| Category |
Decision |
Discussion_log
|
|
Category:1820 Michigan elections |
rename.
(non-admin closure) |
October 17
|
|
Category:1861 in Montgomery, Alabama |
merge to
Category:Montgomery, Alabama in the American Civil War. No opposition.
(non-admin closure) |
October 4
|
|
Category:1930s color films |
keep |
October 27
|
|
Category:1st convocation of the Sukhumi City Council |
merge |
October 10
|
|
Category:2015 Memorial of Hubert Jerzy Wagner |
delete |
October 31
|
| [[:Category::Category:Jains of the Middle Ages]] |
delete |
October 10
|
|
Category:AAA Championships champions navigational boxes |
rename |
October 10
|
|
Category:Ada (plant) |
delete |
October 12
|
|
Category:Adult websites |
merge manually |
October 26
|
|
Category:Airline accidents and incidents designated as Flight 191 |
speedy delete
WP:G7. – |
October 8
|
|
Category:Alienation |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
October 13
|
|
Category:All vital articles |
delete |
October 6
|
|
Category:Alumni of Reimann School |
convert to disambiguation page |
October 15
|
|
Category:American Jews by national origin |
merge |
October 14
|
|
Category:American Jews of Latin European descent |
merge |
October 4
|
|
Category:American military personnel of North American descent |
merge |
October 27
|
|
Category:American people who self-identify as being of Native American descent |
Withdrawn. Withdrawn—I was not aware of the CfD; for some reason it was not findable from the history of the relevant categories.
(non-admin closure) |
October 29
|
|
Category:Amtrak railway line navigational boxes |
rename |
October 1
|
|
Category:Anime and manga portals |
merge to parents |
October 30
|
|
Category:Antetokounmpo brothers |
delete |
October 6
|
|
Category:Arab poets by nationality |
merge |
October 9
|
|
Category:Articles by type of contributor |
delete |
October 31
|
|
Category:Artificial uterus in fiction |
delete. I'll list this on the manual page for possible inclusion in a list |
October 6
|
| Autobots and Decepticons |
keep.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 28
|
|
Category:Bad Seed Ltd. albums |
rename |
October 6
|
|
Category:Baseball portals |
merge |
October 27
|
|
Category:Black Widow films |
merge to
Category:Black Widow (Marvel Comics),
Category:Films based on Marvel Comics and
Category:Films based on works by Stan Lee. – |
October 21
|
|
Category:Bombaj Štampa |
delete |
October 14
|
|
Category:British Speedway Championship champions |
rename |
October 10
|
|
Category:British urology surgeons |
merge |
October 31
|
|
Category:Buddhist communities of Thailand |
delete |
October 2
|
|
Category:Buddhist philosophers |
merge |
October 25
|
|
Category:Buddhist World Heritage Sites |
delete. I'll list these on the
manual page in case someone wants to create a list |
October 15
|
|
Category:Cam girls |
rename |
October 12
|
|
Category:Canadian Jews of Mizrahi Jewish descent |
delete |
October 27
|
|
Category:Canadian subsidiaries of foreign companies |
situation resolved. Since
Category:Schedule II banks in Canada has been upmerged this discussion is now unnecessary. Removing individual items as not defining is as usual possible on a per article basis without going through CfD.
(non-admin closure) |
October 27
|
|
Category:Candidates for speedy deletion as unused redundant templates |
rename.
(non-admin closure) |
October 14
|
|
Category:Carpooling services |
merge, also to
Category:Carsharing |
October 12
|
|
Category:CCI templates |
speedy(ish) rename. – |
October 12
|
|
Category:Christianity and Paganism |
merge. @ |
October 20
|
|
Category:CIS Men's Basketball Championship |
merge |
October 13
|
|
Category:Collegiate sports portals |
merge |
October 27
|
| Combiners (Transformers) |
merge |
October 6
|
|
Category:Combiners (Transformers) |
listify |
October 13
|
|
Category:Comedy science fiction films |
rename |
October 18
|
|
Category:Communist websites |
merge |
October 30
|
|
Category:Companies of the United States by location by type |
rename to
Category:Companies of the United States by industry and location |
October 11
|
|
Category:Country location map templates |
Rename. I've also gone ahead and tagged them as container categories and diffused the remaining enteries.
