| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
| VandalProof categories |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:.NET Framework |
rename to
Category:.NET |
February 18
|
|
Category:12th-century Scottish Roman Catholic bishops |
no consensus |
February 24
|
|
Category:15th-century archaeologists |
merge to
Category:15th-century antiquarians,
Category:16th-century antiquarians, and
Category:17th-century antiquarians. Some of the articles may need to be moved to a "historians" category. |
February 21
|
|
Category:16th-century executions by Germany |
rename. Note that
Category:17th-century executions by Germany also exists. It was not nominated in this discussion |
February 10
|
|
Category:1990s platform video games |
delete |
February 7
|
|
Category:7th-century Gallo-Roman people |
Withdrawn by nominator
(non-admin closure) |
February 25
|
| AA2 OVERCAT |
delete |
February 25
|
|
Category:Abandoned amusement parks in the United States |
merge |
February 10
|
|
Category:Abbasid governors of the Jazira |
do not merge |
February 6
|
| Accidents and incidents by airline |
rename |
February 9
|
|
Category:Administrative territorial entities by language |
rename to
Category:Countries and territories by language for now. If we want to change it to some sort of official languages category, let's do that in a new nomination. |
February 10
|
|
Category:Adultery in films |
no consensus. The discussion was a bit muddled, with at least three different proposals being made. A more focused discussion on one of the proposals may result in a consensus |
February 16
|
|
Category:Africa women's national association football teams |
delete |
February 13
|
|
Category:Afsharid Empire |
rename |
February 12
|
|
Category:Airlines in Alaska |
rename to
Category:Airlines based in Alaska |
February 10
|
|
Category:Airlines of Rhodesia accidents and incidents |
merge |
February 9
|
| Al-Faisaly SC |
rename |
February 25
|
|
Category:Album chart usages for Canadian Albums |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Albums produced by The Neptunes |
rename |
February 25
|
|
Category:Albums recorded at Avatar Studios |
delete. — |
February 25
|
|
Category:Ambassadors of Canada to Taiwan |
keep. – |
February 24
|
|
Category:American academics whose Native American status is seriously disputed |
delete. The members (
Ward Churchill,
Andrea Smith (academic),
Elizabeth Warren) might perhaps be listed in a relevant article. – |
February 19
|
|
Category:American people of Arab-Jewish descent |
no consensus |
February 5
|
|
Category:American people of Lucanian descent |
merge |
February 12
|
|
Category:American people of Maronite descent |
merge |
February 2
|
| Ancient Roman buildings and structures in Britain |
rename/merge |
February 5
|
|
Category:Antiates |
delete, merging content to
Category:Valerii. |
February 23
|
|
Category:Aristocracy of Mantua |
merge |
February 1
|
|
Category:Armenians of Romania |
rename |
February 10
|
|
Category:Articles using E without any arguments |
rename (no consensus to delete) |
February 18
|
|
Category:Assizes |
listify and delete. – |
February 26
|
|
Category:ATSC-M/H stations |
delete |
February 18
|
|
Category:Australian law support structures |
upmerge |
February 2
|
|
Category:Australian Living Treasures |
delete |
February 5
|
|
Category:Australian Operational Service Medal |
delete |
February 1
|
|
Category:Australian rules footballers' wives and girlfriends |
delete. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:Aviation accidents and incidents involving historic warbirds |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Bangsamoro Special Geographic Area |
merge to
Category:Geography of Bangsamoro |
February 3
|
|
Category:Barcelona Metro line templates |
do not merge; populate instead |
February 5
|
| Basshunter music video categories |
delete |
February 4
|
|
Category:Battle of Uhud |
delete, upmerging subcategory as discussed |
February 8
|
|
Category:Bialik Prize recipients |
delete. — |
February 28
|
|
Category:Bishops by nationality |
merge/rename as a first step; there is agreement that further work/nominations will be required. Pinging
Rathfelder. |
February 28
|
|
Category:Bishops in Aosta Valley |
delete. (It can't be merged to
Category:Bishops of Aosta because
Category:Bishops of Aosta is the only content in the nominated category. You can't merge a category to itself.) |
February 23
|
|
Category:Bishops of Malawi |
merge |
February 26
|
|
Category:Bishops of Narok |
merge |
February 26
|
|
Category:Books about Buddhism in the Heian period |
withdrawn |
February 27
|
|
Category:Bor (Niğde) District |
rename. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:Bouloussou family of Yanam |
rename |
February 10
|
|
Category:Brian Greene |
Delete.
