This is a list of redirects that have been proposed for deletion or other action on September 7, 2016.
A one-time insult, not a notable nickname. LM2000 ( talk) 22:26, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
Implausible redirect, per consensus at Unicorn Freaks, Iron Man of the WWE, and Madame McMahon, nicknames used once are not useful redirects. LM2000 ( talk) 22:23, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
@ LM2000: consensus at the other redirects you mention is entirely irrelevant to this. This is not 'used once' it is a slogan he has pushed to sell merch and which his fans push by wearing the merch. Yet again I really doubt you looked into this and are just making malicious assumptions about anything I make you don't immediately recognize.
Pre/War/Crash/Angus/JTP this is not a WP:POLL it is "for discussion" so if you're just going to "per nom" please go away.
HHH Pedrigree this is a slogan associated with Neville through official WWE merchanise, see http://shop.wwe.com/neville-altitude-era-authentic-t-shirt/W09608.html how could you possibly argue this isn't notable?
Admins, please note that none of the 10 WP:RDELETE reasons are given here, while the WP:RKEEP reasons 3 and 5 defend this redirect's existence. Reviewing administrators: please recognize that only actual discussions form a consensus, not polling/voting, and look at more than just the numbers here. Ranze ( talk) 04:26, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Not a plausible redirect, not a real nickname. LM2000 ( talk) 22:18, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
I won't contest this. The guy has been called Big Ryck and Big Zeke so I figured noting Ezekiel begins with E the same way Ettore was is harmless. I did find some other people calling him this but probably not enough to convince you. It's not as notable a nickname as the others which I am trying to defend, even though I still maintain it is a harmless redirect to keep. Ranze ( talk) 03:02, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Not plausible redirects, not real nicknames. LM2000 ( talk) 22:11, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
Delete Per nom, sounds like a one time insult. Chris "WarMachineWildThing" Talk to me 22:41, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
@ LM2000: I get the impression that you don't spend much (any?) effort looking for sources before taking it upon yourself on your mission to dig through my edits and try to demonize them. You begin with falsehood, saying that this is not plausible (wrong, both are things Ryback has beein recurringly called) and that they are not real nicknames (also false).
Crash_Underride and HHH Pedrigree are non-neutral parties who have had past disagreements with me so I would encourage any overseeing administrators to discount their support of these falsehoods. JTP and other "per nom" folk who blindly support this falsehood, I would remind you that RFD is not a vote, you are supposed to actually discuss policy and do your own analysis. All 4 of you are now posting incorrect things.
@ AngusWOOF: thank you for honestly acknowledging that Cryback is a meme. "Traction" is a relative concept I won't quibble about, but I disagree about it being 'short-lived' considering there is still discussion of it by fans and activity in the hashtag in the present year.
We might dispute on whether they are notable enough nicknames to list on his article, but redirects have a lower burden of proof for notability than something you'd list on a page. Plausibly typos, for example, are made into redirects, but not actually mentioned on the article.
I would remind overseeing editors who might want to embrace this so-called "consensus" (it is not, I detract)
Beginning with the most notable, #Cryback is quite popular, and people still talk about on Reddit and while it did originate as an insult from Jericho used 28 June 2013, it took root and influenced articles about him:
Rybotch similarly has coverage to this day in fan discussion. Angus I'm not sure what search engine you're using to get Robotech typos, but if you Google Rybotch it's all wrestler-related I see on the first page. This nickname has stuck with him since 2012, and recurs every year since then until even now. Is it a notable enough nickname to mention on his page? That's a separate discussion. It doesn't need to be for it to be verified as a nickname associated with him to redirect to his page.
Aside from the podcast, you can see fans calling him this in comments on 5 pages worth of articles. Writers may be hesitant to say that openly out of respect or not wanting to burn bridges or future interviews. Ranze ( talk) 02:57, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
LM I notice you conveniently sneak the more notable nickname Cryback under Rybotch's entry. You want a verified YouTube video? Here you go: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHfakJwfuUE&t=1m15s Are you going to call THIS tweet "random" too? https://twitter.com/iamjericho/status/351886641301946370 Do you need more than the official YouTube channel of the WWE and the official Twitter account of Chris Jericho to convince you of the worthwhileness of Cryback? Ranze ( talk) 05:10, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
A couple more to consider:
Cryback .. Cryback just waved off his own match. Listen to the fans' reaction here, booing Cryback for doing just that.
During a match with The Miz, Ryback pulled the WWE version of boxing's famous "No mas" incident. The Big Guy quit mid-match, refusing to take any more of The Miz's kicks. That opened the door for rival Chris Jericho to start calling him "Cryback."
It is a recurring nickname repeated multiple times on 2 different programs, reported on in the news. I'd question if the nicknames that LM doesn't object to are this well-supported. Ranze ( talk) 07:22, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Relisted, see
Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2016 September 15#Internals
This is Portuguese for "idiot", I don't see how it can refer to South Korea. - Champion ( talk) ( contribs) (Formerly TheChampionMan1234) 04:41, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
This just means "other countries", even that is not a specifically Chinese concept, and even that is not a Chinese-related topic. - Champion ( talk) ( contribs) (Formerly TheChampionMan1234) 04:38, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
This is a list of redirects that have been proposed for deletion or other action on September 7, 2016.
