This is an archive of closed nominations for Bot Approvals Group. Active nominations are posted at Wikipedia talk:Bot Approvals Group#Requests for BAG membership.

• Earlier successful membership candidacies
• Earlier unsuccessful membership candidacies

See /Archive for the list of transcluded discussions.

Successful nominations (chronological)

• SD0001 Discussion closed 24 November 2020 by Primefac (6/0/0)
• ProcrastinatingReader Discussion closed 24 November 2020 by Primefac (7/0/0)
• Enterprisey Discussion closed 7 August 2019 by Xaosflux (14/0/0)
• TheSandDoctor Discussion closed 21 January 2019 by WJBscribe (9/0/0)
• Primefac Discussion closed 12 December 2018 by Xaosflux (17/0/0)
• Cyberpower678 Discussion closed 16 July 2017 by Xaosflux (8/0/1)
• BU Rob13 Discussion closed 3 June 2017 by Xaosflux (11/2/0)
• MusikAnimal Discussion closed 16 December 2016 by Xaosflux (20/1/0)
• HighInBC Discussion closed 9 July 2016 by Xaosflux (9/0/0)
• Addshore Discussion closed 27 January 2013 by 日本穣 (10/2/0)
• Hersfold Discussion closed 16 August 2011 by Avi (14/0/0)
• Slakr Discussion closed 3 August 2011 by Dweller (6/1/0)
• Headbomb Discussion closed 20 April 2011 by MBisanz (20/0/3)

Note: This page was not regularly updated between 2008 and 2011 and is missing entries for this period

• Hellknowz Discussion closed 19 December 2010 by MBisanz (8/0/0)
• EdoDodo Discussion closed 16 August 2010 by MBisanz (13/0/0)
• Josh Parris Discussion closed 18 February 2010 by Pakaran (8/0/0)
• Jake Wartenberg Discussion closed 2 February 2010 by Pakaran (13/0/0)
• Harej Discussion closed 5 January 2010 by Avi (20/0/0)
• Kingpin13 Discussion closed 29 July 2009 by Taxman (11/0/0)
• Jarry1250 Discussion closed 23 February 2009 by EVula (7/0/0)
• Fritzpoll Discussion closed 9 January 2009 by Kingturtle (14/0/0)
• Anomie Discussion closed 6 December 2008 by Kingturtle (10/0/0)
• Quadell Discussion closed 5 August 2008 by Daniel (15/0/0)
• Bjweeks discussion, closed 12 June 2008 by Rdsmith4 (12/0/0)
• Giggy discussion closed 20 May 2008 by Taxman (26/0/0)
• Krimpet discussion, closed 15 May 2008 by Kingturtle (9/1/0)
• Maxim discussion, closed 15 May 2008 by Kingturtle (11/1/0)
• MBisanz discussion, closed 15 May 2008 by Kingturtle (19/0/0)
• Mr.Z-man discussion, closed 15 May 2008 by Kingturtle (12/2/0)
• Soxred93 test reconfirmation vote, closed 2 May 2008 by WJBscribe at (34/1/1)
• Werdna test reconfirmation vote, closed 2 May 2008 by WJBscribe at (33/1/0)
• Cobi test reconfirmation vote, closed 27 April 2008 by WJBscribe at (43/0/0)
• Coren test reconfirmation vote, closed 27 April 2008 by WJBscribe at (23/9/2)
• OverlordQ discussion closed 8 April 2008 by ST47 (3/0/0)
• Werdna discussion closed 18 March 2008 by SQL (10/0/0)
• MaxSem discussion closed 18 March 2008 by SQL (5/0/0)
• SQL discussion closed 8 March 2008 by Martinp23 (5/0/0)
• Soxred93 discussion closed 18 February 2008 by Martinp23 (3/0/0)
• Reedy Boy discussion closed 16 February 2008 by Martinp23 (3/0/0)
• Coren discussion closed 16 February 2008 by Martinp23 (2/0/0)
• Snowolf discussion closed 16 February by Monobi (6/0/0)
• Cobi discussion closed 6 February 2008 by Tawker (13/0/0)
• User:Betacommand (2nd request) discussion closed 26 December 2007 by ST47 (was more of a discussion)
• Prior to 2008, memberships were informally managed and did not use candidate pages.

Unsuccessful nominations (chronological)

The following editors were nominated for membership in the BAG, but did not succeed:

• User:Zackmann08, consensus not reached. Closed December 14, 2018 by User:Xaosflux.
• User:Magioladitis, reconfirmation unsuccessful. Closed December 29, 2016 by User:Xaosflux.
• User:Wugapodes, consensus not reached. Closed December 26, 2016 by User:MBisanz.
• User:Cyberpower678, consensus not reached. Closed 13 January 2013 by Avraham.
• User:Rcsprinter123, consensus not reached. Closed 16 April 2012 by Avraham.
• User:Rcsprinter123, consensus not reached. Closed 23 January 2012 by MBisanz.
• User:MZMcBride, consensus not reached. Closed 15 May 2008 by Kingturtle ( talk). (12/5/1)
• Chris G, discussion closed 6 June 2008 by Taxman (7/3/0)
• User:Monobi, discussion, consensus not reached. Never closed technically, last and only comment received on 2 February 2008. (0/1/0)
• Crashdoom, withdrawn by candidate, closed 12 October 2011