Toolbox |
---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because…I think it would make a good candidate for Feature Article status.
In the interests of full disclosure: I did no editing work on this article whatsoever, I just came across it. I am not a practicing Catholic, but I was raised Catholic and I'm familiar with the doctrine and history discussed in the article. The article does focus on exploring the topic from what I would describe as traditional perspectives, tempered with some limited discussion of liberal views.
What I hope to get from peer review are some comments and questions from reviewers who are not familiar with the topic. I think the 'outsider' perspective would help me to tweak the article to improve an overall NPOV examination of the topic. Any and all suggestions that might help towards FA consideration would be greatly appreciated.
The topic might seem like an obscure one to non-Catholics, but Mariology has a key role in Catholic culture in European history and beyond.
Thanks, OttawaAC ( talk) 03:18, 21 October 2011 (UTC)
Comments from Adjwilley
Anyway, I am pretty low on time here, and I didn't read the whole article, but these are some of the problems I found in a half hour. As for my background, I am not catholic, but have been editing on some articles related to Mormonism, one of which is listed below. I would greatly appreciate it if you would do a quick review of that one. -- Adjwilley ( talk) 02:14, 25 October 2011 (UTC)
Toolbox |
---|
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because…I think it would make a good candidate for Feature Article status.
In the interests of full disclosure: I did no editing work on this article whatsoever, I just came across it. I am not a practicing Catholic, but I was raised Catholic and I'm familiar with the doctrine and history discussed in the article. The article does focus on exploring the topic from what I would describe as traditional perspectives, tempered with some limited discussion of liberal views.
What I hope to get from peer review are some comments and questions from reviewers who are not familiar with the topic. I think the 'outsider' perspective would help me to tweak the article to improve an overall NPOV examination of the topic. Any and all suggestions that might help towards FA consideration would be greatly appreciated.
The topic might seem like an obscure one to non-Catholics, but Mariology has a key role in Catholic culture in European history and beyond.
Thanks, OttawaAC ( talk) 03:18, 21 October 2011 (UTC)
Comments from Adjwilley
Anyway, I am pretty low on time here, and I didn't read the whole article, but these are some of the problems I found in a half hour. As for my background, I am not catholic, but have been editing on some articles related to Mormonism, one of which is listed below. I would greatly appreciate it if you would do a quick review of that one. -- Adjwilley ( talk) 02:14, 25 October 2011 (UTC)