(non-admin closure) |
February 15
|
|
Category:British Asian |
rename |
February 12
|
| Broadcast station categories |
merge |
February 10
|
|
Category:Burials at II Alley of Honor in Baku |
delete |
February 2
|
|
Category:Burials at Saint Andrew's Cemetery, Bratislava |
delete |
February 6
|
|
Category:California Golden Seals broadcasters |
rename all to "TEAM announcers" based on the previous discussion. (Deletion was not proposed here.) A full list of changes made is at the base of this discussion. |
February 12
|
|
Category:Canadian Anglican Church in North America members |
merge. All that was left to merge was
Category:Canadian bishops of the Anglican Church in North America |
February 28
|
|
Category:Cardinals by country |
delete/merge |
February 13
|
|
Category:Cartoons animated with Adobe After Effects |
delete. I have moved the content to
Category:Computer-animated television series or
Category:Computer-animated films, as appropriate |
February 11
|
| Catfish the TV show hosts |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Catholic archbishops in the Republic of Ireland |
rename to
Category:Roman Catholic archbishops by archdiocese in Ireland |
February 20
|
|
Category:Characters in animated films |
merge both into a new
Category:Animated characters in film |
February 22
|
|
Category:Chechen national heroes |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Children of Catherine of Aragon |
delete |
February 2
|
|
Category:Church of England church buildings by city |
rename |
February 11
|
|
Category:Circus strongmen |
rename to
Category:Circus strongmen and strongwomen. As noted,
Category:Strongwomen exists; I have added the circus strongwomen in that category to
Category:Circus strongmen and strongwomen but also kept them in
Category:Strongwomen. Further tweaks may be appropriate. |
February 6
|
|
Category:City of Albany, Western Australia |
not renamed |
February 11
|
|
Category:Commanders of the Royal Order of the Two-Sicilies |
delete |
February 25
|
|
Category:Communist genocides |
delete |
February 12
|
|
Category:Congolese male mixed martial artists |
delete' |
February 2
|
|
Category:Contemporary history of the United States |
merge to
Category:Modern history of the United States. Everyone agrees that the nominated category is unsatisfactory. The tree is in a confused and seemingly arbitrary state. Merging to
Category:Modern history of the United States may be a temporary measure, pending other nominations |
February 4
|
| Countries and territories by language |
delete.
List of countries and territories where Afrikaans or Dutch are official languages moved to
Category:Countries and territories by language |
February 21
|
|
Category:Critics of the Russian Empire |
rename. – |
February 19
|
|
Category:Cyprus in the Roman era |
merge to
Category:Roman Cyprus.
(non-admin closure) |
February 1
|
|
Category:Czechoslovak musical groups |
keep |
February 7
|
|
Category:Dafina Zeqiri |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Dallas municipal elections |
do not merge |
February 21
|
|
Category:Deaths from the COVID-19 pandemic by city |
delete/merge. As mentioned, it can be difficult to assess categories like this mid-pandemic. Opinions may well change as we go forward, so we shouldn't be too harsh with restricting non-immediate re-creation of these categories, but they certainly should be discussed if re-created |
February 13
|
|
Category:Descendants of Neapolitan nobility |
merge, but to subcategories of the proposed target.
Joseph Pignatelli was placed in
Category:House of Pignatelli and
Antoniotto Botta Adorno was placed in
Category:Nobility from Naples. |
February 8
|
|
Category:Destroyed individual trees |
keep. – |
February 13
|
|
Category:Dial EV vehicles |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Digital-only albums |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Dinosaur films |
rename; no consensus to delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Dissolution of the Soviet Union armed conflicts |
merge, except those articles discussed that were not "post-Soviet". |
February 12
|
|
Category:Dizengoff Prize recipients |
delete |
February 14
|
|
Category:Dr. West's Medicine Show and Junk Band songs |
keep. Those in favour of keep have the guidelines on their side |
February 10
|
|
Category:DuMont News & DuMont Sports |
rename |
February 14
|
|
Category:Economics and Statistics Administration images |
delete and upmerge to
Category:United States Department of Commerce images |
February 3
|
|
Category:Edinburgh Festival Fringe media |
purge and merge as proposed |
February 11
|
|
Category:Elements Music Camp alumni |
delete |
February 2
|
| Empty American Samoa categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Aruba categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Bonaire categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Cook Islands categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Curaçao categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Guadeloupe categories |
delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Mayotte categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty New Caledonia categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Northern Mariana Islands categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Saba categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Saint Barthélemy categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Saint Pierre and Miquelon categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Sint Eustatius categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Sint Maarten categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Empty Wallis and Futuna categories |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
| Establishments in the Kingdom of Hungary |
merge, but redirects from the old names will be useful for future reference and for category navigation. – |
February 13
|
|
Category:Ethnic minorities in Egypt |
merge |
February 11
|
| Ethnic minorities |
merge. There was also some support for new "Diasporas in FOO" categories, into which the "Ethnic groups" categories could be merged. The "Ethnic groups" categories were not tagged for discussion, so this will require a follow-up nomination if users want to pursue the idea. |
February 12
|
|
Category:Eurovision Song Contest pranksters |
delete. — |
February 25
|
|
Category:Executive branch of the government of Republic of Artsakh |
rename to
Category:Executive branch of the government of the Republic of Artsakh (hoping to get it right this time). |
February 14
|
|
Category:Executive branch of the Singapore Government |
rename to
Category:Executive branch of the government of Singapore. — |
February 26
|
|
Category:Extinct insect families |
no consensus |
February 10
|
|
Category:Fellows of the Committee for Skeptical Inquiry |
delete |
February 23
|
|
Category:Fellows of the Soil Science Society of America |
delete |
February 8
|
|
Category:Festivali i Këngës presenters |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
February 25
|
|
Category:Fictional asteroids |
merge |
February 4
|
|
Category:Fictional comets |
merge to
Category:Fiction about comets.