(non-admin closure) |
October 1
|
|
Category:Credit union case law in Canada |
merge.
(non-admin closure) |
October 16
|
|
Category:Credit union centrals of Canada |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
October 16
|
|
Category:Credit unions of Alberta |
merge, also to
Category:Companies based in Alberta |
October 16
|
|
Category:Credit unions of Manitoba |
merge, also to
Category:Companies based in Manitoba |
October 16
|
|
Category:Criminal comedy |
rename |
October 26
|
|
Category:Daughters (band) EPs |
merge |
October 19
|
|
Category:Defunct Internet companies |
merge (equivalent to rename) |
October 6
|
|
Category:Dinobots |
delete |
October 24
|
|
Category:Discovery system |
delete |
October 22
|
|
Category:Distance education in Bangladesh |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 18
|
|
Category:Distance education in Brazil |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 18
|
|
Category:Distance education in Canada |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 19
|
|
Category:Distance education in Cyprus |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 19
|
|
Category:Distance education in France |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 18
|
|
Category:Distance education in India |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 19
|
|
Category:Distance education in Nicaragua |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 19
|
|
Category:Distance education in the Philippines |
no action taken, discussion deferred to the bundled nomination below |
October 19
|
| Distance education |
merge/rename as indicated except where withdrawn |
October 20
|
|
Category:DJ Magazine |
delete |
October 10
|
|
Category:Dracula in film |
delete |
October 27
|
|
Category:Educational video websites |
merge to
Category:Educational websites. Even if considering the blocked socks contributions, the arguments to merge are better supported by policy.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 19
|
|
Category:Elections websites |
merge the remaining member
Psephos into Elections. – |
October 30
|
|
Category:Emperors of Destruction |
delete |
October 20
|
|
Category:English-language podcasts |
delete |
October 19
|
|
Category:English-language websites |
no consensus |
October 6
|
|
Category:Ethnic Chinese in Indonesia |
merge |
October 3
|
|
Category:Ethnic groups in the Arab League |
rename as nominated |
October 27
|
| Ethnic groups of partial ancestry |
delete |
October 8
|
|
Category:Faculty by university in Europe |
rename |
October 4
|
|
Category:Federal credit unions of Canada |
merge.
(non-admin closure) |
October 16
|
|
Category:Fictional characters from Cairo |
merge |
October 24
|
|
Category:Fictional Egyptian people by occupation |
merge |
October 23
|
|
Category:Fictional scorpions |
Merge to parent categories.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 28
|
|
Category:Fictional ship captains |
split.
(non-admin closure) |
October 17
|
|
Category:Fiscal agents |
merge |
October 25
|
|
Category:Fishing companies in Australia |
merge |
October 4
|
|
Category:Follow for Now albums |
keep. Discussions about the entire tree are best discussed at
Wikipedia talk:WikiProject Music if changing the overall structure is desired, it is however clear that right now there's a consensus to keep the category.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 29
|
|
Category:Fox Channel |
no consensus |
October 18
|
|
Category:Foxing (band) songs |
delete |
October 21
|
|
Category:Gaelic poets |
delete |
October 13
|
|
Category:Gannett (company) |
rename |
October 13
|
|
Category:Geographical Indications in Kongu Nadu |
merge |
October 19
|
|
Category:Germanic diaspora |
delete |
October 25
|
|
Category:Go-Bots |
delete |
October 11
|
|
Category:Greater Croatian ideology |
Rename as proposed. While I usually wouldn't be comfortable closing a discussion with two plausible alternatives with little discussion of the second, but since it has been a relist and 20 days without any discussion I don't believe keeping this open will do any good. I'm consequently closing in favor of the original proposal for which there is consensus is preferable to the status quo. There is no consensus with regards to the Greater Croatia (ideology) alternative and no predjudice against starting a new discussion on this topic.
