where does the figure of 100 killed come from? That would mean almost 40% of IDF soldiers killed in the ground invasion were killed in Khan Yunis. The Hebrew Wikipedia figure should stay until a definitive source can be found
14:3414:34, 10 April 2024diffhist−1
Battle of Beit Hanoun
Putting "Palestinian victory" is contentious and should be subject to discussion. It could be that the IDF simply degraded Hamas to a sufficient extent even if they pulled out.
18:5418:54, 11 April 2024diffhist−47
Battle of Shuja'iyya (2023)
Undid revision
1218400528 by
Based guyy (
talk) The original
Battle of Shuja'iyya is listed as an Israeli military victory despite the IDF later withdrawing. If the IDF achieved its goals there then it doesn't necessarily mean it was defeated, even if Hamas later returned. This is debatable, create a discussion and reach a consensus if you think it should be listed as such.Tag: Undo
13:0813:08, 11 April 2024diffhist+141
Battle of Shuja'iyya (2023)
Adding in the Israeli claim, which is mentioned in Hebrew Wikipedia. Also, again the idea it was a Palestinian victory, as in the other battles, should be discussed in the talk page. From Israel's point of view destroying the local Hamas battalion may have been a victory.
17:3817:38, 10 April 2024diffhist−2
Siege of Khan Yunis
Where does the figure of 100 killed come from? That would mean almost 40% of IDF soldiers killed in the ground invasion were killed in Khan Yunis. The Hebrew Wikipedia figure should stay until a definitive source can be found
14:3414:34, 10 April 2024diffhist−1
Battle of Beit Hanoun
Putting "Palestinian victory" is contentious and should be subject to discussion. It could be that the IDF simply degraded Hamas to a sufficient extent even if they pulled out.