AgreeThe image seems not to be 100% accurate and it is from the Brands of the World
[1] website which seems not to care of how the images are sourced. We don't know if it is home made or how accurate it is. Considering the replacement image is from an official source, getting rid of this one makes great sense. If it will make
ChrisRuvolo happy, we have seen a copy of the NBC Logo Legal Usage Guidelines and this image doesn't conform to them! --
I Hate CAPTCHAS (
talk)
18:49, 20 February 2008 (UTC)reply
Keep and put back in articles -- There is a problem with the newly uploaded logo,
Image:NBC Stacked Logo Legal Identity.svg. It does not have a
verifiable source provided, and no provenance. As for accuracy, the original was updated to have the correct colors some time ago. What is the inaccuracy objection of the original? Also, the usual way to deal with this kind of thing is to upload a new version under the old file name. The
Image:NBC logo.svg image was not orphaned until it was replaced by this other image in articles. Regardless of the decision about which logo image to keep, i agree which ever ends up being orphaned should be deleted. --
ChrisRuvolo (
t)
18:45, 18 February 2008 (UTC)reply
We supplied a source. I am not going to be posting copies of internal NBC documents on the web just so you can have a look at them. The source for the replacement to this inaccurate image is the NBC Logo Legal Usage Guidelines, which is an internal NBC document.
Also We Brief (
talk)
20:31, 18 February 2008 (UTC)reply
AgreeThe image seems not to be 100% accurate and it is from the Brands of the World
[1] website which seems not to care of how the images are sourced. We don't know if it is home made or how accurate it is. Considering the replacement image is from an official source, getting rid of this one makes great sense. If it will make
ChrisRuvolo happy, we have seen a copy of the NBC Logo Legal Usage Guidelines and this image doesn't conform to them! --
I Hate CAPTCHAS (
talk)
18:49, 20 February 2008 (UTC)reply
Keep and put back in articles -- There is a problem with the newly uploaded logo,
Image:NBC Stacked Logo Legal Identity.svg. It does not have a
verifiable source provided, and no provenance. As for accuracy, the original was updated to have the correct colors some time ago. What is the inaccuracy objection of the original? Also, the usual way to deal with this kind of thing is to upload a new version under the old file name. The
Image:NBC logo.svg image was not orphaned until it was replaced by this other image in articles. Regardless of the decision about which logo image to keep, i agree which ever ends up being orphaned should be deleted. --
ChrisRuvolo (
t)
18:45, 18 February 2008 (UTC)reply
We supplied a source. I am not going to be posting copies of internal NBC documents on the web just so you can have a look at them. The source for the replacement to this inaccurate image is the NBC Logo Legal Usage Guidelines, which is an internal NBC document.
Also We Brief (
talk)
20:31, 18 February 2008 (UTC)reply