(non-admin closure) |
February 4
|
|
Category:Fictional galaxies |
merge |
February 4
|
|
Category:Fictional regions of space |
merge |
February 12
|
|
Category:Fictional stars |
merge |
February 12
|
|
Category:Films directed by Fred Allen (editor) |
rename done. We'll count this as a
C2D speedy rename.
Good Olfactory 22:31, 11 February 2021 (UTC)
reply |
February 10
|
|
Category:Films made before the MPAA Production Code |
delete |
February 6
|
|
Category:Films scored by Aryan Ashik |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Foreign relations by administrative division |
rename |
February 12
|
|
Category:Former Countries of Afghanistan |
manual merge to
Category:Former countries in Central Asia and
Category:History of Afghanistan. I've posted at
WT:WPAF and
WP:CFDWM to hopefully have it carried out by someone familiar with the history of Afghanistan. If there are no responses there I will carefully carry it out my self.
(non-admin closure) |
February 15
|
|
Category:Former government ministers of Australia |
delete but merge contents to
Category:Government ministers of Australia |
February 19
|
|
Category:Franklin Dam |
delete |
February 11
|
|
Category:Freemen of the City of Gloucester |
delete |
February 4
|
|
Category:Freemen of Wolverhampton |
delete |
February 14
|
|
Category:FT-Class articles |
delete. I did as discussed |
February 13
|
|
Category:Gabbard family |
delete |
February 1
|
|
Category:Galician Literature Day |
delete |
February 7
|
|
Category:Generals of the Georgian Armed Forces ( 1991 - ) |
rename as nominated. This is a sub-cat of
Category:Generals from Georgia (country), so the suggestion at the end amounts to a merge, which has no support here. CFD participants would do well to look at a nominated category and its parents before commenting. – |
February 21
|
|
Category:German Jewish military personnel of World War I |
no consensus |
February 2
|
|
Category:Grand Crosses of the Order of Carol I |
delete |
February 13
|
|
Category:Groupe PSA |
not merged |
February 8
|
|
Category:Hectomillionaires |
delete |
February 21
|
| Hermitages |
rename |
February 14
|
|
Category:Heroes of the Republic of Cuba |
delete |
February 15
|
| History of the United States by period |
disperse |
February 21
|
|
Category:Hong Kong people of Fujianese descent |
delete |
February 7
|
|
Category:Hong Kong people of Lower Yangtze descent |
delete |
February 5
|
|
Category:Honorary graduates of the University of Exeter |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Honored in Garden of the Righteous in Warsaw |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:How-to |
merge. I have removed the articles (like
Screenwriting) which are not handbooks or manuals.
How-to looks like it will
be deleted. |
February 22
|
| IHG Hotels & Resorts |
keep |
February 6
|
|
Category:Illis Quorum recipients |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Immigration to the United Kingdom by country of origin |
no consensus |
February 12
|
|
Category:Impeachments of Donald Trump |
delete. I have merged the contents back to
Category:Impeached Presidents of the United States and
Category:Trump administration controversies; a user removed these categories from the nominated category while this discussion was ongoing |
February 8
|
|
Category:Invincible Overlord songs |
delete (
non-admin closure) |
February 28
|
| Iranian city councillors |
merge |
February 2
|
|
Category:ISIL terrorist incidents in Libya in 2015 |
dual merge as discussed |
February 1
|
|
Category:Jewish magicians |
delete |
February 24
|
| Jewish mathematicians |
delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Jewish women cinematographers |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:John B. Pickett fellows |
delete |
February 23
|
|
Category:Judges of the Tripura High Court |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
February 28
|
|
Category:Jumana Mattukat |
speedy delete per
C2F |
February 21
|
|
Category:Kalgoorlie-Boulder |
rename to
Category:City of Kalgoorlie–Boulder. There may be some
MOS:DASH issues but consensus seems to be that it's a discussion for another time |
February 9
|
|
Category:Khwarizmi International Award recipients |
delete |
February 25
|
| Kings of Anshan (Persia) |
merge |
February 5
|
|
Category:La bohème |
delete |
February 26
|
|
Category:Labels distributed by Universal Records |
delete |
February 13
|
|
Category:Labor unionists from Illinois (merge) |
merge |
February 26
|
| Late modern period |
rename. There seemed to be a slight preference for the "B" options where an alternate was included |
February 20
|
|
Category:Latinx to Category:Latino |
merge to
Category:Hispanic and Latino American artists. Creation of a new
Category:Hispanic and Latin-American artists could be done, but it would require a nomination of
Category:Hispanic and Latino American artists, which was not part of this nomination |
February 11
|
|
Category:Leaders in the Civilization series |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Linux audio podcasts |
merge |
February 27
|
|
Category:List of Grand Sultans of the Isaaq Sultanate |
rename |
February 18
|
|
Category:List of Institutions using Infosys Finacle |
delete |
February 26
|
|
Category:Lists of administrative territorial entities |
delete. The reasons for the emptying of the category was worked out in the discussion |
February 12
|
|
Category:Lists of astronomical locations in fiction |
do not rename |
February 6
|
|
Category:Lists of engines |
rename. I had to remove
List of aircraft engines, which goes in
Category:Lists of aircraft engines. |
February 25
|
|
Category:Living assistant bishops in the Church of England |
delete. — |
February 28
|
|
Category:Logothetai ton oikeiakont |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Logothetes ton oikeiakontes |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Logothetes tou genikon |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Lokomotiv Yaroslavl plane crash |
delete |
February 6
|
|
Category:LPMud gamedrivers |
delete |
February 24
|
|
Category:Madrilenian footballers |
rename. The other categories referred to were not included in this nomination |
February 20
|
|
Category:Male villains |
keep.
