This article was no big loss and not worth going to DRV for but I just want to register here that this deletion was out of step with policy as generally implemented. WP:NBOOK says two reviews are enough and short reviews are routinely accepted as sufficient as long as they are independent and published in adequate sources. There is nothing wrong with either Publishers Review or Booklist and it is an unfortunate misconception that they cover "every book" or even every book by major publishers or major authors. Being treated on both PB and Booklist is a good sign of notability. Haukur ( talk) 21:19, 21 December 2019 (UTC)
This article was no big loss and not worth going to DRV for but I just want to register here that this deletion was out of step with policy as generally implemented. WP:NBOOK says two reviews are enough and short reviews are routinely accepted as sufficient as long as they are independent and published in adequate sources. There is nothing wrong with either Publishers Review or Booklist and it is an unfortunate misconception that they cover "every book" or even every book by major publishers or major authors. Being treated on both PB and Booklist is a good sign of notability. Haukur ( talk) 21:19, 21 December 2019 (UTC)