It's a brilliant article that deserves Featured status. Best to give it A-Class status first. It's a little long but It covers the topic magnificently--Phoenix 15 (
Talk)17:22, 21 October 2007 (UTC)reply
Oppose - over ten paragraphs lack a single source citation, two or more such citations per paragraph is preferred. That's the only drawback I see, though.
John Carter16:34, 22 October 2007 (UTC)reply
"Society" #1, "Government" #1 (only one citation for the first sentence), Government #2, 4, and 6, "Law' #1, "Economy" all but the last paragraph lack any citations, "Class structure" the entire section lacks any citations, "Family" #3 and 4, "Language" #3, "Religion" #1 needs some source for beyond the first sentence, "Art, music and literature" #2 and 3, "Technology" lacks any, as does "Engineering", "Architecture", and "Roads", "In popular culture" needs citations, at least one probably, and "Scholarly studies" doesn't have any reference citations.
John Carter15:44, 30 October 2007 (UTC)reply
It's a brilliant article that deserves Featured status. Best to give it A-Class status first. It's a little long but It covers the topic magnificently--Phoenix 15 (
Talk)17:22, 21 October 2007 (UTC)reply
Oppose - over ten paragraphs lack a single source citation, two or more such citations per paragraph is preferred. That's the only drawback I see, though.
John Carter16:34, 22 October 2007 (UTC)reply
"Society" #1, "Government" #1 (only one citation for the first sentence), Government #2, 4, and 6, "Law' #1, "Economy" all but the last paragraph lack any citations, "Class structure" the entire section lacks any citations, "Family" #3 and 4, "Language" #3, "Religion" #1 needs some source for beyond the first sentence, "Art, music and literature" #2 and 3, "Technology" lacks any, as does "Engineering", "Architecture", and "Roads", "In popular culture" needs citations, at least one probably, and "Scholarly studies" doesn't have any reference citations.
John Carter15:44, 30 October 2007 (UTC)reply