(non-admin closure) – |
February 26
|
|
Category:Manaus Futebol Clube managers |
do not rename |
February 13
|
|
Category:Mandalay Bay Events Center |
delete |
February 12
|
|
Category:Manuals and gazetteers of India |
rename |
February 22
|
|
Category:Masters sport competitors by sport |
merge to
Category:Senior sport competitors |
February 11
|
|
Category:Mayors of Berbera |
merge as nominated and to appropriate "People from FOO" categories |
February 10
|
|
Category:Mayors of Jever |
merge as nominated and to
Category:People from Jever |
February 10
|
| Mayors of places in Arizona |
merge |
February 5
|
| Mayors of places in Armenia |
merge |
February 7
|
| Mayors of places in Missouri |
merge |
February 1
|
|
Category:Medicine in Lithuania |
merge |
February 15
|
|
Category:Melodifestivalen presenters |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
February 22
|
|
Category:Members of Governing Council Of Indian Premier League |
rename |
February 3
|
|
Category:Members of the Legislative Assembly of Saskatchewan by term |
delete. – |
February 18
|
|
Category:Members of the Royal Red Cross and Bar |
merge |
February 22
|
|
Category:Members of the Women's Engineering Society |
delete.
Category:Women's Engineering Society was not nominated, but it too seems to be categorizing members, so a follow-up nomination would likely be appropriate here |
February 5
|
|
Category:Metropolitan Special Constabulary |
delete; users can work out the proper parentage of the subcategory
Category:Metropolitan Special Constabulary officers in the normal ways |
February 6
|
|
Category:MFA of Ukraine Spokesperson |
delete. – |
February 18
|
|
Category:Mikolas Josef |
delete |
February 24
|
|
Category:Mineral butters |
delete. (For future reference for a list or article, the contents of the category were
Antimony trichloride,
Arsenic trichloride,
Bismuth chloride,
Tin(IV) chloride, and
Zinc chloride.) |
February 23
|
| Miscellaneous X character redirects to lists |
|
February 22
|
|
Category:Mobsters |
rename (several of these were processed as merges in instances where the target category already existed) |
February 8
|
|
Category:Modern history of the United States |
delete, dispersing contents to
Category:20th century in the United States and
Category:21st century in the United States |
February 16
|
| Multiple Proposed renaming of Montana, Massachusetts, South Carolina, Wisconsin |
rename |
February 26
|
|
Category:Named military operations in World War II |
merge |
February 15
|
|
Category:Nannies in films |
rename. The !votes here were evenly split between "rename" and "delete", and there was no consensus on which of these was preferable. So this close is defaulting to "keep" (meaning "do not delete"), but "rename" since there were editors in favour of this and no one had an opinion that the proposed name was worse than the current name |
February 16
|
|
Category:National Heroes of Honduras |
delete for now. For the record, the current members are
José Trinidad Cabañas,
Dionisio de Herrera,
Lempira (Lenca ruler),
Francisco Morazán,
José Trinidad Reyes. The Wikidata item is
[1]. – |
February 22
|
|
Category:NBA G League players from Serbia |
delete |
February 14
|
|
Category:Nobility by nationality |
split
Category:Nobility by nationality to
Category:Nobility by country and
Category:Nobles by country. Rename
Category:Nobility by nationality and title to
Category:Nobles by country and title. (I'm not 100% clear on how to implement the split, but I will do it this way: I will have the bot rename
Category:Nobility by nationality to
Category:Nobility by country. Then,
Paul_012 can manually create
Category:Nobles by country and include in it what belongs there. A follow-up nomination may be needed as this may not leave things in an ideal state. |
February 11
|
|
Category:Noble titles of Andorra |
rename/merge/delete as nominated |
February 24
|
|
Category:Non-denominational Muslims |
delete |
February 11
|
|
Category:Northern California Public Broadcasting |
rename |
February 23
|
|
Category:One-thousanders |
there is some support for a future nomination.– |
February 4
|
|
Category:Order of Danica Hrvatska recipients |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Order of May |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Order of Naval Merit Admiral Padilla |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Order of Saint Elizabeth |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Order of Saint George and Reunion |
