Case Closed on 10 January 2005
Arbitrators should vote for or against each point or abstain.
Conditional votes for or against and abstentions should be explained by the Arbitrator in parenthesis after his time-stamped signature. For example, an Arbitrator can state that he would only favor a particular remedy based on whether or not another remedy/remedies were enacted.
1) Alberuni is banned from editing articles which relate to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict pending resolution of this matter. (Based on POV editing, edit warring, violations of the 3 revert rule, and personal attacks.)
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) {text of proposed principle}
1) Users must follow the three-revert rule; Articles may not be reverted more than three times in a 24 hours period except for simple vandalism.
2) Users are expected to be courteous to other users. The prinicples of wikietiquette should followed.
3) Users are expected to avoid using personal attacks.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) {text of proposed finding of fact}
1) Alberuni has violated the 3 revert rule on several occasions. 19 Nov 2004 (UTC) Black September reverted five times in 24 hours: rv Zioprop rv anon vandal rv anon parade rv anon rv anon mute. Viriditas gives two other examples. When requested to follow the rule he responded rudely [1]
2) Alberuni has been discourteous to other users, for example when requested that he comply with the 3 revert rule he responded with "get a life", when requested to review the no personal attacks policy, he responded with [2]
3) Alberuni has made personal attacks on other users [3].
4) Just after this case was brought to arbitration, Alberuni created at least twelve sock puppets [4], some with names that were designed to provoke Jewish editors (NeverAgain, Wiesenthaler) or that were themselves personal attacks (Jewjg). These sock puppets were deliberately used to further the edit wars and make personal attacks.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for three months.
1.1) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for one month.
1.2) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for one year.
2) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further two weeks.
2.1) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further one week.
2.2) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further two months.
2.3) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further one year.
3) Alberuni is placed on standard personal attack parole for up to and including two months after any bans that are imposed. If he makes any edits which are judged by an administrator to be personal attacks, then he shall be temp-banned for a short time, up to one week, and the parole shall be reset.
3.1) Alberuni is placed on standard personal attack parole indefinitely for one year after all bans that are imposed. If he makes any edits which are judged by an administrator to be personal attacks, then he shall be temp-banned for a short time of up to one week.
4) Alberuni is required to discuss all reverts on the relevant talk page, with the goal of finding mutually acceptable compromises.
5) If Alberuni can demonstrate good skill in discussion and behaviour relatively free of personal attacks, he may apply to the Arbcom to have the above restrictions reduced or lifted.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) Should Alberuni revert an article without discussion, an administrator may block him for up to 24 hours.
Four Aye votes needed to close case
Case Closed on 10 January 2005
Arbitrators should vote for or against each point or abstain.
Conditional votes for or against and abstentions should be explained by the Arbitrator in parenthesis after his time-stamped signature. For example, an Arbitrator can state that he would only favor a particular remedy based on whether or not another remedy/remedies were enacted.
1) Alberuni is banned from editing articles which relate to the Israeli-Palestinian conflict pending resolution of this matter. (Based on POV editing, edit warring, violations of the 3 revert rule, and personal attacks.)
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) {text of proposed principle}
1) Users must follow the three-revert rule; Articles may not be reverted more than three times in a 24 hours period except for simple vandalism.
2) Users are expected to be courteous to other users. The prinicples of wikietiquette should followed.
3) Users are expected to avoid using personal attacks.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) {text of proposed finding of fact}
1) Alberuni has violated the 3 revert rule on several occasions. 19 Nov 2004 (UTC) Black September reverted five times in 24 hours: rv Zioprop rv anon vandal rv anon parade rv anon rv anon mute. Viriditas gives two other examples. When requested to follow the rule he responded rudely [1]
2) Alberuni has been discourteous to other users, for example when requested that he comply with the 3 revert rule he responded with "get a life", when requested to review the no personal attacks policy, he responded with [2]
3) Alberuni has made personal attacks on other users [3].
4) Just after this case was brought to arbitration, Alberuni created at least twelve sock puppets [4], some with names that were designed to provoke Jewish editors (NeverAgain, Wiesenthaler) or that were themselves personal attacks (Jewjg). These sock puppets were deliberately used to further the edit wars and make personal attacks.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for three months.
1.1) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for one month.
1.2) For numerous violations of the 3RR, Alberuni is banned for one year.
2) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further two weeks.
2.1) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further one week.
2.2) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further two months.
2.3) For numerous personal attacks, Alberuni is banned for a further one year.
3) Alberuni is placed on standard personal attack parole for up to and including two months after any bans that are imposed. If he makes any edits which are judged by an administrator to be personal attacks, then he shall be temp-banned for a short time, up to one week, and the parole shall be reset.
3.1) Alberuni is placed on standard personal attack parole indefinitely for one year after all bans that are imposed. If he makes any edits which are judged by an administrator to be personal attacks, then he shall be temp-banned for a short time of up to one week.
4) Alberuni is required to discuss all reverts on the relevant talk page, with the goal of finding mutually acceptable compromises.
5) If Alberuni can demonstrate good skill in discussion and behaviour relatively free of personal attacks, he may apply to the Arbcom to have the above restrictions reduced or lifted.
proposed wording to be modified by Arbitrators and then voted on
1) Should Alberuni revert an article without discussion, an administrator may block him for up to 24 hours.
Four Aye votes needed to close case