A one-time insult, not a notable nickname. LM2000 ( talk) 22:26, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
Implausible redirect, per consensus at Unicorn Freaks, Iron Man of the WWE, and Madame McMahon, nicknames used once are not useful redirects. LM2000 ( talk) 22:23, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
@ LM2000: consensus at the other redirects you mention is entirely irrelevant to this. This is not 'used once' it is a slogan he has pushed to sell merch and which his fans push by wearing the merch. Yet again I really doubt you looked into this and are just making malicious assumptions about anything I make you don't immediately recognize.
Pre/War/Crash/Angus/JTP this is not a WP:POLL it is "for discussion" so if you're just going to "per nom" please go away.
HHH Pedrigree this is a slogan associated with Neville through official WWE merchanise, see http://shop.wwe.com/neville-altitude-era-authentic-t-shirt/W09608.html how could you possibly argue this isn't notable?
Admins, please note that none of the 10 WP:RDELETE reasons are given here, while the WP:RKEEP reasons 3 and 5 defend this redirect's existence. Reviewing administrators: please recognize that only actual discussions form a consensus, not polling/voting, and look at more than just the numbers here. Ranze ( talk) 04:26, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Not a plausible redirect, not a real nickname. LM2000 ( talk) 22:18, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
I won't contest this. The guy has been called Big Ryck and Big Zeke so I figured noting Ezekiel begins with E the same way Ettore was is harmless. I did find some other people calling him this but probably not enough to convince you. It's not as notable a nickname as the others which I am trying to defend, even though I still maintain it is a harmless redirect to keep. Ranze ( talk) 03:02, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Not plausible redirects, not real nicknames. LM2000 ( talk) 22:11, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
Delete Per nom, sounds like a one time insult. Chris "WarMachineWildThing" Talk to me 22:41, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
@ LM2000: I get the impression that you don't spend much (any?) effort looking for sources before taking it upon yourself on your mission to dig through my edits and try to demonize them. You begin with falsehood, saying that this is not plausible (wrong, both are things Ryback has beein recurringly called) and that they are not real nicknames (also false).
Crash_Underride and HHH Pedrigree are non-neutral parties who have had past disagreements with me so I would encourage any overseeing administrators to discount their support of these falsehoods. JTP and other "per nom" folk who blindly support this falsehood, I would remind you that RFD is not a vote, you are supposed to actually discuss policy and do your own analysis. All 4 of you are now posting incorrect things.
@ AngusWOOF: thank you for honestly acknowledging that Cryback is a meme. "Traction" is a relative concept I won't quibble about, but I disagree about it being 'short-lived' considering there is still discussion of it by fans and activity in the hashtag in the present year.
We might dispute on whether they are notable enough nicknames to list on his article, but redirects have a lower burden of proof for notability than something you'd list on a page. Plausibly typos, for example, are made into redirects, but not actually mentioned on the article.
I would remind overseeing editors who might want to embrace this so-called "consensus" (it is not, I detract)
Beginning with the most notable, #Cryback is quite popular, and people still talk about on Reddit and while it did originate as an insult from Jericho used 28 June 2013, it took root and influenced articles about him:
Rybotch similarly has coverage to this day in fan discussion. Angus I'm not sure what search engine you're using to get Robotech typos, but if you Google Rybotch it's all wrestler-related I see on the first page. This nickname has stuck with him since 2012, and recurs every year since then until even now. Is it a notable enough nickname to mention on his page? That's a separate discussion. It doesn't need to be for it to be verified as a nickname associated with him to redirect to his page.
Aside from the podcast, you can see fans calling him this in comments on 5 pages worth of articles. Writers may be hesitant to say that openly out of respect or not wanting to burn bridges or future interviews. Ranze ( talk) 02:57, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
LM I notice you conveniently sneak the more notable nickname Cryback under Rybotch's entry. You want a verified YouTube video? Here you go: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHfakJwfuUE&t=1m15s Are you going to call THIS tweet "random" too? https://twitter.com/iamjericho/status/351886641301946370 Do you need more than the official YouTube channel of the WWE and the official Twitter account of Chris Jericho to convince you of the worthwhileness of Cryback? Ranze ( talk) 05:10, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
A couple more to consider:
Cryback .. Cryback just waved off his own match. Listen to the fans' reaction here, booing Cryback for doing just that.
During a match with The Miz, Ryback pulled the WWE version of boxing's famous "No mas" incident. The Big Guy quit mid-match, refusing to take any more of The Miz's kicks. That opened the door for rival Chris Jericho to start calling him "Cryback."
It is a recurring nickname repeated multiple times on 2 different programs, reported on in the news. I'd question if the nicknames that LM doesn't object to are this well-supported. Ranze ( talk) 07:22, 9 September 2016 (UTC)
Relisted, see
Wikipedia:Redirects for discussion/Log/2016 September 15#Internals
This is Portuguese for "idiot", I don't see how it can refer to South Korea. - Champion ( talk) ( contribs) (Formerly TheChampionMan1234) 04:41, 7 September 2016 (UTC)
This just means "other countries", even that is not a specifically Chinese concept, and even that is not a Chinese-related topic. - Champion ( talk) ( contribs) (Formerly TheChampionMan1234) 04:38, 7 September 2016 (UTC)