This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I need help determining how to divide the article. I was told to look at artilces like
List of Aria (manga) soundtracks and that helped to some extent, but the problem is the
Popotan franchise is much more diverse; first off the visual novel has multiple CDs for it and released as different types. Then there is a radio drama as well (and discography and albums doesn't appear to have a place for radio dramas, even ones with lots of music). Also there is one release that appears to be for the all three major media formats: visual novel, anime and radio drama so I'm not sure where that should go. Finally, a number of the songs were released in generally unrelated band albums for
Under17 which charted so I don't know if and how to reference them, especially as the songs were released on multiple Popotan CDs themselves. Oh and also I'm not sure if I need/should list CD soundtracks that come with games and if {{
Cite video game}} can be used to cite pre-order items for 1st print runs.
Should the article be split and can it be justified being split?
Thanks, 陣 内 Jinnai 23:38, 20 August 2009 (UTC)
I don't see a reason for a split. There are no length issues. When List of One Piece video games was a FLC, it was required to add a bit of reception into the lead. Maybe something similar could be done here like adding surveys in which the CDs were featured such as the ones from Oricon. Tintor2 ( talk) 01:29, 23 August 2009 (UTC)
(outdent)Looking at that maybe having the Under17 live tour and best of albums put into a legacy section might be best. 陣 内 Jinnai 21:10, 26 August 2009 (UTC)
Comment: Well it looks as good as it can be knowing how limited the materials are. Concerning the Drama CDs, i agree that they could be merged with the rest of the CDs but it should not systematically done so. The main point is soundtracks are byproducts of a piece of work, an anime or a video game while Drama CDs are piece of works by themselves. If the Drama CDs are few and not much notable merging with soundtracks is ok but when there are a lot of Drama CDs and most ranked in charts keeping them apart should be discussed. Facepalm fact is fansubbers started to fansub Drama CDs so having summaries for Drama CDs may become in the future (yea, a variant of anime episode list or manga chapters list). -- KrebMarkt 20:19, 27 August 2009 (UTC)
This peer review discussion has been closed.
I've listed this article for peer review because I need help determining how to divide the article. I was told to look at artilces like
List of Aria (manga) soundtracks and that helped to some extent, but the problem is the
Popotan franchise is much more diverse; first off the visual novel has multiple CDs for it and released as different types. Then there is a radio drama as well (and discography and albums doesn't appear to have a place for radio dramas, even ones with lots of music). Also there is one release that appears to be for the all three major media formats: visual novel, anime and radio drama so I'm not sure where that should go. Finally, a number of the songs were released in generally unrelated band albums for
Under17 which charted so I don't know if and how to reference them, especially as the songs were released on multiple Popotan CDs themselves. Oh and also I'm not sure if I need/should list CD soundtracks that come with games and if {{
Cite video game}} can be used to cite pre-order items for 1st print runs.
Should the article be split and can it be justified being split?
Thanks, 陣 内 Jinnai 23:38, 20 August 2009 (UTC)
I don't see a reason for a split. There are no length issues. When List of One Piece video games was a FLC, it was required to add a bit of reception into the lead. Maybe something similar could be done here like adding surveys in which the CDs were featured such as the ones from Oricon. Tintor2 ( talk) 01:29, 23 August 2009 (UTC)
(outdent)Looking at that maybe having the Under17 live tour and best of albums put into a legacy section might be best. 陣 内 Jinnai 21:10, 26 August 2009 (UTC)
Comment: Well it looks as good as it can be knowing how limited the materials are. Concerning the Drama CDs, i agree that they could be merged with the rest of the CDs but it should not systematically done so. The main point is soundtracks are byproducts of a piece of work, an anime or a video game while Drama CDs are piece of works by themselves. If the Drama CDs are few and not much notable merging with soundtracks is ok but when there are a lot of Drama CDs and most ranked in charts keeping them apart should be discussed. Facepalm fact is fansubbers started to fansub Drama CDs so having summaries for Drama CDs may become in the future (yea, a variant of anime episode list or manga chapters list). -- KrebMarkt 20:19, 27 August 2009 (UTC)