delete |
February 18
|
|
Category:Order of Stjepan Radić recipients |
delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Order of the Croatian Cross recipients |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Ortaköy District, Aksaray |
rename. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:P. LEAGUE+ |
rename |
February 7
|
| Parallel Britannia and United Kingdom trees |
rename/merge. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:People associated with networking industry |
no consensus to delete; rename to
Category:Computer networking people |
February 11
|
|
Category:People associated with the International Committee on Intellectual Cooperation |
delete. For those who wish to listify, a list of the category contents is found on the
talk page. |
February 7
|
|
Category:People associated with water |
delete |
February 15
|
| People by 4th level administrative divisions in Greece |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:People convicted of carrying a concealed weapon |
delete |
February 7
|
|
Category:People executed by Italy |
split to
Category:People executed by Italian states. – |
February 10
|
| People from Achaea |
merge, except not
Category:People from Kleitoria |
February 7
|
| People from Aetolia-Acarnania |
merge, except do not merge
Category:People from Astakos |
February 9
|
| People from Arcadia, Peloponnese |
option A. If there ever are more articles to place in
Category:People from Megalopoli, Greece, it could be re-created. (At the time of close, it contained three articles and
Category:Ancient Megalopolitans.) |
February 10
|
| People from Argolis |
merge |
February 12
|
| People from Arta (regional unit) |
merge |
February 12
|
| People from Cephalonia |
merge |
February 12
|
| People from Chalkidiki |
merge |
February 13
|
| People from Chania (regional unit) |
merge, except no consensus to merge
Category:People from Kissamos |
February 13
|
| People from Corinthia |
merge |
February 13
|
| People from Drama (regional unit) |
merge |
February 14
|
| People from East Attica |
merge |
February 14
|
| People from Elis |
merge, except no consensus to merge
Category:People from Andritsaina |
February 26
|
| People from Euboea (regional unit) |
merge. There were individual calls to keep certain of these, but none garnered a consensus |
February 14
|
| People from Evros (regional unit) |
merge |
February 15
|
| People from Evrytania |
merge |
February 15
|
| People from Florina (regional unit) |
merge to
Category:People from Florina (regional unit).
(non-admin closure) |
February 16
|
| People from Grevena (regional unit) |
merge |
February 26
|
| People from Heraklion (regional unit) |
merge |
February 17
|
| People from Imathia |
merge |
February 17
|
|
Category:People from Indiana in World War I |
merge |
February 18
|
| People from Ioannina (regional unit) |
merge, except: no consensus to merge
Category:People from Zagori. Therefore, merge
Category:People from East Zagori,
Category:People from Papingo, and
Category:People from Tymfi to
Category:People from Zagori rather than as proposed |
February 26
|
| People from Islands (regional unit) |
option B merge |
February 27
|
| People from Karditsa (regional unit) |
merge |
February 18
|
| People from Kastoria (regional unit) |
merge |
February 18
|
| People from Kavala (regional unit) |
merge |
February 18
|
| People from Kilkis (regional unit) |
merge |
February 19
|
| People from Kozani (regional unit) |
merge, but no consensus to merge
Category:People from Askio |
February 27
|
| People from Laconia |
merge, but no consensus to merge
Category:People from East Mani |
February 27
|
| People from Larissa (regional unit) |
merge |
February 19
|
| People from Lesbos |
merge |
February 19
|
| People from Magnesia (regional unit) |
merge. — |
February 28
|
|
Category:People from Martin, Michigan |
merge. Whether
William Mohr belongs in
Category:People from Allegan County, Michigan can be discussed on
Talk:William Mohr. It may become moot because the article is
nominated for deletion. |
February 11
|
| People from Messenia |
merge |
February 28
|
| People from Pella (regional unit) |
merge. — |
February 28
|
| People from Phthiotis |
merge to
Category:People from Phthiotis.
(non-admin closure) |
February 20
|
| People from Rethymno (regional unit) |
merge to
Category:People from Rethymno (regional unit).
WP:Smallcat
(non-admin closure) |
February 20
|
| People from Rhodope (regional unit) |
Merge all categories with less then 5 entries..
