16:3016:30, 10 May 2024diffhist+3
Jewish cemetery of Salonica
The word "finally" just seems disrespectful; it could be read with a similar nuance to "at last". Am I over thinking it? Open to better suggestions.currentTags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
05:2105:21, 25 May 2022diffhist−112
ApologetiX
→Band members: Unlinking. The few of these that actually had articles ended up being for different people entirely, and if the red links are left alone, it will keep happening.
1 April 2022
11:1411:14, 1 April 2022diffhist+992
Lifespring
→Criticism: Some of this, I can source, some more I can add from the article, but the rest (the death threat) I am removing since it is not in the article. If there is a separate (or more complete) interview where she actually says this, please share!
09:1409:14, 1 April 2022diffhist+167
Seiji Nishino
→Bibliography: The original Japanese version should be listed here (especially since it looks like we have a couple translated versions)Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
11:3911:39, 17 August 2021diffhist−63
Rising Sun Flag
Sorry for the delayed reply. Again, Fantastic Four is not a good example since this is not a Japanese comic and this should not be used to represent Japanese comics. A reader of this article would be very confused into thinking perhaps Fantastic Four were a Japanese franchise..
16:2416:24, 25 April 2020diffhist−316
Battle of Shiroyama
Undid revision 953024621 by Lack of Plethora - I appreciate that you tried to provide rationale for including them here, but I still believe Sabaton to just be trivia. Works included here should have wide cultural impact. Last Samurai would meet that bar, but
Last Samurai doesn't even mention Shiroyama so we don't have a source saying it was inspired by this battle. It would be more relevant in e.g.
Satsuma Rebellion or
Saigō Takamori instead of this battle specifically...Tag: Undo
18 January 2020
23:0023:00, 18 January 2020diffhist−160
High-speed rail
Agree this is not relevant to HSR. This is what happens when
WP:PROCON goes too far... the purpose of these articles isn't to let each side argue for and against, but to give an NPOV presentation of the topic as a whole. Really this whole section needs a rework.Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
22:4722:47, 18 January 2020diffhist+6
High-speed rail
Undid revision 933859825 by
VivaBlondie2000 (
talk) - Actually, we do need the D.C. It is normal for local route maps to add D.C. to Washington even though state abbreviations aren't added to NYC or Philly. This also removes ambiguity with Washington StateTags: UndoMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
31 December 2019
23:3523:35, 31 December 2019diffhist−43
Battle of Shiroyama
Yeah... Last Samurai doesn't belong there either. In prose (not list format), this might merit a one line callout as something "inspired" by the battle (if a source says that...) but it is not a depiction of the actual battle. Without an explanation of its significance, this is not relevant and does not merit a list.Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
15:0215:02, 9 December 2019diffhist−61
Rising Sun Flag
→Present day use: I don't think Fantastic Four is a good example since this is not a Japanese comic. I accept that this could potentially be an example of *overseas* use, which is covered in a later section, however, Wikipedia is not a list, we don't necessarily need examples of every usage unless notable and relevant to illustrate a point (in which case I'd suggest manga, anyway)Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
22:5922:59, 23 December 2017diffhist−6
Eid al-Fitr
I believe this is referring to Zakat al-Fitr, but please correct me if this is not so, as I do not have the background knowledge on this topic.
7 October 2017
15:4915:49, 7 October 2017diffhist+3
Kibō no Tō
Even English-language news coverage is primarily using the "Kibo no To" Romanization with an occasional parenthetical translation. If the party itself eventually designates an official English title, that may be a different matter...
16:3016:30, 10 May 2024diffhist+3
Jewish cemetery of Salonica
The word "finally" just seems disrespectful; it could be read with a similar nuance to "at last". Am I over thinking it? Open to better suggestions.currentTags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
05:2105:21, 25 May 2022diffhist−112
ApologetiX
→Band members: Unlinking. The few of these that actually had articles ended up being for different people entirely, and if the red links are left alone, it will keep happening.
1 April 2022
11:1411:14, 1 April 2022diffhist+992
Lifespring
→Criticism: Some of this, I can source, some more I can add from the article, but the rest (the death threat) I am removing since it is not in the article. If there is a separate (or more complete) interview where she actually says this, please share!
09:1409:14, 1 April 2022diffhist+167
Seiji Nishino
→Bibliography: The original Japanese version should be listed here (especially since it looks like we have a couple translated versions)Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
11:3911:39, 17 August 2021diffhist−63
Rising Sun Flag
Sorry for the delayed reply. Again, Fantastic Four is not a good example since this is not a Japanese comic and this should not be used to represent Japanese comics. A reader of this article would be very confused into thinking perhaps Fantastic Four were a Japanese franchise..
16:2416:24, 25 April 2020diffhist−316
Battle of Shiroyama
Undid revision 953024621 by Lack of Plethora - I appreciate that you tried to provide rationale for including them here, but I still believe Sabaton to just be trivia. Works included here should have wide cultural impact. Last Samurai would meet that bar, but
Last Samurai doesn't even mention Shiroyama so we don't have a source saying it was inspired by this battle. It would be more relevant in e.g.
Satsuma Rebellion or
Saigō Takamori instead of this battle specifically...Tag: Undo
18 January 2020
23:0023:00, 18 January 2020diffhist−160
High-speed rail
Agree this is not relevant to HSR. This is what happens when
WP:PROCON goes too far... the purpose of these articles isn't to let each side argue for and against, but to give an NPOV presentation of the topic as a whole. Really this whole section needs a rework.Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
22:4722:47, 18 January 2020diffhist+6
High-speed rail
Undid revision 933859825 by
VivaBlondie2000 (
talk) - Actually, we do need the D.C. It is normal for local route maps to add D.C. to Washington even though state abbreviations aren't added to NYC or Philly. This also removes ambiguity with Washington StateTags: UndoMobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
31 December 2019
23:3523:35, 31 December 2019diffhist−43
Battle of Shiroyama
Yeah... Last Samurai doesn't belong there either. In prose (not list format), this might merit a one line callout as something "inspired" by the battle (if a source says that...) but it is not a depiction of the actual battle. Without an explanation of its significance, this is not relevant and does not merit a list.Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
15:0215:02, 9 December 2019diffhist−61
Rising Sun Flag
→Present day use: I don't think Fantastic Four is a good example since this is not a Japanese comic. I accept that this could potentially be an example of *overseas* use, which is covered in a later section, however, Wikipedia is not a list, we don't necessarily need examples of every usage unless notable and relevant to illustrate a point (in which case I'd suggest manga, anyway)Tags: Mobile editMobile web editAdvanced mobile edit
22:5922:59, 23 December 2017diffhist−6
Eid al-Fitr
I believe this is referring to Zakat al-Fitr, but please correct me if this is not so, as I do not have the background knowledge on this topic.
7 October 2017
15:4915:49, 7 October 2017diffhist+3
Kibō no Tō
Even English-language news coverage is primarily using the "Kibo no To" Romanization with an occasional parenthetical translation. If the party itself eventually designates an official English title, that may be a different matter...