(non-admin closure) |
October 4
|
| Greek Catholic Churches |
rename |
October 27
|
|
Category:Greyhawk magical items |
merge |
October 16
|
|
Category:Guangdong Southern Tigers F.C. managers |
speedy rename |
October 31
|
|
Category:Health blogs |
merge |
October 24
|
|
Category:High tech recruitment companies |
delete |
October 24
|
|
Category:Hispanic and Latino winners of beauty pageants |
delete |
October 9
|
|
Category:Hispanic pornographic film actors |
delete |
October 9
|
|
Category:Hispanic theologians |
delete |
October 9
|
|
Category:Holy orders in the Catholic Church |
rename/merge |
October 2
|
|
Category:Humor websites |
merge manually to the target or its subcategories if appropriate |
October 7
|
|
Category:Image hosting |
rename |
October 8
|
|
Category:Indian comedy science fiction films |
rename |
October 29
|
|
Category:Indian government districts in British Columbia |
no consensus. The main debate here is whether
Category:Indian government districts in British Columbia is part of a large overall accepted sub-categorization scheme . This question wasn't settled making both sides about equally backed by policy as well as a close !vote count leading to no consensus. If this is to be renominated I would recommend considering
Category:Indigenous municipalities in Canada from the start and settle factual disputes about relationships between municipalities, Indian government districts and First Nation governments using sources.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 12
|
|
Category:Informer (newspaper) |
delete |
October 27
|
|
Category:Insecticons |
merge |
October 6
|
|
Category:Interdisciplinary websites |
delete. For the record, the only member was
Figure/Ground |
October 29
|
|
Category:Internet companies of Finland |
merge to
Category:Companies of Finland by industry |
October 5
|
|
Category:Internet companies of Israel |
merge |
October 25
|
|
Category:Internet companies of Malaysia |
merge |
October 25
|
|
Category:Internet companies of Mexico |
merge to
Category:Companies of Mexico by industry |
October 5
|
|
Category:Internet companies of Norway |
delete |
October 12
|
|
Category:Inuit community governments in Quebec |
procedural close. Meanwhile the category has already been deleted. (
non-admin closure) |
October 7
|
|
Category:Irish collaborators with the British Empire |
delete.
Wikipedia:Categories for discussion/Log/2019 October 29#Category:Collaboration with the British Empire was closed as delete |
October 27
|
|
Category:Irish Gaelic poets |
rename |
October 2
|
|
Category:Irish-related place names in England |
delete. I'll list this on the manual page if someone wants to create a verifiable list |
October 29
|
|
Category:Isotope content page |
Populate through Infobox isotope. There was a lot of discussion, but in the end it seems there is a quite strong consensus to populate the category through the infobox. If there are any more concerns please take it to the relevant talk page.
(non-admin closure) |
October 9
|
|
Category:Japan Air Lines accidents and incidents |
DELETE as duplicate category. ... |
October 14
|
|
Category:Jewish pornographers |
delete |
October 5
|
|
Category:Judaism and atheism |
delete |
October 29
|
|
Category:Kingdom of Denmark |
do not merge |
October 10
|
|
Category:Language-oriented digital libraries |
delete |
October 24
|
|
Category:Laotian cuisine |
rename |
October 5
|
|
Category:LGBT horror film directors |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
October 17
|
|
Category:LGBT people by ethnicity |
delete |
October 29
|
|
Category:LGBT people of Puerto Rican descent |
merge to parents |
October 4
|
|
Category:LGBTQ fraternities and sororities |
rename |
October 31
|
|
Category:Library websites |
disperse, then delete |
October 26
|
|
Category:Link Light Rail stations |
rename.