WP:SMALLCAT
(non-admin closure) |
February 20
|
|
Category:People from Saigon |
merge to
Category:People from Ho Chi Minh City |
February 11
|
|
Category:People from the Athens Urban Area |
merge/delete as nominated |
February 8
|
| People from Thessaloniki (regional unit) |
merge |
February 22
|
| People from Trikala (regional unit) |
merge |
February 23
|
|
Category:People in computing |
do not merge, but rename to
Category:People in the computer industry per
C2C |
February 11
|
|
Category:People of Ningbo descent |
delete |
February 5
|
| People of the Russian Empire |
rename. (Note: I was leaving this to be closed by someone else, since I had closed the previous one which was then disputed, but that hasn't happened after a month, and the consensus here is clear.) – |
February 20
|
| People of Zhejiang descent |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:People on postage stamps |
purge and rename |
February 12
|
|
Category:People positive to COVID-19 |
delete per
G4 (
original discussion) |
February 25
|
| People who have or had an infectious disease that didn't kill them, at least not yet |
delete, except no consensus to delete
Category:Ebola survivors |
February 6
|
|
Category:People with cancer |
delete. The three subcategories (
Category:Deaths from cancer,
Category:People with multiple myeloma, and
Category:Cancer survivors) were moved to
Category:Cancer. |
February 8
|
|
Category:People with dementia |
containerize. Remove the bio articles and keep the subcategories (
Category:People with Alzheimer's disease,
Category:Deaths from dementia,
Category:Fictional characters with dementia, and
Category:Sportspeople with chronic traumatic encephalopathy) in it. Tag with
Template:Container category |
February 10
|
|
Category:People with type 2 diabetes |
delete |
February 12
|
|
Category:Period action films |
no consensus. I suggest that this might be revisited after closure of the above CFD re period television series. If anyone wants to pursue reverse merge, the whole hierarchy of historical films by genre should be put up for renaming. – |
February 25
|
|
Category:Period films |
merge contents to appropriate subcategories of
Category:Historical films. Note that there is also
Category:Period pieces,
Category:Period horror films,
Category:Period action films, and
Category:Period television series, all of which were not nominated in this discussion. |
February 14
|
|
Category:Period horror films |
no consensus (as Carlossuarez46 also opposes the proposed merge). I suggest that this might be revisited after closure of the above CFD re period television series. – |
February 25
|
|
Category:Perpetual travellers |
delete. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:Physician-politicians |
delete. — |
February 4
|
|
Category:Place names of German origin in Romania |
delete |
February 12
|
|
Category:Places named after Slave Owners |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Plantain-eaters |
merge; also overwrite history |
February 13
|
|
Category:Pokémon video game screenshots |
rename |
February 22
|
|
Category:Pop-folk albums |
split. There was no real discussion despite efforts to re-list. I am not competent to split this, so it will be added to
WP:CFDWM. |
February 5
|
|
Category:Pope Pius XII appointments |
delete |
February 14
|
|
Category:Practical aesthetics actors |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Primates of the Anglican Church of Ireland |
merge to
Category:Primates in the Anglican Communion (see also discussion
immediately above) |
February 20
|
|
Category:Primates of the Anglican Communion |
rename |
February 20
|
|
Category:Private islands |
merge all |
February 12
|
|
Category:Professional wrestling jobbers to the stars |
delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Prokaryotes taxonomy |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
February 28
|
|
Category:PSA Group people |
not renamed |
February 8
|
|
Category:PSA Group templates |
rename |
February 8
|
|
Category:PSA Group timeline templates |
rename |
February 8
|
|
Category:Radio programs by station |
merge |
February 24
|
|
Category:Rail stations in Taiwan by system |
rename to
Category:Rail stations in Taiwan by operator |
February 4
|
|
Category:Rattachists |
delete |
February 2
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Banner of Gold |
delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Blood Order |
listify, then delete |
February 8
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Creu de Sant Jordi |
delete |
February 26
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Egypt Medal |
delete |
February 5
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Humane Order of African Redemption |
delete |
February 16
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Infosys Prize |
delete |
February 26
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Medal of the Crown of King Zvonimir |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Military Karl-Friedrich Merit Order |
delete. — |
February 28
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Neshan-e Aqdas |
delete |
February 17
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Brilliant Jade |
delete |
February 16
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Construction |
delete |
February 15
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Henry the Lion |
delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Mehr |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Merit of the Bahamas |
delete |
February 24
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of Military Merit (Dominican Republic) |
delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Double Dragon |
delete |
February 1
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Republic (Serbia) |
delete |
February 24
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the White Falcon |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Order of the Zahringer Lion |
delete |
February 26
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Sniper's Badge |
merge |
February 5
|
|
Category:Recipients of the Supreme Order of the Renaissance |
delete |
February 18
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic archbishops of Bologna |
rough consensus is to keep
Category:Roman Catholic archbishops of Bologna and not rename |
February 15
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic dioceses in Aosta Valley |
no consensus |
February 23
|
|
Category:Romani minorities |
rename. (The nomination was stated to be a "merge" proposal, but the target did not exist until it was created by this close.) |
February 11
|
|
Category:Rotorua District |
rename |
February 24
|
|
Category:Russian Empire agnostics |
rename per the strong consensus here. – |
February 14
|
|