Category:Future Link Light Rail stations is renamed to
Category:Future Link light rail stations |
October 3
|
|
Category:Literary techniques |
merge |
October 22
|
|
Category:Lords Lyon King of Arms |
rename |
October 18
|
|
Category:Martial arts portals |
merge |
October 27
|
|
Category:Mass murders |
do not merge |
October 21
|
|
Category:Maximals (Transformers) |
rename |
October 7
|
|
Category:Mayors of Kelowna |
merge |
October 18
|
|
Category:Medical Councils |
merge |
October 31
|
| Members of the Congress of Deputies |
rename according to Place Clichy's proposal |
October 11
|
|
Category:Meridian Secondary School |
delete |
October 25
|
|
Category:Methodist church buildings |
merge per option A |
October 20
|
|
Category:Minhagim |
Withdrawn after it was removed from a few previous subcategories. Other issues, like renaming and category tree structure were also addressed to satisfaction of the nominator. Involved, non-admin closure, in view of consensus and withdrawal of this nomination. |
October 25
|
|
Category:Mockumentary web series |
merge, also to
Category:Mockumentaries |
October 12
|
|
Category:Moloch |
delete |
October 31
|
| Museum stubs |
rename |
October 18
|
|
Category:Music by country |
nomination withdrawn |
October 10
|
|
Category:Musicians from Queens, New York City |
rename |
October 10
|
|
Category:Muslim members of the Parliament of the Netherlands |
delete |
October 7
|
|
Category:National Association for the Advancement of Colored People activists |
rename |
October 22
|
|
Category:National Association for the Advancement of Colored People |
rename |
October 22
|
|
Category:National Lacrosse League Champion's Cup championship seasons |
rename |
October 25
|
|
Category:Nautical captains by watercraft type |
upmerge.
(non-admin closure) |
October 16
|
|
Category:Nautical captains |
rename.
(non-admin closure) |
October 16
|
|
Category:Ocadia |
delete |
October 11
|
| OKC Energy U23 players/Oklahoma City Energy U23 players |
delete. I will list this on the manual page to verify the recategorization |
October 25
|
|
Category:Online catalogues |
delete |
October 25
|
|
Category:Online education |
merge as nominated |
October 6
|
|
Category:Online retailers of England |
merge, also to
Category:Retail companies of England |
October 18
|
|
Category:Online schools in Wisconsin |
merge |
October 20
|
|
Category:Online service providers |
delete manually |
October 14
|
|
Category:Open marriage |
speedy merge |
October 28
|
|
Category:Pages containing click using deprecated parameters |
no action taken (out of scope for CFD) |
October 27
|
|
Category:Parodies of Donald Trump in South Park |
keep |
October 2
|
|
Category:People from Mukacheve |
rename |
October 10
|
|
Category:People from Pietersburg |
rename |
October 10
|
|
Category:Photo sharing |
merge to
Category:Image sharing websites |
October 7
|
|
Category:Podcasts by language |
delete.
Category:Russian-language podcasts and
Category:English-language podcasts (the surrounding nominations and the only content of this category) were both deleted |
October 19
|
|
Category:Polara albums |
Renamed.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 29
|
|
Category:Political theorists |
merge/rename as nominated |
October 17
|
|
Category:Primitives (Transformers) |
delete |
October 8
|
|
Category:Princes of Asturias |
keep |
October 8
|
|
Category:Professional lawn mowers |
delete |
October 12
|
|
Category:Professional wrestling navigational boxes named after people |
rename per first choice |
October 20
|
|
Category:Propaganda websites |
delete |
October 30
|
|
Category:Protestant holiness denominations |
merge as nominated |
October 9
|
|
Category:Queer anarchism |
rename as nominated |
October 23
|
|
Category:Queer erasure |
rename as nominated |
October 23
|
|
Category:Queer studies |
rename |
October 27
|
|
Category:R.E. Mouscron players |
do not merge |
October 13
|
|
Category:Radio terminology |
merge |
October 23
|
|
Category:Recipients of aid from Lewis Tappan |
delete. I will place this category on the manual page to allow someone to create a list |
October 7
|
|
Category:Religious skeptics by ethnicity |
delete |
October 27
|
|
Category:Rescue Me characters |
delete |
October 20
|
|
Category:Roman Catholic church buildings in Australia |
rename |
October 27
|
| Roman Catholic churches by continent |
option b.
(non-admin closure) |
October 15
|
|
Category:Romaniote Judaism |
merge.
(non-admin closure) |
October 17
|
|
Category:Russian-language podcasts |
delete |
October 19
|
|
Category:Saint Ann's School (New York City) alumni |
rename |
October 11
|
|
Category:Santa Trackers |
merge |
October 5
|
|
Category:Schedule II banks in Canada |
Double upmerge to
Category:Banks of Canada and
Category:Canadian subsidiaries of foreign companies.
(non-admin closure) |
October 11
|
|
Category:Seekers (Transformers) |
merge to parents |
October 25
|
|
Category:Slag |
delete |
October 2
|
|
Category:Soca and calypso radio stations |
Rename. Reasonable request with no opposition for over a month. No predjudice against further rename discussions.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 25
|
|
Category:Social care in England |
nomination withdrawn |
October 12
|
|
Category:Spacecraft by launch system |
keep |
October 27
|
|
Category:Specific models |
rename per the alternative proposal |
October 13
|
|
Category:Speculative fiction websites & portals |
Rename to
Category:Speculative fiction websites. There's a clear consenus for renaming and a rough consensus against merging.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 29
|
|
Category:Sport à Chrudim |
Speedy delete. No need to use French on the English Wikipedia. Category is already empty |
October 6
|
|
Category:Spouses of United States Cabinet members |
delete |
October 11
|
|
Category:Spouses of United States senators |
delete |
October 19
|
|
Category:Tatort (film) |
rename |
October 26
|
| Template:Android-stub |
delete with manual replacement |
October 12
|
| Template:Korea-museum-stub |
delete |
October 7
|
| Template:Nbl-stub |
delete |
October 20
|
|
Category:Tencent Music |
do not merge |
October 5
|
|
Category:Thai Buddhist monarchs |
delete |
October 4
|
|
Category:The Pink Panther characters |
merge. with
Category:The Pink Panther (cartoons) characters. There is a consensus for the alternative merger with
Category:The Pink Panther (cartoons) characters, but currently no consensus with regards to the original proposal of merging with
Category:The Pink Panther. If someone want further mergers to be performed please start another CfD.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 20
|
|
Category:Trans-exclusionary radical feminism |
do not rename |
October 31
|
|
Category:Transylvanian sculptors |
delete |
October 11
|
|
Category:Triple Changers |
keep.
(non-admin closure) ‑‑ |
October 28
|
|
Category:Turkish Neoclassical architecture |
merge |
October 11
|
|
Category:Turtle articles needing attention |
withdrawn. – |
October 15
|
|
Category:United Kingdom–France proxy conflict |
delete |
October 15
|
|
Category:United States–Russia proxy conflict |
delete |
October 15
|
|
Category:Universities and colleges affiliated with the Sathya Sai Organization |
delete. For the record and if someone wants to merge, the only member was
Sri Sathya Sai Institute of Higher Learning |
October 27
|
|
Category:Valis series |
rename |
October 7
|
|
Category:Wikipedia categories named after districts of London |
rename |
October 22
|
|
Category:Wikipedia pages under 30-500 editing restriction |
rename |
October 6
|
| Wikipedians contributing under a Creative Commons license |
delete |
October 5
|
|
Category:WikiProject Media Inspection Team |
delete |
October 28
|
|
Category:Women by religion |
delete |
October 12
|
|
Category:Women recording artists |
delete.
(non-admin closure) |
October 17
|
|
Category:Women's National Basketball Association presidents |
rename |
October 21
|
|
Category:World Food Prize laureates |
delete |
October 5
|
|
Category:Wreckers (Transformers) |
delete |
October 20
|
| Xxx of the University of California, Los Angeles |
do not rename |
October 24
|