Category:Russian Empire people of Moldovan descent |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Sanai Researchers from Iran |
merge. I have also made a list at
Sanai#See_also. – |
February 18
|
|
Category:Saturn Award for Best Film winners |
delete |
February 17
|
| Scheduled monument categories |
rename. The fact that the article
Scheduled monument does not capitalize is near determinative here. |
February 12
|
| Schools in Sri Lanka by city |
merge |
February 6
|
|
Category:Scottish emigrants to England |
delete |
February 5
|
| Sects in the Latter Day Saint movement |
rename. Merger proposals may be presented separately. – |
February 14
|
|
Category:SGpedians' notice board members |
merge |
February 19
|
| Shanghainese emigrants to Hong Kong |
merge |
February 11
|
|
Category:Similarity and distance measures |
rename. This seems to be about all the discussion we are going to squeeze out of this. The distance measures have been upmerged to
Category:Distance. |
February 10
|
|
Category:Sleepy Wikipedians |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Slovak Catholic bishops |
merge |
February 14
|
|
Category:Sokolov Prize recipients |
delete |
February 4
|
|
Category:Song recordings produced by The KLF |
rename' |
February 6
|
|
Category:Songs about elves |
delete |
February 7
|
|
Category:Songs written by Rafe VanHoy |
rename |
February 22
|
|
Category:South Australian Railways locomotives 1–3 |
delete |
February 19
|
| Spanish municipal councillors |
merge |
February 6
|
|
Category:Spirituals |
merge |
February 28
|
|
Category:Sports events by sport type |
split between
Category:Sports competitions by sport and a new
Category:Sports disciplines by sport. This could use a second pair of eyes to ensure that the split was done properly |
February 11
|
|
Category:Sportspeople from Pilot Butte, Saskatchewan |
merge to
Category:Sportspeople from Saskatchewan |
February 15
|
|
Category:Spotify listeners |
delete |
February 2
|
|
Category:Stanley family (NZ rugby) |
rename (
non-admin closure) |
February 19
|
|
Category:Stinc Team Members |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Streaming-only albums |
delete |
February 18
|
|
Category:Stroke survivors |
delete. — |
February 27
|
|
Category:Subdivisions of the United Kingdom |
rename five from "subdivisions" to "administrative divisions"; no consensus on
Category:United Kingdom by country. – |
February 6
|
|
Category:Summits of the Laurentians (administrative region) |
delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Svenska Hollywoodfruar cast members |
Delete.
(non-admin closure) |
February 22
|
|
Category:Swaminarayan sect of Hinduism |
rename. There is no consensus which title is preferable,
Category:Swaminarayan Hinduism or
Category:Swaminarayan Sampradaya, however there is a clear consensus that both are better than the status quo. I've chosen to rename to
Category:Swaminarayan Sampradaya for consistency with the article with both having the same amount of support. I would suggest that the next step be an RM for the article. If the page is moved it is clear that the scale would tip in favor of Swaminarayan Hinduism with several people citing consistency as the reason for their preference. Another CfD is not necessary to move this category in that case.
(non-admin closure) |
February 19
|
|
Category:Syria in the Roman era |
merge.
(non-admin closure) |
February 1
|
|
Category:Technology demonstration satellite |
rename |
February 23
|
| Television shows based on comics |
no consensus. (Also, categories were not tagged with
Template:Cfr.) |
February 9
|
| Temples (LDS Church) in England and Germany |
Merge.
(non-admin closure) |
February 17
|
|
Category:Temples (LDS Church) in Italy |
merge to
Category:Temples in Italy.
(non-admin closure) |
February 16
|
|
Category:The CW cable-only affiliates |
merge |
February 19
|
|
Category:Timeline of the War in Iraq (2013–2017) |
rename |
February 4
|
|
Category:Titles of nobility by nationality |
rename |
February 24
|
|
Category:Topics in fiction by work |
rename |
February 19
|
|
Category:Topics in science fiction |
merge. Ah, Stefanomione. |
February 23
|
|
Category:Transport in Karditsa |
merge |
February 26
|
|
Category:Tree programming languages |
merge to
Category:Programming languages |
February 22
|
|
Category:Tweenies characters |
delete |
February 11
|
|
Category:TWiT.tv podcasts |
merge |
February 27
|
|
Category:Typographers |
rename. – |
February 21
|
|
Category:Ugandan Anglican bishops |
no consensus, but in light of
this CFD, consensus may change on this quickly, so a renomination should be allowed without any particular waiting time. |
February 24
|
| Underpopulated Stub Categories |
delete those with fewer than 30 articles in it. I have upmerged the contents of the deleted ones to the appropriate parent categories (usually "FOOian football biography stubs" and "CONTINENT women's football biography stubs") |
February 7
|
|
Category:United States Army Air Service pilots of World War I |
do not rename. There was support for creating
Category:United States Army Air Service personnel of World War I as a parent category. I won't do that as part of this close, but it can be done by any editor. |
February 7
|
|
Category:Unity (game engine) games |
delete. This was relisted a couple of times in an effort to get a stronger consensus, but we had no takers. With what we have, there is a rough consensus to delete. Perhaps the other related categories could be nominated to overcome the procedural arguments that were made in favour of retention |
February 4
|
|
Category:Universities and colleges in Historical Germany |
merge. There is clear consensus to get rid of the present category. There is also some support for having another category, and
Category:Universities and colleges in the German Empire would be similar to others, so this close is no bar to creating that or something like it. – |
February 13
|
|
Category:Universities and colleges |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
February 20
|
|
Category:University of Florida University of Florida College of Liberal Arts and Sciences alumni |
G7 delete |
February 15
|
|
Category:University of Zagreb faculty |
no consensus, except that an RfC on
Category:Faculty by university or college would be a good idea. I apologise for not replying when I was pinged below, but agree with the recommendations made by |
February 8
|
|
Category:Urdu encyclopedias |
rename |
February 14
|
| Vehicle categories containing only redirects |
delete all |
February 10
|
| Vehicle categories with only one article and redirects |
Manually delete. During discussion, some have been converted from redirect to article and back to redirect. Each will be manually checked for membership in the parent categories
Category:Cars of China and
Category:Vehicles by brand.
(non-admin closure) |
February 21
|
|
Category:Victims of domestic abuse |
delete |
February 10
|
| Warfare of the Industrial era |
rename |
February 20
|
|
Category:Washington Huskies football broadcasters |
Dual merge to parent categories.
(non-admin closure) |
February 15
|
|
Category:Welsh Christian ministers |
merge |
February 28
|
|
Category:Welsh clergy |
Withdrawn by nominator
(non-admin closure) |
February 25
|
|
Category:Welsh-speaking academics |
no consensus |
February 27
|
|
Category:Welsh-speaking politicians |
no consensus |
February 25
|
| West Indies Power |
merge/delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Wheeled motor vehicles |
merge |
February 23
|
|
Category:Wikidata autopatrollers |
delete |
February 11
|
|
Category:Wikipedia abuse response volunteers |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedia backlog cleaners |
delete |
February 27
|
|
Category:Wikipedia categories named after subdivisions of the United Kingdom |
No Consensus to delete. That said, there doesn't seem like much of a strong policy-related arguement to keep these either. So no prejudice against a follow-up nom, which takes the concerns in this discussion in consideration. - |
February 10
|
|
Category:Wikipedia categories named after subdivisions of the United States |
delete |
February 3
|
|
Category:Wikipedia Connection members |
merge |
February 27
|
|
Category:Wikipedian WikiElves |
merge |
February 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedian WikiPrairie Dogs |
delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Wikipedian WikiPrincesses |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedians by regional Wikipedian notice board |
merge |
February 21
|
|
Category:Wikipedians in the Featured Article Drive |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Wikipedians interested in Jacksonville Jaguars |
rename |
February 25
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who contribute to the Article Incubator |
delete |
February 21
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who had Toolserver accounts |
delete |
February 11
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who participate in Mathematics Collaboration of the Month |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who participate in Science Collaboration of the Month |
delete |
February 27
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who participate in Spanish Translation of the Week |
delete |
February 27
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who spend way too much time editing Wikipedia |
delete |
February 9
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who use Flow on Metawiki |
delete |
February 10
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who use igloo |
delete |
February 19
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who use LibreOffice |
delete |
February 12
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who use NPWatcher |
delete |
February 20
|
|
Category:Wikipedians who use the Yahoo! Widget Engine |
delete |
February 23
|
|
Category:Wikipedians willing to provide fourth opinions |
delete |
February 27
|
|
Category:Wikipedians with Labs accounts |
rename |
February 12
|
|
Category:WikiProject Law, Sport, And Science |
delete |
February 4
|
|
Category:Women in the The Troubles (Northern Ireland) |
delete |
February 15
|
|
Category:Women's Engineering Society |
no consensus. Side point: The category is categorizing bio articles, so it should probably be renamed to something like
Category:Women's Engineering Society members, but I'm not doing that with this close. |
February 18
|
|
Category:WOR radio programs |
delete |
February 24
|
|
Category:Works based on Street Fighter |
no consensus. As noted, per the guideline
WP:RELIST, discussions should generally only be relisted twice. A relist should also not be used in place of a "no consensus" result. It was my mistake to relist it a third time, so I am closing it. |
February 18
|
|
Category:Works set in fictional galaxies |
delete |
February 4
|
|
Category:Works set on fictional planets |
no consensus |
February 4
|
|
Category:WWE 24/7 Champions |
keep.
(non-admin closure) |
February 16
|
| X in in Y soft categories |
speedy delete
WP:G6. – |
February 15
|
|
Category:Zero thermal expansion materials |
rename |
February 4
|
|
Category:Zionist Women |
manual upmerge to
Category:Zionists,
Category:Women activists and
Category:Jewish women as appropriate. – |
February 28
|
|
Category:Zvane Črnja Award winners |
delete |
February 7
|